Search this site
Embedded Files
All in Favor, Say Pie! LLC
  • Home
    • My Story
    • Reviews
  • Menu Items
    • Special Announcement
  • How to preserve your pie
All in Favor, Say Pie! LLC
  • Home
    • My Story
    • Reviews
  • Menu Items
    • Special Announcement
  • How to preserve your pie
  • More
    • Home
      • My Story
      • Reviews
    • Menu Items
      • Special Announcement
    • How to preserve your pie

Menu

Order here 


MENU UPDATE:  

Price change as of 11/1/25 - see below

LIMITED SUPPLY OF PEACHES AVAILABLE FOR PEACH PIE

PLENTY OF STRAWBERRIES AND RHUBARB AVAILABLE FOR STRAWBERRY RHUBARB PIE UNTIL SOLD OUT OF RHUBARB

Click the link for the order form to place an order for your pie today!  All orders must be received at least 2-5 days in advance.  Once I receive your order, I will send a confirmation email with the address for pick-up in Waukesha and the amount owed for the order.


Allergen information:  

All pie crust is made using Butter Flavor Crisco, which does have soybean oil as an ingredient.  

Regular crust uses wheat flour.  

I use eggs as a wash for the top crust.

PRICING:

  • 9" pies $28

  • 5" pies $10

  • handpies $5  --- available at monthly pop up sales

  • special order pies -- price varies -- email to inquire (avg. $33-35)


Payment accepted as cash or venmo 


Credit card accepted for larger orders



GIFT CERTIFICATES AVAILABLE   - order any denomination

Regular & Gluten Friendly crust available

As pictured with a lattice crust topping.  

Door County Cherry Pie 

Ingredients:  flour, butter flavor crisco, salt, water, door county cherry, tapioca flour, lemon juice, sugar

Available year round

apple blueberry

Similar to the Apple Cranberry, I have discovered a new favorite pie!!!  

Ingredients:  flour, butter flavor Crisco (soybean oil), salt, apples, blueberries, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, tapioca flour 


Dutch Apple Pie 

Ingredients:  flour, butter flavor crisco, salt, water, apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar, tapioca flour

Regular & Gluten Friendly crust available

As pictured with a crumb topping. 

cranberry Apple

Ingredients:  flour, butter flavor Crisco, salt, water, apples, cranberries, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, tapioca flour

Regular & Gluten Friendly crust available

As pictured with a lattice topping. 

mixed berry (Strawberry, blackberry and blueberry) pie

Ingredients:  Strawberries, raspberries, blueberry, sugar, tapioca starch, lemon juice, salt, flour, butter flavor Crisco, water.

blueberry pie

Ingredients:  Blueberries, sugar, flour, lemon zest, salt, butter flavor Crisco, water, tapioca starch

STILL AVAILABLE WHILE SUPPLIES LAST 

Chocolate Flourless Cake

with Chocolate ganache 

Very rich, decadent cake.  If you love anything chocolate, you will really love this.

$45

serves12-20 depending on slice size

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Ingredients:  Strawberries, rhubarb, sugar, egg, flour, butter flavor Crisco, water,salt, brown sugar, butter.

Regular & Gluten Friendly crust available

As pictured with a crumb topping.  


Strawberry Rhubarb Pie day is June 9th!!!  Reserve yours today!

Seasonal Varieties --- check back in summer

see below

Peach pie

Ingredients:  Peaches, cinnamon, sugar, tapioca flour, lemon juice, salt, flour, butter flavor Crisco, water.

Peach blueberry pie

Ingredients:  Peaches, Blueberries, sugar, tapioca flour, cinnamon, lemon juice, salt, butter flavor Crisco, water

Very Berry Lemon

Blueberries, blackberries, and lemon with a lemony crust!

Ingredients:  Blueberries, blackberries, lemon, sugar, flour, lemon zest, salt, butter flavor Crisco, water, 

Perfect pie for spring and summer!

the all american

Ingredients:  Apples, blueberries, strawberries, sugar, cinnamon, lemon zest, lemon juice, cornstarch, flour, Butter flavor Crisco, salt, water.


copyright 2024                                               
Google Sites
Report abuse
Page details
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse