How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a big, universal supply of flat 12x16-inch parchment sheets that fit standard half sheet pans and work in a regular oven, air fryer basket or toaster oven, choose AMFOCUS 400; if you need a liner kit built specifically around a Ninja air fryer toaster oven and you want reusable mats mixed in with disposables, choose MMH 154PCs.
• AMFOCUS 400 — biggest strength: 400 identical pre-cut 12"x16" unbleached sheets that lie flat, so you never measure, cut or fight a curling roll again.
• AMFOCUS 400 — biggest trade-off: every sheet is the same large rectangle, so it's oversized for small air fryer baskets and needs trimming there.
• MMH 154PCs — biggest strength: a mixed kit — 100 plain sheets, 50 perforated sheets and 4 reusable mats — sized to sit inside a Ninja SP151 air fryer toaster oven.
• MMH 154PCs — biggest trade-off: it's built around one oven family, so the fit is less universal than a plain rectangular sheet.
• Who each pick is for: AMFOCUS 400 for the home baker running trays of cookies, macarons and pizza on sheet pans. MMH 154PCs for the Ninja SP151 owner who air fries and bakes in the same countertop machine.
The AMFOCUS 400 is a straightforward idea executed at scale: 400 sheets of unbleached wood-pulp parchment, each pre-cut to 12 by 16 inches, packed flat instead of rolled. That flatness matters more than it sounds. Rolled parchment curls, and a curling sheet on a hot tray is a fight you don't want mid-bake. These come out of the pack ready to lay down. The material is food-grade, waterproof and oil-resistant, and it's rated to 450°F — above what most cookie, cake and bread recipes call for. There's no greasing step, nothing sticks, and when you're done you lift the sheet and toss it. No scrubbing sticky dough off a tray.
For air fryer cookies specifically, this is the sheet you'd use when your "air fryer" is really a half sheet pan running in a full-size oven, or when you're baking in batches and want a fresh liner under each round without stopping to wash anything. It's also the pick for anyone who bakes a lot: macarons, cupcakes, pizza, hot sandwiches, even gift wrapping. Four hundred sheets is a genuinely long runway.
One safety note straight from the specs: keep the paper on the bottom of the tray, press it down with enough food, and never run it in the oven without food on top of it.
MMH 154PCs: Who It's For
The MMH 154PCs is the opposite approach — not one sheet size for everything, but a kit tuned to a specific machine. It's designed to be compatible with the Ninja SP151 air fryer toaster oven, and the contents reflect that: 100 disposable parchment sheets, 50 disposable sheets with holes, and 4 reusable mats. The perforated sheets are the interesting part for air frying, because holes let hot air move through instead of trapping it under a solid liner. The plain sheets suit baking cookies, dough, croissants, pizza crusts and pies. The four reusable mats are coated with Teflon and rated to 500°F, versus 450°F for the paper.
The materials are food-grade and unbleached, with no dyes, and the mats are described as BPA and PFOA free. Nothing here is supposed to change how your food tastes.
This is the set for the person whose countertop oven is their main oven. You air fry, you toast, you bake cookies in the same box, and you want liners that already fit it instead of ones you adapt. The mix of plain, perforated and reusable gives you a liner for basically any job without buying three separate products.
Who should skip it? If your oven isn't in the Ninja SP151 family, the fit advantage evaporates and you're paying for compatibility you can't use. And if you bake on full-size half sheet pans, these liners simply aren't the right footprint.
Same safety cautions apply: don't run the paper during preheat, keep enough food on the liner so it doesn't touch the heating element, keep the reusable mat off direct contact with heating elements or open flames, and rinse the mat with water before its first use.
• Best for sheer quantity → AMFOCUS 400. Four hundred sheets in one pack versus 154 total pieces.
• Best for a Ninja SP151 toaster oven → MMH 154PCs. The whole kit is sized for that machine.
• Best for standard half sheet pans → AMFOCUS 400. The 12"x16" cut is the point.
• Best for air frying with airflow in mind → MMH 154PCs. The 50 perforated sheets let air through.
• Best if you want reusable options → MMH 154PCs. Four Teflon-coated mats rated to 500°F.
• Best if you want zero washing up, period → AMFOCUS 400. Every sheet is disposable and non-stick.
• Best for macarons and delicate bakes → AMFOCUS 400. Flat, consistent sheets make even piping rows easier.
• Best for a mixed cooking routine in one small oven → MMH 154PCs. Plain, perforated and reusable covers more jobs.
If I were buying for a normal home kitchen that bakes cookies on sheet pans and occasionally uses an air fryer or toaster oven, I'd take the AMFOCUS 400. In my opinion the flat 12"x16" cut, the 400-sheet count and the 450°F rating cover the widest range of everyday baking with the least fuss, and disposability means cleanup is basically free. I'd only switch to the MMH 154PCs if a Ninja SP151 air fryer toaster oven were my main cooking appliance — in that case the fitted liners, perforated sheets and four reusable mats are the smarter kit. Check the current price on Amazon for both before deciding, since value depends on what you're paying today.
how to air fryer cookies
Line your basket or tray with a sheet of parchment first — AMFOCUS 400 sheets work if trimmed to fit, while the MMH perforated sheets suit a Ninja SP151 directly. Keep the paper flat on the bottom, press it down with the dough, and never run it during preheat or without food on top. Bake in small batches so air can circulate.
how to air fry cookies pillsbury
Refrigerated cookie dough goes straight from the fridge onto a lined tray or basket — no greasing needed with either product. Space the dough pieces apart so they don't merge as they spread, and keep the liner pressed flat under them. A perforated MMH sheet helps airflow around the cookies in a toaster-oven style air fryer.
how to air fry cookies dough
Any cookie dough works the same way: portion it, set the pieces on a non-stick liner, and leave room between them. Both liners here are oil-resistant and waterproof, so dough won't soak through. Stick to the 450°F paper limit, or 500°F if you're using one of the MMH reusable mats.
how to air fry cookies from frozen
Frozen dough needs a slightly lower temperature and a bit more time so the middle cooks through before the edges catch. Put the frozen portions on a flat liner — AMFOCUS paper or an MMH sheet — and don't crowd them. Keep food on the liner at all times so the paper can't lift into the heating element.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: MMH 154PCs vs Ketofa Air Fryer Replacement: Air Fryer, air fryer cookies, MMH Air Fryer Liners vs Pro Bamboo Kitchen 10PCS: Air Fryer