How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-06 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR — biggest strength: Premium active noise cancellation with dual noise sensor technology, a 40mm dynamic driver, a dedicated ULT bass button, and up to 30 hours of battery (50 hours with ANC off).
• Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR — biggest trade-off: It's a certified refurbished unit with a 90-day limited warranty rather than a new-in-box purchase, and it has no headphone jack.
• SOAR Collegiate Active — biggest strength: New condition with a 1-year manufacturer warranty, Bluetooth 5.3, up to 40 hours of playtime, and wired or wireless listening.
• SOAR Collegiate Active — biggest trade-off: Smaller 32mm drivers and fewer advanced sound-shaping features, so it's a simpler audio experience than the Sony.
• Who each pick is for: The Sony suits listeners who prioritize noise cancelling performance and bass depth; the SOAR suits fans who want a new, comfortable, team-themed pair with a longer warranty and don't need premium tuning.
The Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR is built around one idea: making noise disappear so the music takes over. Sony's active noise cancellation here uses dual noise sensor technology, which is designed to read external sound and cancel it out. On a plane, a bus, or in a busy open office, that's the feature that matters most. The 40mm dynamic driver covers a 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz frequency range, and the ULT button adds two bass modes — one for punchy, danceable low end and one for a deeper, more relaxed bass boost. For anyone chasing that physical, chest-thumping feel in their music, this is the headphone's whole personality.
Comfort and battery are the other two pillars. The ear cushions use a thermo-foaming process that molds to your head for a wrinkle-free, over-ear fit, and the whole unit weighs 8.96 ounces. Battery life runs up to 30 hours, and a 3-minute charge adds roughly 90 minutes of playback — genuinely useful when you're about to walk out the door. Turn ANC off and you can stretch it toward 50 hours. Controls are touch-based for media and calls, and Bluetooth 5.2 holds a connection up to about 10 meters.
Who should buy it? Audiophiles who want deep, adjustable bass, strong noise cancelling, and long battery life, and who are comfortable buying a certified refurbished unit that ships with essential components and a 90-day warranty. Who should skip it? Anyone who insists on new-in-box condition, wants a longer warranty, or needs a wired 3.5mm option — this model has no headphone jack. If that matters, look elsewhere.
The SOAR Collegiate Active takes a different approach. This is a licensed collegiate sports headphone, finished in team colors, aimed at fans who want their gear to match their Saturday. The core spec is active noise cancellation, positioned to cut crowd noise, traffic, or bar chatter so you can follow commentary or music. It runs Bluetooth 5.3, the newer standard of the two here, and recharges fully in just 1–2 hours via quick charge.
Sound comes from 32mm dynamic drivers — smaller than the Sony's 40mm, which generally means less low-end authority, though SOAR tunes them for what it calls bold, game-day audio. The design leans hard into comfort: lightweight construction with super-soft ear pads, pitched at long tailgates and all-day listening sessions. Battery life is rated up to 40 hours, and unlike the Sony, you get both wireless and wired listening options, which is a real bonus if you ever want to plug in. Weight is listed at 1.2 pounds, so it's a chunkier unit on paper.
Who should buy it? Sports fans, students, and casual listeners who want a new pair with a 1-year manufacturer warranty, a team look, and marathon battery life. Who should skip it? Critical listeners who want advanced bass control, premium noise cancelling engineering, or the lighter build — those buyers are better served by the Sony.
• Best for noise cancelling depth → Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR, thanks to dual noise sensor technology and dedicated ANC engineering.
• Best for bass and sound tuning → Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR, with its 40mm driver and two-mode ULT bass button.
• Best for battery life → SOAR Collegiate Active, rated up to 40 hours versus 30 hours on the Sony.
• Best for newer Bluetooth → SOAR Collegiate Active, which uses Bluetooth 5.3 against the Sony's 5.2.
• Best for wired listening → SOAR Collegiate Active, since it supports wired and wireless while the Sony has no jack.
• Best for warranty length → SOAR Collegiate Active, with a 1-year manufacturer warranty versus the Sony's 90-day limited warranty.
• Best for lightweight comfort → Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR, at 8.96 ounces with thermo-formed cushions.
• Best for new condition → SOAR Collegiate Active; the Sony is a certified refurbished unit.
In my opinion, the Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR is the better buy for most people shopping for over-ear noise cancelling headphones for audiophiles. The dual noise sensor ANC, the 40mm driver, and the ULT bass modes give it a clear edge in sound and noise blocking — the two things this category is actually about. The SOAR Collegiate Active is a genuinely good pick if you value a fresh unit, a longer warranty, wired listening, and 40 hours of battery, or if team colors matter to you. But if audio quality and noise cancelling lead your list, I'd take the Sony. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding.
what is the best over ear noise cancelling headphones
There's no single answer, but by specs the Amazon Renewed Sony ULT WEAR stands out for noise cancelling with dual noise sensor technology and a 40mm dynamic driver. The SOAR Collegiate Active counters with Bluetooth 5.3 and up to 40 hours of battery. In my opinion the Sony wins on audio and ANC; the SOAR wins on warranty and battery.
which over ear noise cancelling headphones
Both are over-ear with active noise cancellation. Choose the Sony if you want premium ANC engineering, bass control, and a lighter 8.96-ounce build. Choose the SOAR if you want a new unit, a 1-year manufacturer warranty, wired plus wireless listening, and longer rated battery life.
what are the most comfortable over ear noise cancelling headphones
Comfort is personal, but the data points differ. The Sony uses thermo-formed ear cushions for a moldable over-ear fit at 8.96 ounces. The SOAR uses super-soft ear pads in a lightweight design rated at 1.2 pounds. The Sony is lighter on paper; the SOAR emphasizes pressure-free all-day wear.
how to on noise cancelling headphones
Turn on the headphones, connect over Bluetooth, then engage the ANC control — both models use active noise cancellation you switch on when you want to block background sound. The Sony adds touch media controls and a ULT bass button; the SOAR pairs over Bluetooth 5.3 and supports wired listening too. ANC works best when the ear pads seal fully around your ears.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Astell&Kern Billie Jean in-Ear vs Linsoul ZiiGaat x Hangout, Koss KSC35 vs Sonitum Classroom Headphones-Bulk 10-Pack, Raycon Fitness vs Sony WF-C700N: Premium Wireless Earbuds, Monster Persona Noise Cancelling vs WUYI Earbuds