How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
My top pick is the GWY Air Fryer Grill — a 9.7-inch crisper plate with a grab handle, an enameled non-stick finish and a fit list that covers a wide spread of Ninja Foodi pressure cooker air fryers, which makes it the most broadly useful tray in this group.
• GCQ Air Fryer Tray — best for the Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360; pick this if you want a 12 × 10 × 0.7 inch food-grade stainless steel tray that can take temperatures up to 480°F.
• GWYXC Air Fryer Replacement — best for Ninja AF141 / AF142 5 QT baskets; pick this if you want an 8.43 × 8.43 inch handled crisper plate that is light and easy to lift out.
• GXF Air Fryer Grill — best for the same Ninja 5 QT models with a slightly heftier plate; pick this if you want an 8.43 × 8.43 inch non-stick crisper plate with bumpers and a cloth in the box.
This is a replacement crisper plate for Ninja Foodi pressure cooker air fryers, sized 9.7 × 9.7 inches. The listing names FD302 6.5 Qt, FD101 5 Qt, FD401 8 Qt, FD305CO, OP302, OP305, OS301, OS400, OS401 and OL500, and it also states that it fits other air fryers that use a 9.7 × 9.7 inch crisper plate. It is made of aluminium with an enameled non-stick coating applied in two sprayed layers, and it is dishwasher safe.
The feature that matters most day to day is the handle. On a crisper plate, a handle is the difference between lifting a hot tray out of a basket with tongs and simply grabbing it — and in my opinion that is the single most useful detail on any accessory tray. The non-stick coating means wings, fries and vegetables release without a fight, and the dishwasher-safe claim means cleanup is a load-it-and-forget-it job rather than a scrub. The package also includes a magic cleaning cloth and six air fryer rubber bumpers, which are small silicone feet you can fit to the plate so it sits without scratching the basket.
Because this is a pressure cooker air fryer accessory, it suits people who own a Ninja Foodi and want to air fry, crisp or reheat on a raised plate rather than straight in the basket. Raising food off the basket floor lets air circulate under it, which is the whole point of a crisper plate. The 9.7-inch footprint is on the larger side for this group, so it holds more food at once — better for a family portion of fries or a batch of wings.
The trade-off is fit. A 9.7-inch square plate needs a genuinely large basket or pot, so this is not a pick for compact 4 to 5 quart air fryers, and the brand itself advises measuring your air fryer's inner diameter before ordering. It is also a single-plate package — no skewers, no liners — so if you want a full accessory kit, this is not that. In my opinion, though, for anyone with a compatible Ninja Foodi, the handle, the coating and the bumpers make this the most practical tray of the four.
This one is a different animal. It is a 12 × 10 × 0.7 inch stainless steel tray built for the Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360 air fryer, and the listing is explicit that it does not fit the Emeril Lagasse 360 Dual Zone 25 QT or 26 QT models with French doors. Steel, not coated aluminium — silver, food grade, BPA-free and stated to meet FDA standards.
Stainless steel brings two real advantages. The first is heat tolerance: the tray is rated to a maximum of 480°F, which is higher than most coated plates will comfortably take. The second is durability — there is no non-stick layer to chip, so you can use metal utensils on it without the anxiety that comes with a coated pan. It is dishwasher safe, and the brand notes that even stuck-on food lifts after a short soak.
There is one catch you must not skip. Because of how the steel behaves, the brand requires preheating before first use: put the tray in an oven at 300°F for 10 minutes. Skip that step, and the listing warns the tray may deform, bend or be damaged, shortening its life. That is a one-time step, but it is a real instruction, not a suggestion.
Who is it for? Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360 owners who want a flat tray for baking, grilling, frying and roasting — chicken wings, fries, vegetables, pizza, steak. The 12 × 10 inch surface is generous and flat, which makes it good for food that needs to lie still rather than tumble. The trade-off is that it only ships as a single tray, it is not non-stick, and it is locked to one specific appliance family. If you own anything other than the Everyday 360, this is not your tray. If you own that machine, it is a straightforward, hard-wearing choice.
