We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
My top pick is the GXF Grill Pan, because its 6.1-inch round stainless steel plate with PTFE non-stick coating and a take-out handle is the most straightforward drop-in replacement for the small 2 QT Chefman, Dash, PowerXL and 1.6 QT Bella baskets that so many people own — and it costs you almost nothing in guesswork.
• GXF Grill Pan — best for small 2 QT and 1.6 QT baskets; pick this if you own a Chefman, Dash, PowerXL 2 QT or Bella 1.6 QT air fryer and want a dishwasher-safe stainless plate with a handle.
• ZuKaYeHome Air fryer Replacement — best for Ninja 4 QT and 5.5 QT owners; pick this if you need an 8.2-inch round crisper plate for an AF100/AF101/AF150/AF161 and want the extra cleaning cloth and bumpers in the box.
• GWY Air Fryer Replacement — best for Instant Vortex and Gourmia 6 QT baskets; pick this if you want a 9.1 x 9.5-inch plate with a center handle and an airflow design for even heating.
• GCQ Air fryer Replacement — best for Ninja Foodi pressure cooker crossover; pick this if you want an 8.2-inch plate that also works in a Ninja Foodie pressure cooker, plus a cleaning cloth.
This is a 6.1 x 6.1-inch round grill plate made of food-grade stainless steel with a PTFE non-stick coating applied in two sprayed layers. It's built specifically for small baskets: Chefman 2 QT, Dash, PowerXL 2 QT, and Bella 1.6 QT air fryers. It is not a universal part — the listing is blunt about that, and it's the single most important thing to understand before buying. If your basket isn't one of those, this plate will either rattle around or not seat at all.
In daily use, the handle is the feature you'll notice most. Instead of fishing a hot crisper plate out with tongs, you lift it straight out of the basket by the handle. The non-stick coating means fries, wings, steak and fried vegetables release without a fight, and the whole thing goes in the dishwasher. Three rubber bumpers are included in the package to keep the plate from scratching the basket interior and to stop it sliding while the air circulates.
The trade-off is size and compatibility. At 6.1 inches across and just 0.39 inches tall, this is a small plate for small appliances — you won't be doing a full family portion of wings on it in one pass. It's also the narrowest fit list of the four here, so measure your basket's inner diameter first. GXF also warns against scrubbing it with abrasive cloths or steel balls, and against washing it while it's still hot, both of which will shorten the life of the coating.
In my opinion, this is the right pick if your air fryer is a compact 2 QT workhorse and you just want a replacement that drops in, cooks, and rinses clean.
ZuKaYeHome Air fryer Replacement
ZuKaYeHome's plate is an 8.2-inch round crisper plate aimed squarely at the Ninja AF100, AF101, AF150 and AF161 — the 4 QT and 5.5 QT models a lot of people bought first. It's made of food-grade 304 stainless steel with an enameled non-stick coating, again double-layer sprayed, and it's dishwasher safe.
What I like about this one beyond the plate itself is that the brand describes it as usable in a regular oven and in a pressure cooker too, so it isn't a single-appliance purchase. The package also includes a magic cleaning cloth and the bumpers.
The main trade-off: like the GXF, this is a model-specific part. It's for 8.20 x 8.20-inch round baskets. If your air fryer has a square or rectangular basket, or a round basket of a different diameter, this is the wrong shape. And the coating still needs the same gentle handling — no metal scouring pads.
I'd recommend this for anyone with a Ninja 4 QT or 5.5 QT who wants a spare plate or a replacement for a lost original.
GWY's plate is the odd one out on shape, and that's deliberate. It measures 9.1 x 9.5 x 0.47 inches — wider than it is deep — and it's designed for Instant Pot Vortex Plus 6 Quart and Gourmia GAF735 6 Quart air fryers. The listing is unusually precise about which Vortex models fit: the Vortex Plus 6QT XL (6-in-1), the Vortex 6QT XL (4-in-1) and the Vortex 5.7QT (4-in-1). It explicitly does not fit the Vortex Plus 6QT with Odor Erase Technology, or the standard Vortex Plus 6QT. Read that twice if you own a Vortex — it's the most common way to buy the wrong tray.
Functionally, this is the most thoughtfully designed of the four for airflow. The plate has a perforated airflow pattern so hot air moves through and around the food rather than just over the top, which is what gives you even browning on onion rings, fries and wings. The handle sits in the middle of the plate rather than at the edge, which keeps the balance point centered when you lift it out of a deep 6 QT basket.
The trade-off is the fit list. It's a large plate for large baskets, and the size mismatch risk is real if you're not sure which Vortex you own. It's also the heaviest of the group at 5.3 ounces, which is trivial in practice but tells you it's a chunkier piece of steel.
For 6 QT Vortex and Gourmia owners, I think this is the best-balanced option here.
GCQ Air fryer Replacement
GCQ's tray is the closest thing to a twin of the ZuKaYeHome plate — same 8.2-inch round size, same Ninja AF100/AF101/AF150/AF161 compatibility list, same enameled double-layer non-stick coating, same handle and three rubber bumpers, same included magic cleaning cloth. Where it pulls ahead is one extra line on the compatibility list: GCQ also states it works with the Ninja Foodie Pressure Cooker.
That's a meaningful difference if you own both a Ninja air fryer and a Foodi. One plate covering both appliances means less cabinet clutter and one less thing to lose. The plate is food-grade stainless steel, non-toxic and tasteless, and cleans up by hand or in the dishwasher.
The specs list the same 4 QT and 5.5 QT Ninja pairing, and GCQ specifically flags that it does not fit the 6.5 Quart Ninja air fryer. It also warns against abrasive cloths and metal balls, and against cleaning the plate while it's hot — standard guidance for any coated tray.
The trade-off is that it's a near-duplicate of the ZuKaYeHome option. If you don't own a Foodi pressure cooker, the two are functionally interchangeable, so the deciding factor becomes which compatibility list you trust more for your exact model.
In my opinion, this is the pick for Ninja owners who want one tray that does double duty across their air fryer and their pressure cooker.
How We Picked
Measure the inner diameter of your basket, then match it to the plate. GXF is 6.1 inches for 2 QT and 1.6 QT baskets; ZuKaYeHome and GCQ are 8.2 inches for Ninja 4 QT and 5.5 QT; GWY is 9.1 x 9.5 inches for Vortex and Gourmia 6 QT. Round plates need round baskets.
Yes — all four are listed as dishwasher safe. Hand washing with a soft cloth is gentler on the non-stick coating, and every brand warns against abrasive cloths or steel balls and against washing the plate while it's still hot.
Some can. ZuKaYeHome, GWY and GCQ all state their trays work in ovens and pressure cookers. GXF's listing is focused on air fryer compatibility, so treat it as an air fryer part.
They clip onto the plate and sit between it and the basket floor, keeping the tray stable during cooking and protecting the inner pot from scratches. GXF and ZuKaYeHome and GCQ include three; GWY includes four.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer tray, Geesta 304 vs GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement, Freebily Replacement Odor Erase vs QinCiao Air Fryer Replacement