If there is one thing that is absolutely essential to life, it is water. Humans are made up of about sixty percent water, the Earth’s surface is about seventy percent water, and one hundred percent of all living things need water to survive. However, less than one percent of Earth’s water is potable.
Nowadays, our infrastructure is reliable enough that we don’t often think about the scarcity of drinking water. The Ancient Greeks and Romans, on the other hand, did not benefit from such inventions as electricity, which allows us to pump water directly into our homes. As a result, ancient philosophers spent a great deal of time researching water sources and determining which ones were safe to drink and which were not.
Qualities of Water
In order to determine which water was safest to drink, and also which would taste the best, ancient philosophers divided water into 3 different categories: weight, temperature, and clarity.
Light vs Heavy
The first of these was light versus heavy water. There is much debate as to exactly what this means. Some classicists believe that it simply refers to water’s weight, while others argue that it has more to do with its viscosity. In either case, ancient philosophers believed that heavy water contained more elements, making it less pure and therefore less healthy. This belief stems from pre-Socratic teachings that divide the world into atoms and void, with atoms making up all tangible matter and void being the absence of matter. In the case of water, heaviness meant a high atomic content, whereas lightness could be attributed to the presence of void, having neither mass nor viscosity.
Hot vs Cold
Ancient philosophers also categorized water by its temperature. Vitruvius maintained that water is naturally cold, the exception being water that comes from hot springs. Water from hot springs, he argued, often carried an unpleasant taste due to the flowing water picking up elements from the ground, making the water heavier. He also argued that artificially hot water was equally unhealthy. Hippocrates explained the concept of evaporation by saying that the sun attracts light water, but will leave heavy water behind. This is visibly evident if you leave a cup of salt water to evaporate—the water is gone, and the elements (in this case salt) are left behind. Because evaporation leaves behind elements while removing water, ancient philosophers like Vitruvius and Hippocrates viewed artificially hot water as unhealthy.
Clear vs Unclear
Finally, ancient philosophers categorized water by its visible clarity. Again, philosophers explained the different levels of clarity in water by the amount of matter contained in it. If water contained more elements, it would become murky. If it had fewer elements, that space was filled by void. Because void is not visible, water with fewer elements would be clear. Ultimately, the classification of water as clear or unclear is little more than a visible metric of the elemental content of the water. Clear water is healthy because it is light and contains fewer elements, murky water contains more elements and is heavy, making it unhealthy.
Types of Water
Rain Water
Spring Water
Well Water
Surface Water
Rain Water
Spring water was generally considered to be the healthiest and tastiest type of water. While philosophers like Hippocrates and Vitruvius thought water from hot springs was heavy and unclear, containing small particles of rock, water from cold springs was considered very healthy. The location of the spring was also a large factor. Vitruvius argued that mountain springs are superior to springs from flat land because the latter are exposed to more sunlight. Because he believed that the sun attracted the lightest water, leaving only heavy water behind, springs in flat areas that are exposed to more sunlight produce heavier water. He also claimed that northern springs are superior to springs from the other cardinal directions, though it is unclear why. Similarly, Hippocrates claimed that springs to the east are best, with northern springs coming in second. These were followed by western springs, with southern springs being the worst.
Spring Water
Hippocrates explained the concept of evaporation by saying that the sun attracts light water, but will leave heavy water behind. This is visibly evident if you leave a cup of salt water to evaporate—the water is gone, and the elements (in this case salt) are left behind. For this reason, he and other ancient philosophers considered rainwater to be very healthy, although not as tasty as spring water. They attributed the taste of water to certain minerals picked up when it flowed through earth from springs. Although too many minerals would make the water heavy, unclear, and unhealthy, limited minerals gave water its flavor. This is why some springs were more preferable than others. Rain water, being void of most elements, was lacking in taste, and as such was considered a good second option if cold spring water were not available.
Well Water
Most ancient philosophers agreed that well water is a good alternative to spring water. Hippocrates valued water that remained cool in the summer and warm in the winter, relative to other kinds of water. Well water is deep enough that its temperature does not fluctuate as much as surface water or water stored in cisterns. However, this is really only true of water at the bottom of the well, as water at the surface is warmed by the sun and cooled by winter air temperatures. If you have ever swam in a lake, you may have noticed that the water around your feet felt colder than the water at the surface. Similarly, in winter it is only a few inches on the surface of the lake that actually freeze. Hippocrates observed these same phenomena in wells, and concluded that the deeper well water would be best for drinking. Other philosophers, such as Celsus, denounced well water as being the worst source of drinking water due to its static nature, and its accumulation of algae.
