How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 9 min read · Independent comparison
The Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster is my top pick: an 1800-watt, 8-in-1 machine that air fries, convection bakes, broils, grills and warms, and it's the only one here with a reversible grill/griddle plate and a three-year warranty. If you want one countertop box that genuinely replaces a toaster, a small oven and a basket air fryer, start there.
• Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster — best for all-round cooking and grilling; pick this if you want 1800 watts, eight functions, a 0.6 cu ft interior, and a reversible grill/griddle in the box.
• Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 6 — best for small kitchens and quick access; pick this if you want a roll-top glass door that lets you reach food without pulling the rack out, in a 1400-watt, 4-function body.
• Gourmia French Door Air — best for family-size meals and preset cooking; pick this if you want a 25-quart french-door oven with 17 presets and FryForce 360° convection.
This is the most complete machine of the four. Cuisinart builds it around a 0.6 cubic foot interior, and the brand's own figures say that's enough for six slices of toast, three pounds of chicken wings, a 12-inch pizza, or a four-pound chicken. That last number matters: a four-pound bird is a real roast dinner, not a snack. Most countertop ovens in this category top out well below that.
The 1800 watts feed a top-mounted fan and heater assembly that Cuisinart calls AirAdvantage technology. In plain terms, that means the hot air blows down over the food rather than just sitting around it, which is what gives you browning on the top of a wing or a fry without flipping everything twice. Eight functions cover air fry, toast, convection bake, bake, convection broil, broil, grill and warm. The temperature range runs from 80°F up to 450°F, so it's not only a hot-and-fast machine — that low end is useful for proofing dough or gently warming plates.
The controls are a jog dial plus a touch interface, with a 60-minute timer and auto-shutoff, plus a separate toast shade selector. I like that combination for one reason: toast is the thing people actually use these ovens for every morning, and a dedicated shade dial beats punching in a time and temperature before you've had coffee. The included kit is unusually generous — oven rack, baking pan/drip tray, air fry basket, and a ceramic non-stick reversible grill/griddle. That griddle plate is the standout, because it's what lets the machine sear a sandwich or cook eggs and bacon, which is a job a basket air fryer simply can't do.
Two honest trade-offs. First, it's heavy at 11.5 kg (about 25 pounds), so it's a leave-it-on-the-counter appliance, not something you tuck in a cupboard. Second, care instructions call for hand washing, so the accessories aren't going in the dishwasher. If you want zero-fuss cleanup, that's a genuine annoyance. In my opinion, the capacity, the griddle and the three-year limited warranty make it the pick for anyone who cooks real meals rather than reheating.
Hamilton Beach takes a different angle: access. The signature feature is the Easy Reach glass door, which rolls up and back like a garage door instead of dropping down toward you. On a normal toaster oven, a drop-down door means leaning over a hot panel to slide a rack in and out. Here you reach straight in. If you've ever juggled a baking sheet one-handed, you already understand why that's a nice piece of design.
Underneath, it's a 1400-watt combo that runs four functions — toast, air fry, bake and broil — using Sure-Crisp convection for the air fry side. Sure-Crisp is Hamilton Beach's name for circulating hot air to brown food with little or no oil, and the brand points to fries, wings and vegetables as the target foods. The capacity is a claimed six slices of toast, a 12-inch pizza, or a 9" x 11" baking pan, with two rack positions to choose from. Two positions is fewer than the Chefman's three, but for toast, a tray of vegetables and a frozen pizza it's plenty.
The timer is a 30-minute dial with a ready bell, auto shutoff and a Stay On setting for longer cooks. That's the sensible compromise on a knob machine: short jobs get timed, long roasts get Stay On and you keep an eye on them. Accessories cover the basics — metal mesh air fry basket, bake pan, broil rack and a slide-out crumb tray, which is the easiest crumb system of the four.
The trade-offs are straightforward. Four functions and 1400 watts is the least powerful setup here, so it's the least flexible for anyone who wants to grill, dehydrate or roast a whole chicken. The 30-minute cap also means you can't dial in a two-hour bake and walk away. And the one-year warranty is shorter than Cuisinart's. In my opinion this is the right oven for a small kitchen, a single cook, or anyone who mostly makes toast, reheat-and-crisp jobs and weeknight tray bakes.
