How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want to stop your crisper plate from scratching and sliding inside a Dreo 4-quart fryer, choose ALJ Air Fryer Rubber; if you need to stop food and grease from touching the basket in the first place, choose GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper.
• ALJ Air Fryer Rubber — biggest strength: Four food-grade silicone bumpers rated to 430°F that clamp onto the crisper plate, giving it grip and shielding the fryer interior from scratches.
• ALJ Air Fryer Rubber — biggest trade-off: It's a fit-specific part. The listing is built around the Dreo DR-KAF002 4QT plate, and the installation is intentionally tight, so it isn't a universal grab-and-go item.
• GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper — biggest strength: 125 unbleached, non-stick round liners that catch grease and crumbs so the basket barely needs washing, and they work in air fryers, microwaves, ovens and steamers.
• GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper — biggest trade-off: It's disposable, so you restock it, and it only works safely when you weigh it down with food — an empty liner near a hot element is a real burn risk.
• Who ALJ is for: Dreo 4QT owners dealing with a rattling or scratching plate who want a fix they install once.
• Who GSSKIME is for: Anyone who cooks often and is tired of scrubbing a basket after every batch of wings or fries.
Think of the ALJ bumpers as a repair-and-protect part rather than a cooking accessory. Each piece measures 1.2 x 0.7 x 0.3 inches and weighs a fraction of an ounce, and the material is food-grade silicone that's BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless. The spec that matters most is heat resistance up to 430°F / 221°C — that's well above what a normal air fryer session throws at the plate, so the silicone won't degrade into a sticky mess the way a cheap rubber substitute might. The material is also described as tough and tear-resistant, which is what you want from something that gets pressed on and pulled off repeatedly.
The job itself is simple: you push these silicone tips onto the crisper plate, and they act as non-slip feet and bumpers. Two things happen. The plate stops sliding around when you shake a basket, and the metal stops grinding against the fryer's interior coating. If you've ever noticed faint scuff marks inside your drawer, this is the cheap insurance against more of them. ALJ notes the fit is deliberately tight so the tabs don't pop off mid-cook — expect to work them on the first time, and expect them to stay put after that.
GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper: Who It's For
The GSSKIME liners attack the problem from the opposite direction: instead of protecting the fryer's parts, they keep food and oil from ever reaching them. You get 125 round sheets made from untreated wood pulp, unbleached and free of BPA, PFAs and fluorescent agents. They're waterproof, oil-proof and non-stick, and they're rated to 450°F / 230°C — slightly higher than the silicone bumpers, which makes sense given they sit directly under food.
The design is what makes them practical. Each liner is 8 x 8 inches with a raised 4.5cm edge, so it forms a shallow bowl rather than a flat disc. That lip is the difference between a liner that contains a saucy batch of drumsticks and one that lets grease run straight off the edge onto the basket. There's no cutting, folding or measuring — you drop one in the tray or basket and add food. Cleanup becomes a matter of lifting out the paper and tossing it, which is the entire appeal for anyone who air fries several times a week.
The versatility is genuinely broad. The same liners work in microwave ovens, regular ovens, steamers and for packing or storing cooked food, which means a box does double duty at home and on camping trips or summer cookouts.
Buy it if you cook often, hate scrubbing, or make messy foods — wings, marinated proteins, anything with a wet rub or glaze. Skip it if you're trying to fix a loose or scratching plate, because paper can't do that job. And take the caution seriously: always put food on the liner before it goes in. A lightweight paper disc left empty in a hot air fryer can lift toward the heating element and burn. That single habit is the difference between a convenient accessory and a safety problem.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for cutting cleanup time → GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper. Grease, crumbs and stuck-on residue land on the liner, not the basket.
• Best for a one-time purchase → ALJ Air Fryer Rubber. Four reusable pieces you install once and keep using.
• Best for high-volume cooking → GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper. 125 sheets in the box means you're not rationing them.
• Best heat ceiling → GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper at 450°F / 230°C, narrowly ahead of the silicone's 430°F / 221°C.
• Best for multi-appliance kitchens → GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper. Air fryer, microwave, oven, steamer — one box covers all of them.
• Best for a specific fryer model → ALJ Air Fryer Rubber. It's engineered for the Dreo DR-KAF002 4QT plate, so compatibility is the first thing to check.
• Best if you want both problems solved → buy both. They don't overlap at all, and together they cover hardware wear and everyday mess.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper. In my opinion, maintenance is the daily pain point with an air fryer, and 125 disposable liners that catch grease and wipe out the scrubbing routine deliver more value per use than a set of silicone feet that you install and then forget about. That said, this is genuinely close. If your complaint is a loose, scratching crisper plate rather than a dirty basket, the ALJ bumpers are the correct fix and the paper is irrelevant. Match the product to your actual annoyance — and if both annoy you, there's no reason not to own both. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide, since the math changes once you know what each one costs.
Yes, they don't conflict. You can fit the silicone bumpers on the crisper plate and still lay a paper liner on top. One protects the hardware, the other protects the basket from food mess.
Each liner is 8 x 8 inches with a 4.5cm raised edge, which suits most standard round baskets and trays. If you have a very small or unusually shaped basket, measure the base first so the liner sits flat.
The ALJ silicone bumpers are reusable — you install them and keep them until they wear or tear. The GSSKIME liners are single-use, so the 125-sheet box is a consumable you'll work through over time.
GSSKIME rates the liners to 450°F / 230°C, and the ALJ silicone to 430°F / 221°C. The important rule with the paper is to always add food before cooking — an empty liner can lift and burn.
Buy the one that matches your frustration. Scratching or sliding plate → ALJ. Scrubbing the basket every night → GSSKIME. If you're unsure, the paper solves the more common everyday problem.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper vs HOYDATE 2-Pack: Air Fryer, Sactercon 8.5 vs JEWEDECO Air Fryer Paper: Air Fryer Size, YQL 9x13 vs PACKOVE Baking Paper 5.5: Air Fryer Spring Rolls