Surface Water
Surface water was generally considered to be the worst source of drinking water by ancient philosophers. Due to its stagnant nature, it is most likely to accumulate algae and host other living organisms. Hippocrates argued that surface water, often being the basin of a watershed, or the convergence of several different water sources, would be dominated by the strongest of those sources. Because the strongest tasting sources of water were full of elements, this meant that surface water was considered heavy and unclear. Vitruvius agreed with this sentiment, also arguing that rivers imbibe whatever soil they run through. Therefore, rivers flowing into a basin could be tainted, potentially with lethal effect. Galen, well known for his medical contributions to the ancient world, simply said not to drink water from pools, puddles, or marshes.
When it comes to civil engineering, the Primary Source of drinking water is usually Spring water. Settlements were often planned around a source of Spring water due to it's relative safety and superiority in taste compared to other forms or water. Specifically, Vitruvius explains that Mountains with Northern exposure have the best springs due to protection from evaporation and that Springs near metal mines are harmful due to contamination. If Spring water is not an option, then wells are used to acces surface water.
However, a growing civilization could not rely on one source of water. The first reason is due to nature's unpredictability. For example, if there is a drought - especially in the dry summers - spring water may be lacking. In such cases, water of less quality, such as rain water or surface water is then relied on. This is why many civilizations store rain water in cisterns for emergencies. The second is due to the sheer size of a city. In these cases, water is drawn from several sources and delegated due to quality ratings. Spring water is used from drinking, while surface or rain water is used for baths and the staging of ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY mock naval battles.
Infrastructure
The 3 main water infrastructure that we see in ancient Greek and Roman history are wells, cisterns, and aqueducts.
Wells
Aqueducts
Cisterns
Wells
Wells are structures built to draw water from an underground source, specifically surface water. Wells are created when nearby springs are not available, because surface water is second to spring water due. They are often created near sanctuaries and on hilltops to honor deities. However, choosing the location requires proper research.
In Vitruvius, we learn about choosing the best location for a well. We are taught to dig where water vapor rises from the ground and where vegetation is found. Further tests, such as a bowl condensation test, was used to ensure that enough vapor rises from this area to indicate a body of water lies beneath
Additionally, the ground itself mattered. Vitruvius explains that caly and gravel provided water with a Poor taste, that pebbles create a better taste, and that black earth has the best taste.
Once a well is constructed, the Ktesibius pump was used to draw water up from the well. This pump was invented by Greek engineer Ktesibios and was strong enough to not only produce jets of water, but also help lift the water up from the wells.
Cisterns
Cisterns are waterproof reservoirs built to store water, usually rainwater. However, some also store water that's been transported using an aqueduct system. Most are built underground and can span vast areas of land.
The cistern is a paradox. Although rainwater is seen as the best water due to its purity, cistern water is the least desirable, because it is even more stale than surface water. This is because the walls of a cistern can become covered in mold, and bacteria is given the chance to grow in such conditions. However, many cisterns had sand purification to filter the wate rbeing stored.
Most philosophers such as Aristotle advise that cistern water should only be consumed as a last resort due to its staleness. In many civilizations, the cistern is used as a backup water supply when no other source is available.
Aqueducts
The roman aqueducts consists of a series of channels that hesavily relied on gravity to transport from away location into the city. They heavily drew from spring water sources, but also drew from alternative sources for-non-consumption purposes. If there were hills between the city and the source, subterranean channels would be dug.
Once the water passes through the filtration (discussed later) system and reaches the city, it is stored in a central reservoir (cistern). Then it is diverged to three destinations: Basins and fountains, baths, private houses.
The best water was used for consumption, while surface water may have been used for bathing.
Susceptible to mold, these aqueducts required consistent upkeep and ventillation.
Upkeep
Infrastructure designed to contain and transport water required intensive upkeep.
