How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Seropy 3 — best for everyday air frying in a 4–7 quart basket; pick this if you want a reusable, food-grade silicone liner that is non-stick, heat resistant to 464 °F, and dishwasher safe.
• katbite Air Fryer Parchment — best for small round baskets and steamers; pick this if you want 120 pre-cut 7.5-inch perforated rounds in extra-thick 45gsm paper that lets steam circulate.
• GOTHAM STEEL Crisper Tray Air — best for oven-based air frying; pick this if your oven or convection oven has an air fry setting and you want a 12-inch mesh basket over a drip tray.
• OPENICE Oven Air Fryer — best for feeding a family or batch cooking; pick this if you want two sizes of stainless steel basket-and-tray sets plus 60 parchment sheets in one package.
The Seropy 3 is a three-pack of square silicone liners sized for 4–7 quart air fryer baskets. Each one is 7.1 inches across and made from food-grade silicone that is free of PVC and BPA. Think of it as a soft, reusable pot that drops into the basket you already own: you cook in the liner, then lift it out by the two side handles instead of scrubbing the basket itself.
In daily use, the design details matter more than they sound. The inner surface is smooth so grease slides off, while raised lines on the bottom keep food slightly elevated and let oil drain away — which is exactly what you want for wings, fries, or bacon. The silicone is rated heat resistant up to 464 °F, well above normal air fryer temperatures, and it is scratch and tear resistant, so metal tongs and repeated washing are not a problem.
Cleaning is where this set earns its place in my top spot. It is dishwasher safe, and you can also flip it inside out and wipe it down with a brush. Compared with disposable paper liners, three reusable pieces cover you for months of cooking instead of one session, and there is no paper sitting near a heating element. They also work as baking mats, oven liners, or small bowls in the fridge and freezer.
The trade-off is shape and fit. Square liners suit square or rectangular baskets best, and the 7.1-inch size is aimed at the 4–7 quart range — if your basket is much smaller or unusually round, the fit will feel loose. They also hold in some airflow at the base, so food sitting directly on the liner can brown a little less underneath than food on a bare rack.
The katbite set is the opposite approach: 120 pre-cut round parchment liners, 7.5 inches in diameter, with holes punched through them. The paper is 45gsm, which the brand describes as thicker than the 35–40gsm paper commonly used for this kind of liner. It is made from food-grade wood pulp and is described as fluorescent free. These are sized for 3.5–3.7 quart air fryers and also fit 7.5-inch bamboo or metal steamers.
The perforations are the whole point. Steam and hot air pass through the holes, so food heats more evenly than it would on a solid sheet, and the paper still keeps drips and stains off the basket floor. Temperature resistance runs from -68 °F to 450 °F. Because you throw each one away after use, cleanup is essentially a two-second job.
This is the pick for anyone with a smaller round basket who hates washing up, or for steaming dumplings and buns. It is also handy for messy foods like chicken wings or breaded snacks that leave residue behind.
The trade-off is real and worth stating plainly. Parchment is disposable, so you are buying it again and again, and it is not reusable. More importantly, the brand warns against putting these liners in the air fryer empty or during pre-heat, and food must be placed on top so the paper does not fly up into the heating element. Paper can scorch if it touches the heating tube. If you want set-and-forget convenience, silicone is the safer habit.
The GOTHAM STEEL Crisper Tray Air is not a liner at all — it is a two-piece oven air frying system: a 12-inch round mesh basket that sits above a solid non-stick pan. The basket is elevated so hot air can circulate 360 degrees around whatever you are cooking, and the pan underneath catches grease and crumbs. It carries a copper-colored Ti Cerama titanium and ceramic non-stick coating and is dishwasher safe.
The intended use case is an oven with an air fry or convection mode. Instead of buying a countertop appliance, you set this on a standard oven rack and let the oven's fan do the crisping. The mesh design means fries, wings, and vegetables get exposed to moving air on all sides, closer to what a dedicated air fryer does than a flat sheet pan ever manages. Because the pan below is solid, your oven floor and racks stay cleaner, and the open rim is easy to grab with an oven mitt.
Two honest trade-offs. First, it needs an oven that genuinely has an air fry or convection setting — in a plain bake oven you get a rack-and-pan setup, not air frying. Second, at 12 inches round it takes up a full rack and needs hand space around it, so it is a poor fit for very small ovens or anyone cooking for one.
OPENICE Oven Air Fryer
The OPENICE set is the value-volume option: two large basket-and-tray sets at 15.6 × 11.6 inches, two medium sets at 12.8 × 9.6 inches, plus 60 parchment sheets split across the two sizes. That is six pieces in total. The baskets and trays are stainless steel with a non-stick coating, and the large tray is 2.16 inches tall.
The mesh basket is designed for 360-degree air circulation without flipping food, and the tray below catches oil and fat so it drips away rather than pooling around what you are cooking. That combination is what lets you cut back on added butter and oil. Cleanup is straightforward: both parts are dishwasher safe, and the included parchment makes some jobs a simple rinse.
Where this set wins is capacity and flexibility. Two sizes mean you can run a small batch in the medium set on a weeknight and use the large set when guests are over — fries, roasted vegetables, steaks, cookies, or fish cooked en papillote. It is aimed at regular ovens with an air fry option or wall ovens rather than countertop air fryers.
The trade-offs are space and material expectations. At 15.6 × 11.6 inches the large set is genuinely big, so measure your oven rack and your storage cupboard before committing. Stainless steel with a non-stick coating is a sensible middle ground, but it will not outlast a heavy bare-metal rack, and the coating needs the usual gentle handling — no metal tongs scraping across it.
I compared published specs and features only: material, dimensions, heat resistance, coating, dishwasher suitability, and what each item is designed to do. Nothing here is based on hands-on testing, and the order reflects my independent editorial opinion about which design suits which shopper. No brand paid for placement, and no brand reviewed or approved this page.
It can reduce browning on the underside, because the liner blocks some direct airflow and contact heat. Use the raised-line side and avoid overcrowding so hot air still moves around the food.
No. The katbite instructions say not to put the liners in without food or in pre-heat mode, and to keep them away from the heating tube, since paper can burn if it lifts into the element.
The Seropy liners are 7.1 inches square and are specified for 4–7 quart baskets. The katbite rounds are 7.5 inches and target 3.5–3.7 quart air fryers and 7.5-inch steamers.
Yes for real air frying results. The GOTHAM STEEL and OPENICE sets both rely on an oven or convection oven with an air fry mode to circulate hot air; a standard bake oven will only give you a rack-and-pan setup.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: best dual basket air fryer, air fryer basket divider, air fryer silicone basket