How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• ALJ Air Fryer Oven — biggest strength: two replacement drip pans in one pack, made of food-grade carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick coating, plus a nonstick cleaning cloth included.
• ALJ Air Fryer Oven — biggest trade-off: it is built specifically for one oven family (Gourmia 14QT All in One Digital Air Fryer Oven), so it is useless if your oven is a different brand or size.
• Anniparts 304 — biggest strength: upgraded 304 stainless steel construction that resists deformation and rusting, sized at 12.5'' x 11'' for large Kalorik MAXX ovens.
• Anniparts 304 — biggest trade-off: you get only one tray per pack, and there is no nonstick coating, so food release and cleanup lean on the stainless surface rather than a coating.
• Who each pick is for: the ALJ tray set is for Gourmia 14QT owners who want spares and easy wipe-down cleanup; the Anniparts tray is for Kalorik MAXX owners who want a rigid, long-lasting stainless bottom pan.
The ALJ Air Fryer Oven drip tray is a purpose-built accessory. It is designed to slot into the drip pan position of the Gourmia 14QT All in One Digital Air Fryer Oven, where it catches oil, grease and breadcrumbs as you cook or toast. The whole point is to keep the bottom of the oven from becoming a greasy mess, and to give you a removable pan you can pull out and wash instead of scrubbing the oven cavity.
What stands out, based on the specs, is the material and the coating. It is food-grade carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick finish, described as high temperature resistant, BPA-free and compliant with FDA standards. In practice, that combination is what makes the pan easy to release food from and easy to rinse. The nonstick layer is also the part you have to protect: the manufacturer explicitly warns against rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, which is why a magic cleaning cloth is bundled in the box. It is dishwasher safe as well, which matters on nights when you cannot be bothered to hand-wash anything.
The package is another reason to consider it. You get two replacement drip pans plus the cleaning cloth, so you can keep one in the oven and one clean and waiting. For a household that air-fries several times a week, having a spare means you are never stuck scrubbing a pan before you can start the next batch.
Anniparts 304: Who It's For
The Anniparts 304 is a different kind of product aimed at a different owner. It is a single crumb tray measuring 12.5'' x 11'', made from upgraded 304 stainless steel, and it fits at the bottom of Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart Digital Air Fryer Ovens — specifically models like the AFO 46045 SS, AFO 47631 SS2, AFO 51041 SS and others in that family. The job is the same as any crumb tray: sit under the cooking area, catch the debris, grease and crumbs that fall, and keep the oven interior cleaner so heat circulates more evenly.
The headline difference is the material. Stainless steel is the reason this tray is described as stronger and more robust than alternatives, resistant to deformation and protected against rusting. If you have ever had a thin coated pan warp or flake after months of high heat, the appeal of a rigid stainless tray is obvious. It holds its shape, it does not depend on a coating to stay usable, and there is no nonstick layer to scratch. That also means no warnings about abrasive sponges — you can clean it the way you clean stainless cookware.
Two practical notes from the data sheet. First, you get one tray, not a set, so if you like having a spare you will want to plan accordingly. Second, there is a 30-day warranty listed, which gives you a short window to confirm fit and condition. The manufacturer also asks that you let the oven cool completely before removing the tray, which is plain common sense with any metal pan that has just been under heat, and invites you to reach out if you are unsure about compatibility.
Who should skip it? Owners of Gourmia ovens, or anyone whose oven is not one of the listed Kalorik MAXX models. The size — 12.5'' x 11'' — is substantial and is meant for a large oven. In a smaller unit it will simply not sit right.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Gourmia 14QT owners → ALJ Air Fryer Oven. It is made for that exact oven, so fit is not a gamble.
• Best for Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart owners → Anniparts 304. It is dimensioned and listed for the AFO 46045 SS, AFO 47631 SS2, AFO 51041 SS and similar models.
• Best for durability and heat resistance → Anniparts 304. 304 stainless steel resists deformation and rusting, with no coating to wear away.
• Best for getting spares in one order → ALJ Air Fryer Oven. You receive two drip pans plus a nonstick cleaning cloth.
• Best if you want a single, rigid tray → Anniparts 304. One 12.5'' x 11'' stainless pan, nothing extra.
• Best for large-oven coverage → Anniparts 304. The 12.5'' x 11'' footprint is built for a 26-quart oven.
• Best for lowest-maintenance cleaning routine → depends on your habits. Choose the nonstick ALJ if you want to wipe and rinse; choose the stainless Anniparts if you would rather scrub without worrying about damaging a coating.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down almost entirely to which oven you own, because these two trays are not interchangeable. If you have the Gourmia 14QT All in One Digital Air Fryer Oven, I would buy the ALJ Air Fryer Oven set: two nonstick pans and a cleaning cloth is a genuinely useful package, and the nonstick surface makes the daily cleanup chore shorter. If you own a Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart, I would buy the Anniparts 304. A single 304 stainless tray that resists warping and rusting is the more durable long-term answer for a big oven, and you can clean it hard without babying a coating. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your oven, and confirm your model number before ordering — that is the one step that decides everything here.
How to clean air fryer crumb tray
Let the tray cool completely, then remove it from the oven. For the ALJ pan, wipe with a soft cloth or sponge and mild soap — the manufacturer warns against abrasive pads or metal balls because they damage the nonstick coating — or place it in the dishwasher since it is dishwasher safe. For the Anniparts 304, wash with warm soapy water and a normal sponge; stainless steel does not carry the same coating-care warning.
How to clean breville air fryer crumb tray
Neither tray in this comparison is made for Breville ovens, so the general method is what applies: cool the tray first, remove it, and wash with warm water and mild dish soap. Use a soft sponge rather than anything abrasive, and dry it thoroughly before putting it back so moisture does not sit against the metal.
How to clean ninja air fryer crumb tray
Same principle, and again neither of these trays is sized for Ninja ovens. Cool, remove, wash by hand with mild soap, and avoid harsh scrubbers if your tray has a nonstick finish. The ALJ pan specifically should not be rubbed with rough abrasive cloth or metal balls, which is the rule to follow with any coated tray.
How to get grease stains off of air fryer crumb tray
Start with hot water and grease-cutting dish soap and give it a short soak before wiping. On the nonstick ALJ pan, stay with soft cloths and gentle cleaners so the double-layer coating survives; on the 304 stainless Anniparts tray you have more freedom to scrub, since the material is designed to resist rust and deformation rather than rely on a coating.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: KunoNana Crumb Tray vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer Crumb Tray, atgestore KCO124 vs Allstare 304: Air Fryer Crumb Tray, ALJ Air Fryer Rubber vs EiiJugaloo Toaster Oven Air