Due to the staleness of cistern water and the presence of mold, aqueducts, cisterns, and wells required intense upkeep. To account for this, these structures were designed so that the mold contamination level could be not only monitored, but also cleaned. Line-inspectors were able to enter the structure through channels and ducts. Some of these shafts were also vertical, serving as vents for the reservoir. This vertical ventillation was also meant to air out the space and prevent mold build-up. The task of cleaning the structure's walls itself was often delegated to the slaves, because it required large scale labor.
When thinking back on ancient technology, we often fail to realize just how many advanced discoveries were present. If we look at a modern water purification center, our water is intensively treated with chemicals in order to achieve a potability that is up to our health standards. However, water has always been put through purification systems, even though the ancient systems did not use chemical treatments like the ones we have implemented.
Boiling is often thought of as the main way to filter water, but it was actually paired with many other methods of water purification. The main water purification methods seen before the 1700s were Gravel and Sand filtration, Coagulation, and Sieving.
Gravel and sand treatment involved running the water through sands to clear it out and remove debris/unwanted particles.
Coagulation involved putting an element into the water that would then bond with the unwanted elements, bringing them all to the bottom of the container, so that the water becomes clearer. Using herbs and other similar elements can also seen as coagulation.
The third method, sieving, is similar to what we think of today when buying physical water filters: the water is passed through a cloth in order to remove the unwanted particles by sifting them out.
Filters
The 3 main filtration methods we see in antiquity are Gravel and Sand Filtration, Coagulation, and Sieving.
Cistern Sandy Filters in Phaistos palace
Many ancient societies were known to use sand when filtering their water. Many documents show that in ancient Indian and Egyptian societies, running water through sand or gravel was used as a method of filtration. This technology is nearly 3,500 years old.
In many cisterns, this filtration method can also be seen, paired with the reoccuring physical upkeep of the cistern. Specifically, the Greeks used sedimentation tanks to suspend and eliminate purities from the waters before storing it in Cysterns.
Similarly, the Mayans are know have had complex a sand filtration system for their water that combined/layered many different stones/elements, including limestone and quartz. (coagulation and sand)
a) Egyptian Water Clarification Device
Egyptians are known to have used the principle of coagulation sometime around 1500 BC. They did this by adding a chemical alum to the impure water. The alum then bonded with any suspended particles and sinks them to the bottom of the container. This water is then further boiled, filtered, and consumed as needed. (coagulation)
Egyptians were also known to use natural herbs, such as Amla and Vetiver to purify their water. Similar to the mayans, they also used stones such as quartz crystals, garnet and pearls for water as well. (coagulation)
Hippocratic Sleeve (500BC)
Greek physician hippocrates Hippocrates is not only known for medicine, but also for creating the Hippocrates Sleeve. The hippocratic sleeve is a cloth bag used to filter boiling water poured into it by removing impurities. This is one ancient application of sieving water.
As we know, even the best filtration methods cannot prevent disease. It is a part of life, and our societies have encountered it in many forms. Here, we will discuss water-born diseases.
Though philosophers like Vitruvius and Varro understood that water often contained foreign pathogens, the concept of germs wasn't as we know it today.
Many public facilities lacked running water, and citizens often frequented public baths that were not cleaned as frequently as we would see today.
In antiquity, there have been many recorded outbreaks of plagues: Typhoid, Malaria, Scurvy (Gum Disease), Smallpox (Athenian Plague), and Hydrophobia (Rabies) are some of the min water-borne diseases that have been documented by medics such as Hippocrates.
Not only did migration into urban environments and the the increasing urban population contribute to these outbreaks, but so did the contamination of sewage in drinking waters and the popularity of communal bathing
In many cases, sewage was dumped into rivers. Specifically, if we focus on the troops stationed at the Tiber River, it was known that they would constantly fall sick due to theriver water. Eventually, they had to frequently move to different camps in order to give the water time to filter itself.
Additionally, though water may carry disease, it was also known to have healing properties. Many diseases were treated with baths, whether communal or in hot springs. For example, a symptom of Hydrophobia (rabies) is the fear of water. However, someone with Hydrophobia maybe advised to enter the communal bath in order to "face their fear" of water. This led to further contamination of the water and spreading of disease.
Conclusion
Through examining these different aspects of water management in antiquity, we see not only the importance of sourcing water, but also of storage, filtration, upkeep, and an awareness water-born disease and their causes/spread. Though our society has advance much further, it is only due to the advancements of the past.
