How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 9 min read · Independent comparison
• ZLR 4-in-1 — best for catching drips and splatter under an air fryer or coffee maker; pick this if you want a 12" × 12" food-grade silicone mat that doubles as a 450°F trivet and rolls up for storage.
• Bakken- Swiss Air Fryer Tray — best for crisping food inside the oven or air fryer; pick this if you want a two-piece carbon steel tray and elevated mesh basket with a ceramic nonstick coating.
• Joyfair 9 — best for small-batch roasting and grease drainage; pick this if you want a stainless steel pan and rack combo with no coating at all.
• GWY Air Fryer Replacement — best for replacing a worn Gourmia crisper plate; pick this if you own a GAF856 or GAF826 8 QT and need a 9.8" × 9.8" square plate with a handle.
This is a 12" × 12" square mat made of food-grade, BPA-free silicone in Mint Green, with raised wavy ridges across the surface. It's the product I'd point most people toward first, because it solves the mess problem at the source: it sits under the appliance rather than inside it. The grippy silicone base keeps an air fryer, coffee maker, toaster oven, kettle or stand mixer from creeping forward while it runs, and it catches the drips, crumbs and oil splatter that would otherwise land on your counter.
The specs matter in daily use. The 450°F heat resistance means you can pull a hot baking sheet or roasting pan off the stove and set it straight down on the mat — useful if you have quartz or granite, which don't love thermal shock. The raised wavy ridges aren't just for looks; they let air move underneath whatever you set on top, so washed fruit, vegetables, a French press carafe or a couple of bowls dry faster than they would flat on the counter. The square 12" × 12" footprint is deliberately compact — it fits beside a coffee bar, on an apartment galley counter or an RV surface without eating the whole workspace.
Cleaning is the easy part. It's top-rack dishwasher safe, or you can just rinse it in the sink, and it rolls up tight to tuck into a drawer. One thing the manufacturer is explicit about, and I'd take it seriously: hang it or roll it to air-dry fully between uses, and run it through the dishwasher weekly. Silicone is non-porous, but residue can build up if the mat stays damp. That's the main trade-off here — it's a maintenance habit, not a throw-it-in-the-sink-and-forget item. The other honest limitation is the size. At exactly 12" × 12" it suits small and mid-size appliances; a very large air fryer may overhang it. And note the manufacturer's own clarification: this is a non-slip mat, not a slider, so appliances stay put rather than gliding.
For anyone whose air fryer lives on the counter and leaves a ring of oil and crumbs behind it, this is the pick I'd make.
Bakken- Swiss Air Fryer Tray
The two-piece design is the whole point. Set food in the mesh basket and the raised mesh lifts it off the base tray, which means air circulates around the food instead of pooling underneath it — that's how you get crisp fries, chicken wings or onion rings rather than steamed ones. Grease and juices drip through into the tray below, and the tray's raised edges keep that liquid from spilling into your oven. The ceramic coating is what makes release easy without a lot of oil, and it's rated to 450°F, so it's fine for standard oven temperatures.
Who is it for? Anyone who wants one accessory that handles both air fryer and oven duty, and who cooks for more than one person. The 13.78" × 8.86" basket is genuinely extra-large by the standards of this category, and the easy-grip handles make pulling a hot basket out of a hot oven less of a juggling act. Fries, wings, vegetables, seafood, baked goods — the size covers a real family portion rather than a single serving.
The trade-offs are worth naming. The ceramic nonstick surface needs gentler handling than bare steel to keep its release properties, and it's a single-purpose cooking tool — it won't catch drips under an appliance the way a mat does. It also takes up real storage space compared to something that rolls up. If you want a drip tray in the "catch the mess" sense, this isn't it; if you want a crisper that doubles as a baking tray, it is.
The Joyfair set is a 9" baking sheet pan with a matching grid rack, both in pure stainless steel with a mirror finish — no coating, no nonstick layer. The pan measures 9"L × 7"W × 1"H, and the rack comes in at 8.6"L × 6.2"W × 0.75"H. It's a small-format setup built for toaster ovens and compact air fryer baskets.
The rack is the interesting part, and it's where the drip-tray function actually lives. It uses a cross design with 3/8" grid spacing — wide enough that grease drips through, tight enough that food doesn't fall between the bars. Two load-bearing rods prop the rack up, and four raised feet lift it off the pan so air circulates around whatever you're cooking. That means crispier results and faster cooling, and it also means the pan underneath is doing real work collecting fat and juices rather than just sitting there.
