How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Allstare 304 — biggest strength: Food-grade 304 stainless steel that resists rust, holds up to high heat and won't warp the way cheaper materials can. It's a one-time fix for a broken or worn tray.
• Allstare 304 — biggest trade-off: It only fits a specific list of Ninja Foodi oven models, and you have to match the size exactly. Order by appearance and you'll get the wrong part.
• FryEasy Air Fryer Paper — biggest strength: 100 disposable liners heat-safe to 428°F that catch grease and crumbs so the basket stays clean. Months of scrub-free cooking from one pack.
• FryEasy Air Fryer Paper — biggest trade-off: It's paper, so it's single-use by design. You're buying a consumable, not a part that lasts for years.
• Who each is for: Allstare 304 is for someone repairing or maintaining a compatible Ninja Foodi digital air fry oven; FryEasy is for someone with a Ninja Foodi Smart XL Grill who wants faster cleanup.
The Allstare 304 is a crumb tray and drip pan built as a replacement for the Ninja Foodi air fry oven. It measures 13.3" long by 12.8" wide and just 0.2" tall, and it's stamped from 304 stainless steel — the food-grade, high-temperature-resistant grade that resists rust and deformation far better than the thin materials many aftermarket trays use. In plain terms, this is the part that sits at the bottom of your oven and catches whatever falls: crumbs, oil, drips. That single job matters more than people expect, because a tray that catches the mess is what keeps your food from sitting in pooled grease and keeps cleanup from turning into a scraping session.
What it does best is be a permanent part. You slide it out after cooking, dump the crumbs, wipe it with a soft damp sponge, and put it back. A little liquid cleanser handles any staining that builds up. Because it's stainless rather than a coated or plated material, you're not fighting flaking or rust over time. The manufacturer lists a 30-day warranty, which is worth knowing before you commit.
Who should skip it: anyone who doesn't own one of the listed models. The fit list is specific — SP080, SP100, SP101 and its many variants, SP102, FT102A, FT102CCO and FT102CO. It also won't help you if what you actually want is faster cleanup rather than a replacement part. And if you're the type to order by looks instead of measuring, be careful here: the listing itself warns against ordering parts by appearance, and 13.3" x 12.8" needs to match your original tray before you buy.
FryEasy Air Fryer Paper: Who It's For
The FryEasy Air Fryer Paper is a 100-count pack of disposable parchment liners made for the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Grill. They fit the FG551, DG551 and IG551 models with a snug, secure fit, and they're also rated as compatible with the Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 air fryer, air oven and indoor grill setups — so the same box covers grilling, roasting and air frying across those configurations. The paper is heat-safe to 220°C / 428°F, which covers the temperatures you'd normally use for those cooking modes, and it's brown, sold as 100 sheets in a 5QT size.
What it does best is eliminate the worst part of cooking: the scrubbing. The liners stop grease and residue from bonding to the grill basket in the first place, which means you lift the paper out and throw it away. The listing also highlights airflow and crispiness, oil and water protection, and a thick, durable construction — the point being that a liner shouldn't steam your food into mush or tear the moment you lift it. Cross-contamination between cooks is another real benefit: cook fish, then cook something else, and you're not carrying flavors over on a shared basket.
Who should buy it: anyone with one of the compatible Ninja Foodi Smart XL units who cooks often and resents cleanup time. If you grill indoors several times a week, a 100-pack translates into months of not thinking about it.
Who should skip it: if your appliance isn't one of the listed models, these won't fit properly, and a loose liner in a hot basket is worse than no liner. Skip it too if you'd rather not generate disposable waste — this is a consumable, and there's no getting around that. And if you're expecting a permanent accessory, you're looking at the wrong product; paper is meant to be used once.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for cutting cleanup time to zero → FryEasy Air Fryer Paper. Lift out, toss, done.
• Best for durability and longevity → Allstare 304. 304 stainless steel resists rust and deformation; paper is single-use.
• Best for high-volume, everyday cooking → FryEasy Air Fryer Paper. 100 liners means you're not washing a basket after every meal.
• Best for heat tolerance in the oven/grill range → both are fine in practice. The Allstare tray is built for oven temperatures, and the FryEasy liners are heat-safe to 428°F.
• Best for a specific appliance match → depends entirely on your model. Allstare fits the SP/FT oven series; FryEasy fits the FG551, DG551 and IG551 grill series.
• Best for someone who hates waste → Allstare 304. One tray, wiped and reused indefinitely.
• Best for someone who hates scrubbing → FryEasy Air Fryer Paper. No basket scouring, no grease soak.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to whether you're fixing something or maintaining something. If your compatible Ninja Foodi oven is missing its tray or the original has rusted out, I'd buy the Allstare 304 — it's the actual part you need, and 304 stainless is the material I'd want in a high-heat oven anyway. If your appliance is working fine and you just want your evenings back, I'd buy the FryEasy Air Fryer Paper and stop scrubbing baskets. Neither is a "better" product; one is a repair, one is a habit change. Match it to your problem, and check the current price on Amazon before you decide.
FAQ
I wouldn't count on it. They're built specifically for the FG551, DG551 and IG551 models, plus the Smart XL 6-in-1 configurations. If your appliance isn't on that list, the fit won't be snug.
The listing rates them heat-safe to 220°C / 428°F. Stay within that range and keep them from touching exposed heating elements, which is good practice with any parchment.
No. They do different jobs in different appliances. Buy the Allstare 304 if you need a replacement tray for a compatible oven; buy the FryEasy paper if you want disposable liners for a compatible grill. Only overlap if you happen to own both kinds of machine.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: QYH 300 vs Acasimo Parchment Paper Sheets: Air Fryer Bread, SIUDANGKA Crumb Tray Replacement vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer, CHUAHAHA Air Fryer Paper vs FOXYAEO 100: Can You Use