Weight and Mass
Ancient philosophers placed a great amount of emphasis on whether water was “heavy” or “light.” Although this does not necessarily mean weight, most classicists agree that it is related to the number of elements in the water. For our purposes, we assumed that more elements means greater mass, and measured the weight of different water samples to determine if there is legitimacy to the theory that water can be “heavy” or “light.”
Abdrbba, M. O. M. Water supply systems in Cyrenaica during the greek and roman periods: Cyrene in context: Libyan studies. Cambridge Core, 2019
This texts went in-depth to explain the functionalities of cisterns and their upkeep. We got to further see it in it's different forms and functinonalities, rather than the main image of a singular underground chamber.
Adams, Charles Darwin. The Genuine Works of Hippocrates. Hippocrates. Dover, 1868.
Hippocrates provided perspective on the health affects of water, as well as his further classifications of which water is best for consumption. We were able to compare and contrast him with other philosophers taking on a similar challenge. We also contrasted it with the Watery World source to further simplify water into simpler categories and move past inconsistencies.
Ahmed, A. T., El Gohary, F., Tzanakakis, V. A., & Angelakis, A. N. (2020, November 23). Egyptian and Greek water cultures and hydro-technologies in ancient times. MDPI. Retrieved December 19, 2022, from https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/12/22/9760
This source went in-depth into filtration. It was a source found after the presentation that really gave insight on, not only acient greek and roman filtration technologies, but also those of other cultures as well, such and the Egyptians and Minoans.
Irby, Georgia L. Conceptions of the Watery World in Greco-Roman Antiquity. Bloomsbury, 2022.
This book's Water, Health, and Disease chapter gave an indepth overview of water-borne disease and the consequential effects of water contamination. We got to see the both the positive and negative sides of water upkeep.
Spencer, W.G. De Medicina. Celsus. Harvard University Press, 1971 (Republication of the 1935 edition).
This source provided details on the health benefits of water, as well as the negative consequences of bad water.
Van Tilburg, C. "Greek and Roman Ideas about Healthy Drinking-water in Theory and Practice." Eä Journal 5 (2013): 1-30.
This article was or main introduction into the world of water management in antiquity. We found most of the main classifications of water. there are perspectives from many different philosophers that we were able to gain an overview of before diving into each individual philosopher's perspectives. Additionally, we had an idea of what water structures to start researching and looking into.
Staff, E. W. L. V. (2021, October 1). The evolution of Water Filtration Systems. EcoWater Systems Las Vegas. Retrieved December 19, 2022, from https://www.lvecowater.com/water-purification/evolution-water-filtration-systems/
Here, we got an in-depth description of the Egyptian methods of water filtration using alum. We also looked into the herbs they used, as well as what the Romans may have used in terms of herbs and elements/stones.
The history of Clean Water: Filtration Systems through the years. Kinetico Quality Water. (2022, March 23). Retrieved December 19, 2022, from https://www.kineticotucson.com/blog/the-history-of-clean-water-filtration-systems-through-the-years/
Here we got an in-depth description of the Hippocratic sleeve and its usage in antiquity.
Sürmelihindi, G., Passchier, C. W., Baykan, O. N., Spötl, C., & Kessener, P.. Environmental and depositional controls on laminated freshwater carbonates: An example from the roman aqueduct of Patara, Turkey. Palaeogeography, 2013
Here, we saw the aqueduct in depth with maps and details on both location and construction. We saw the aqueduct structure, it's span, and it's upkeep. The diagrams were more helpful than anything, because they added images to the descriptions.
Vitruvius, and Morris Hicky Morgan. The Ten Books On Architecture. Dover, 1914.
Vitruvius gave very in depth guidance on why water infrastructre is important. From city infrastructure to nature causes, he dives into a little bit of each aspect and shows why each step in water sourcing matters. The forming of civilizations around spring and other water sources, as well as what happens when backups are needed is very insightful.
Water treatment in history. Association of Water Technologies. (n.d.). Retrieved December 19, 2022, from https://www.awt.org/resources/seed-program/water-careers/water-treatment-in-history/
Through this source, we read in-depth about aqueduct upkeep. How inspections were handled, ventilation, and the manual labour needed for upkeep. We used this as we dived into filtration.