Because there's no coating, there's nothing to peel, flake or wear through. The manufacturer designed it as a direct alternative to aluminum and non-stick pans, and the heavy-gauge steel with a reinforced rolled rim is meant to resist twisting and warping. Round edges with no sharp spots make it comfortable to move around. Both pieces are rust-proof and dishwasher safe, and the rounded corners leave no dead spots where food hides.
I'd recommend this to someone who roasts small portions — bacon, a chicken breast or two, a batch of jerky — or who wants a cooling rack that also drains grease and water. The trade-off is honest and simple: it's small. At 9" × 7", this is a one- or two-person tool, not a sheet-pan-dinner setup. And uncoated stainless requires a bit more oil or parchment for sticky foods than a ceramic or nonstick surface would. In exchange, you get a set that should outlast most coated pans in your drawer.
This is a drop-in replacement part rather than a multi-purpose accessory. It's a 9.8" × 9.8" square nonstick crisper plate designed specifically for the Gourmia GAF856 and GAF826 8 QT air fryers, made from food-grade stainless steel with a nonstick coating and shipped with four rubber bumpers.
If your original Gourmia crisper plate has lost its coating or gone missing, this is the straightforward fix. The handle is the detail that matters most day to day — it lets you lift the hot plate out of the frying basket without reaching for tongs, and the whole thing is dishwasher safe. The whirlwind airflow design is the functional claim: the plate's pattern is meant to move hot air around the food more evenly, which is what you want for barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, french fries, pizza and chicken wings.
The stainless steel base with a nonstick top gives you durability plus easy food release, and the manufacturer notes it's BPA-free with no hazardous chemicals to worry about. The four rubber bumpers are a small but sensible addition — they sit between the plate and the basket to keep it from rattling or scratching.
Now the trade-offs, and there are two clear ones. First, fitment is narrow: this is built for the GAF856 and GAF826 8 QT models, and the manufacturer's own first instruction is to measure your air fryer basket's inner diameter before ordering. If you don't own one of those two models, this isn't your part. Second, the nonstick coating needs care — no abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, which will damage it. A cleaning cloth is included for that reason. Treat it gently and it should serve like the original; scrub it hard and you'll be shopping again.
How We Picked
We compared the published specs and features of each product — materials, dimensions, heat ratings, coating types, airflow design and cleaning requirements — and weighed how each one actually functions as a drip tray or drip-catching accessory in a real kitchen. The order reflects our independent editorial opinion about which designs serve the most shoppers best, not any brand's influence. No company paid for placement or was consulted on this ranking, and the final call is ours.
how to clean air fryer drip tray
It depends on the material. Silicone mats like the ZLR are top-rack dishwasher safe or can be rinsed in the sink, though the manufacturer recommends hanging or rolling them to air-dry fully between uses and running them through the dishwasher weekly. Metal trays and racks, including the Bakken-Swiss, Joyfair and GWY options, are dishwasher safe. For coated surfaces, avoid abrasive cloths and metal scouring pads, which damage the nonstick layer.
how to clean breville air fryer drip tray
None of the products in this guide are made for Breville air fryers, so I can't give you Breville-specific instructions from these data sheets. The general rule for any coated drip tray or crisper plate applies: warm soapy water and a soft cloth or sponge, then dishwasher if the part is rated for it. Never use metal scouring balls on a nonstick coating.
how to clean ninja air fryer drip tray
Same caveat — these four products aren't Ninja-specific parts. What the data sheets do tell you is the material logic: stainless steel pans and racks like the Joyfair set are rust-proof and dishwasher safe, and uncoated steel tolerates a warm soapy soak followed by a simple wipe. Coated plates need the gentler approach.
how to clean cuisinart air fryer drip tray
I don't have Cuisinart-specific data here either. The transferable advice from these sheets: check whether your tray is bare stainless or coated. Bare stainless can handle a warm soapy soak and a dishcloth; coated trays should skip abrasive scrubbers entirely so the nonstick surface stays intact.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWYXC Air Fryer Basket vs Dinlon Air Fryer Drip, GXF Air Fryer Tray vs GCQ Air Fryer Grill, GSZN Air Fryer Tray vs bainianMS Deep Fryer Cover