Here we move down in size. This is an 8.43 × 8.43 inch crisper plate designed for the Ninja AF141 Air Fryer Pro 4 in 1 and the AF142 Air Fry Max 5 in 1, both 5 QT, plus any other air fryer that uses an 8.43 × 8.43 inch plate. It is aluminium with a ceramic-style non-stick coating, applied in two sprayed layers, and it is dishwasher safe.
Two things stand out. First, the weight — 4.9 ounces. That is light enough to lift one-handed with the built-in handle, which matters when the plate is hot and loaded. Second, the coating. The listing describes it as a ceramics non-stick coating and specifically warns against scouring it with abrasive cloths or metal balls, which tells you the finish is the part to protect. Treat it gently and it should stay slippery.
The package includes the grill plate, a magic cleaning cloth and four rubber bumpers. The bumpers are worth mentioning again: they lift the plate slightly off the basket surface, which reduces scratching and helps air move underneath. For a 5 QT Ninja, that combination — right size, handle, light weight — is exactly what you want in a daily-use tray.
This is the pick for someone with a compact Ninja AF141 or AF142 who wants a like-for-like replacement or a spare plate for a second batch. It is best for single portions and small sides: a handful of fries, a few chicken wings, roasted vegetables for one or two. The trade-off is surface area — 8.43 inches square is noticeably smaller than the GWY plate, so a big family batch means cooking in rounds. It is also a single-plate package with no extra accessories beyond the cloth and bumpers. In my opinion, it is the best fit if your basket is small and you value easy lifting over maximum capacity.
This is the closest thing in this group to a direct twin of the GWYXC plate. Same 8.43 × 8.43 inch size, same Ninja AF141 and AF142 5 QT fit list, same "other air fryers using an 8.43 × 8.43 inch crisper plate" note, same aluminium build with a two-layer enameled non-stick coating, same handle, same dishwasher-safe claim, and the same box contents: one grill plate, one magic cleaning cloth, four rubber bumpers.
So what is the difference? Weight. This one is listed at 5.6 ounces against 4.9 ounces for the GWYXC. That is a marginal difference — under an ounce — but it hints at a slightly thicker or denser plate. In practice, a fractionally heavier plate can feel a little more substantial in the hand and may resist flexing better when you load it up. It is not a dramatic distinction, and I would not build a decision around it alone.
Functionally, you are getting the same experience: a handled non-stick crisper plate that raises food for better air circulation, releases food cleanly, and goes in the dishwasher. Same coating caveat applies — no abrasive pads, no metal scouring balls, or you will wear through the finish that makes it easy to clean. The package dimensions are also a touch tighter than the GWYXC's, though both are sized around a 9-inch square shipping footprint.
Who is it for? The same person as the GWYXC plate: a Ninja AF141 or AF142 owner who wants a replacement or spare tray, cooking for one or two people. The trade-off is identical too — smaller usable surface than the 9.7-inch GWY plate, single-plate package, and a coating that needs gentle handling. If you are choosing between this and the GWYXC, I would treat them as near-equivalents and let the slightly heavier build decide it for you.
We compared the published specifications and features of each tray — plate dimensions, material, coating type, handle design, heat tolerance and what comes in the box — and matched each one to the air fryers it is stated to fit. The order here is our own independent editorial opinion, not a claim about which product is objectively better. No brand paid for placement, and none of these picks was influenced by anything other than the listed specs.
Measure the inner diameter of your air fryer basket or pot before ordering. Each of these trays lists a specific size — 9.7 × 9.7 inches for the GWY plate, 8.43 × 8.43 inches for the GWYXC and GXF plates, and 12 × 10 inches for the GCQ tray — and the fit lists name specific models.
Yes. All four are described as dishwasher safe. The coated plates (GWY, GWYXC, GXF) should not be scrubbed with abrasive cloths or metal balls, because that damages the non-stick surface.
Yes. The brand states that before first use you should place it in a preheated oven at 300°F for 10 minutes. Skipping this step may cause the tray to deform or bend, which shortens its lifespan.
The GWY, GWYXC and GXF packages each include rubber bumpers. They are small silicone feet that fit to the plate so it sits in the basket without scratching, and they help keep a little airflow underneath the tray.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer accessories baking, air fryer drip tray, air fryer accessories