How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• SettleDown Air Fryer Tray — best for Cuisinart toaster-oven owners who want basket and pan in one buy; pick this if you want a 12.4" x 11" x 2.3" stainless set that is dishwasher safe and produces no chemicals at high heat.
• COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray — best for Cuisinart owners who want an explicit preheating routine and a stated 480°F heat resistance; pick this if you want a 12.4" x 11" pan plus an 11.5" x 10" x 2" mesh basket with a nonstick finish.
• GCQ Air Fryer Tray — best for Ninja 4QT and 5.5-quart basket-style fryer owners; pick this if you need an 8.2-inch round crisper plate with a handle, rubber bumpers and a cleaning cloth included.
• GSZN Air Fryer Tray — best for 7-quart GoWise USA, PowerXL and 6.5-quart Chefman owners; pick this if you want a 10.3" x 9.5" carbon steel plate with a double-layer coating, handle and rubber tabs.
This is a two-piece replacement set: a stainless steel baking tray pan plus a mesh air fryer basket. The footprint is 12.4" x 11" with a 2.3" depth, and SettleDown lists it as compatible with the Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70. If your original tray has warped, lost its coating, or you simply want a spare that lives in the cabinet for back-to-back cooking, this is the bundle that covers both jobs at once.
The mesh basket is the part that matters most day to day. Air moves through the perforations instead of bouncing off a solid surface, which is how you get crisp edges on wings, frozen fries and vegetable chunks without constantly shaking the basket. The solid tray underneath catches drips and works as a straight baking pan for things that would fall through mesh — think fish fillets, small pastries, or a batch of roasted chickpeas.
Material-wise, it is stainless steel, described as non-toxic, tasteless and high-temperature resistant, with no chemicals produced during high-heat baking. It is also corrosion-resistant and dishwasher safe, which in practice means you can run it after a greasy chicken session instead of scrubbing by hand. At 4.8 ounces it is light enough to lift out one-handed with oven mitts.
The trade-off: this is a Cuisinart-specific fit. If you own a Ninja, GoWise, PowerXL or Chefman, the dimensions will not line up and you should look at the GCQ or GSZN entries instead. It is also a two-piece set, so you need somewhere to store the basket when you are only using the pan.
COWHERDING takes the same Cuisinart target — TOA-60, TOA-65, TOA-70 — and splits the sizing more precisely: a 12.4" x 11" baking pan and a separate 11.5" x 10" x 2" mesh basket rack. That slightly smaller basket is worth noting, because it means the rack sits inside the pan footprint rather than fighting it. The company also says it fits other similarly sized air fryer pans, so it is not locked to one badge.
The steel is described as food-grade, BPA-free, non-toxic, tasteless and FDA-compliant, with a nonstick finish intended to contain oil splatter. Heat resistance is stated at up to 480°F. That number is the headline for anyone who likes a hard sear or high-heat roasting, since it gives you real headroom above typical air fryer set temperatures.
One genuinely useful detail: COWHERDING recommends preheating the basket at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, and says this step helps prevent warping or bending. Whether or not every buyer bothers, it is a concrete instruction rather than vague advice, and it tells you the manufacturer is thinking about long-term shape retention. Cleanup is dishwasher safe, with a note to skip abrasive cloths and metal scrubbers, and hand-washing plus thorough drying is suggested for longer life.
The trade-off is that this is a heavier, more involved kit — 1.3 pounds and roughly an inch shallower in overall height than some alternatives. If you want something you can toss in and forget, the preheat step is one more thing to remember. In my opinion it is the better pick for someone who wants a documented heat ceiling and does not mind a two-minute setup ritual.
Here the form factor changes completely. GCQ makes an 8.2-inch round crisper plate designed for Ninja AF100, AF101, AF150 and AF161 air fryers, plus the Ninja Foodie pressure cooker and any other fryer that takes an 8.20 x 8.20 inch round plate. That round shape is the whole point: it drops into a basket-style fryer, not a toaster-oven cavity.
The build is food-grade material, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and GCQ says it meets FDA standards. The coating is described as an enameled nonstick with double-layer spraying, which the brand frames as both easier to clean and more durable. It is dishwasher safe, and GCQ includes a magic cleaning cloth plus three rubber bumpers in the box.
Those bumpers are the detail I would actually pay attention to. They sit under the plate so it stays put in the basket and does not scratch the fryer pot, which is a real annoyance with loose inserts that slide around while you shake. The handle design is the other practical touch — you can lift a hot plate out without tongs gymnastics.
The trade-off is fit. GCQ explicitly warns that this does not fit the Ninja 6.5-quart model, and the listing tells you to measure your fryer's inner diameter before ordering. It also will not work in a Cuisinart toaster oven, and it is a single plate rather than a pan-and-basket set. For a 4QT or 5.5-quart Ninja owner who wants a replacement crisper plate for fries, nuggets, pizza and egg tarts, though, the size and the accessories line up well.
GSZN goes after the large-basket crowd: 7-quart GoWise USA, 7-quart PowerXL Vortex, 7-quart PowerXL Maxx Classic and 6.5-quart Chefman air fryers. The plate measures 10.3" x 9.5" with a slim 0.39-inch profile and weighs 1.76 ounces, so it is a wide, flat insert that covers a big basket floor without eating much vertical space.
Material here is carbon steel rather than stainless, with a double-layer nonstick coating the brand describes as heat-resistant and more durable than a single coat. The perforated pattern is designed for air circulation so food heats evenly and comes out crisper, and there is a handle for pulling it out. GSZN also includes four rubber tabs to stabilize the plate and a nonstick cleaning cloth, and it is dishwasher safe.
If you cook in volume — a full basket of wings, a pile of fries for two or three people — the extra surface area is the reason to choose this over a smaller round plate. The thin profile also means it will not push food up against the heating element the way a deep insert can.
The trade-off: carbon steel with a coating needs more care than bare stainless. GSZN specifically warns against rough abrasive cloths and metal scrubbers because they damage the nonstick layer, so hand-washing with the included cloth or a gentle dishwasher cycle is the way to go. It also only fits the 7-quart and 6.5-quart models listed — measure before you commit.
How We Picked
We compared published specifications and features across these four trays: dimensions, material, coating type, heat resistance, included accessories and stated model compatibility. The order above is our independent editorial opinion based on how well each design serves a specific fryer type, not a paid placement. No brand paid for inclusion, and no manufacturer saw this guide before publication.
Match the size and shape first. Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 take a roughly 12.4" x 11" rectangular pan, Ninja AF100/AF101/AF150/AF161 take an 8.2-inch round plate, and 7-quart GoWise, PowerXL and 6.5-quart Chefman take a 10.3" x 9.5" plate. Measure your basket's inner dimensions before ordering.
All four are listed as dishwasher safe. COWHERDING and GSZN both suggest hand-washing and thorough drying for longer life, and all the coated models warn against abrasive cloths or metal scrubbers that can damage the finish.
Avoid metal tools on the coated plates from COWHERDING, GCQ and GSZN, since scratching the coating is the main way these wear out. COWHERDING notes that foil or parchment liners can make cleanup even easier — just make sure airflow through the mesh is not fully blocked.
Not according to COWHERDING, which states its basket handles foods without a splatter shield because the mesh allows 360° heat circulation. You can cook wings, fries and vegetables directly on it, and use foil or parchment liners if you want faster cleanup.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer replacement tray, air fryer basket replacement, GZHCJJ Air fryer Replacement vs CoeurAur Air Fryer Extender