Chefman's EasyAir is the "modern controls" option. The whole front is a touch panel where you set time, temperature and cooking function, with a digital readout instead of dials. There's a "+2 MIN" button for adding a little more time without resetting the whole cook, which sounds trivial and isn't — it's the single most-used button on any oven like this.
The interior is 15 quarts with three rack positions, and Chefman says that's enough for four slices of bread or a 10-inch frozen pizza. Five functions cover air fry, bake, broil, toast and bagel, with five toast shades to pick from. The 1750 watts and 90°F to 450°F range put it close to the Cuisinart on raw power while keeping a compact 15"D x 16.8"W x 11.4"H footprint — the smallest depth of the group, which matters if your counter is shallow.
Two features stand out in daily use. First, no preheat wait: Chefman specifically pitches this as cooking frozen fries and chicken tenders from frozen, which is exactly how most people use an air fryer on a weeknight. Second, the "Flip" reminder that sounds halfway through cooking, so you turn the food and get even browning without hovering. The accessory list is genuinely generous too — two air-fry baskets, a flat wire rack and a baking pan/drip tray.
Trade-offs: the body is metal and plastic with a plastic interior, so it won't feel like the stainless Cuisinart, and the 15-quart figure is measured differently from the Cuisinart's 0.6 cubic feet, so don't assume it roasts a four-pound chicken. It's also the heaviest of the four at 16 pounds. What it is: a well-organized, touch-controlled oven with a 1-year warranty and cETL approval, and the flip reminder and extra basket make it my pick for two-person households cooking from frozen most nights.
The Gourmia is the biggest and the most automated. Two doors open outward with one hand, which means you load food from the front like a proper oven instead of reaching over a drop-down door — genuinely useful when you're holding a hot tray with both hands. Inside, 25 quarts takes a 12-inch pizza, six slices of toast, or a whole chicken.
Cooking runs on FryForce 360° technology, a 1700-watt convection system that circulates hot air around the food for oil-free crisping. What sets Gourmia apart is the preset count: 17 of them, covering air fry, bake, broil, roast, dehydrate and toast. If you don't want to think about temperature and time, you pick the preset and walk away. If you do, the digital panel gives you 90°F to 450°F and a 1-99 minute timer, so the manual control is there.
The dehydrate function is the one to note, because none of the other three list it. That opens up jerky, dried fruit and vegetable chips — a niche, but a real one if you want it. Accessories are the standard set: stainless steel fry basket, baking pan, oven rack and crumb tray, and the care instructions allow dishwasher use for at least some parts, which is the friendliest cleanup story of the four.
The trade-offs: at 25 quarts it's a large appliance, and the 17"D x 14"D footprint plus french doors means you need clear space in front of it, not just beside it. It's also the least powerful at 1700 watts despite being the biggest, so a very full oven will take longer than the Cuisinart. In my opinion, this is the one for families feeding three or four people who want preset-driven cooking and the widest capacity.
We compared the published spec sheets — wattage, capacity, cooking functions, temperature range, rack positions, controls, included accessories, dimensions and warranty — and weighed them against how people actually use a countertop oven: toast in the morning, frozen food at night, and a roast or a pizza on the weekend. The ranking is our independent editorial opinion, based on those specs and features. No brand paid for placement, and no brand saw this guide before it published.
No, and that's the main reason to buy one. All four use convection airflow to crisp food with little or no oil, so they cover the fries-and-wings jobs a basket air fryer handles — plus toast, baking and broiling that a basket air fryer can't do.
Match it to your household. Four to six slices of toast and a 10 to 12-inch pizza suits one or two people. For three or four, look at the larger interiors — the Gourmia's 25 quarts or the Cuisinart's 0.6 cubic feet, which Cuisinart rates for a four-pound chicken.
Dials are faster for toast and simple reheats, and there's less to break. Touch panels give you precise temperature and time plus extras like Chefman's flip reminder and Gourmia's 17 presets. If you cook the same few things on repeat, touch wins; if you want the machine to disappear from your mental load, dials do.
For most weeknight cooking, yes — baking, broiling, roasting a chicken and crisping frozen food are all covered, and they preheat far faster than a wall oven. For large holiday meals, big sheet-pan bakes or anything needing multiple racks at once, you'll still want the full-size oven.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer vs toaster oven, GreenLife Countertop Toaster Oven vs BELLA Fits-anywhere Slim 4qt, IPOW 24 vs casaWare Toaster Oven 6: Air Fryer English Muffin