How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a full squad outfitted with talk-and-listen earpieces that plug straight into common Motorola Talkabout radios, choose abcGoodefg 1; if you need a discreet listen-only surveillance piece for a Harris XL-200 shoulder mic, choose PZYPYM All Black Listen.
• abcGoodefg 1 biggest strength: A 10-pack of G-shape clip-ear headsets with a built-in mic and push-to-talk button on a 2.5mm single-pin plug — enough units to equip a whole team at once.
• abcGoodefg 1 biggest trade-off: The 10-pack only makes sense if you actually need many units, and the compatibility list is long but specific — it's built around Motorola-style 2.5mm one-pin radios, not Harris gear.
• PZYPYM All Black Listen biggest strength: Purpose-built listen-only acoustic tube design in all black, with a 2.5mm small plug aimed at Harris XL-200 shoulder mics, a metal swivel clip, a coiled cord and spare earmolds.
• PZYPYM All Black Listen biggest trade-off: There is no microphone and no PTT, so you can receive but never transmit — and the plug is sized for a narrow set of 2.5mm small-plug jacks.
• Who abcGoodefg 1 is for: Teams and families running compatible Motorola two-way radios who want two-way talk plus listen in one earpiece, in bulk.
• Who PZYPYM All Black Listen is for: Police, security, EMS and similar users on a Harris XL-200 shoulder mic who want to hear traffic quietly without any risk of accidentally transmitting.
The abcGoodefg 1 is a classic G-shape ear-hanger headset. A soft hook loops over the ear, a thin tube carries sound into the ear canal, and the whole thing hangs off a 2.5mm single-pin plug. The interesting part is what sits on the cable: a push-to-talk button with the microphone hidden inside it. So instead of holding a radio to your face, you clip the radio to your belt, run the cable up your shirt, and talk by pressing the button near your collar. It fits either ear, left or right, which matters more than people expect when you're wearing a hat, a headset or a uniform collar all day.
The compatibility list is the real story here. This earpiece is built for the Motorola Talkabout ecosystem and the many radios that share its 2.5mm one-pin jack — MH230R, MR350R, MS350R, MT350R, MG160A, MD200TPR, the EM and MC series, and a long tail of TLKR and T-series Talkabout models. If your radios are on that list, this is a plug-and-play swap. If they aren't, it isn't. There's no adapter in the box, and the 2.5mm one-pin format is not the same as a 3.5mm jack or a multi-pin connector.
Then there's the count. Ten pieces ship in one offer. That's the headline feature for anyone buying for a group: a security crew, a warehouse team, a hiking club, a large family on a road trip, or an event staff roster. Ten means spares, replacements, and enough to hand one to every person on shift without reordering.
Who should skip it? Anyone who needs a single earpiece, anyone whose radio uses a different connector, and anyone who wants a completely silent receive-only setup — because the mic and PTT are baked in and always there, whether you press the button or not. If you only ever listen, you're paying for hardware you won't use.
The PZYPYM All Black Listen is a different animal entirely, and the name tells you so: listen only. There is no microphone, no push-to-talk and no transmit path at all. Audio comes down a soft silicone acoustic tube into an in-ear mold, fed by a 2.5mm small plug designed for a Harris XL-200 shoulder mic. The all-black finish, black tube and black earmolds keep the whole thing visually quiet against a dark uniform.
The design choices all point the same direction: concealment and stability. The 2.5mm small plug is a precise fit for the XL-200 shoulder mic and other devices with a standard 2.5mm small-plug earphone jack — note that "small plug" is doing real work in that sentence, because it won't seat properly in a jack that isn't sized for it. The metal swivel clip anchors the cable to a shirt or vest so the cord doesn't snag or swing. The cord is coiled, which gives it stretch and take-up on the move, and it's described as reinforced for extra strength. The acoustic tube is coiled too, and silicone earmolds plus ear-tip replacements ship in the box so you can match your ear shape. The stated frequency range runs 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, with a dynamic driver.
Who is this for? Police officers, firefighters, EMS crews and security personnel who receive instructions through a shoulder mic and want that audio in their ear rather than broadcast into the room. The listen-only design is the point: no mic means no accidental signal emission, which is exactly what you want in tactical or confidential settings where a stray transmission is a real problem.
Who should skip it? Anyone who needs to talk through their earpiece. There's no mic and no PTT, so this cannot replace a two-way radio headset. And anyone whose radio isn't a Harris XL-200 or a device with a matching 2.5mm small-plug jack should verify the connector before buying — the fit is narrow by design.
• Best for two-way communication → abcGoodefg 1. The hidden mic in the PTT button lets you transmit as well as receive.
• Best for receive-only, no-transmit discipline → PZYPYM All Black Listen. No microphone means no accidental transmission, ever.
• Best for equipping a whole team at once → abcGoodefg 1. Ten complete headsets in a single offer versus one headset plus a pair of earmolds.
• Best for Harris XL-200 shoulder mic users → PZYPYM All Black Listen. The 2.5mm small plug is built specifically for that radio's shoulder mic.
• Best for Motorola Talkabout owners → abcGoodefg 1. The compatibility list covers MH, MR, MS, MT, MG, MJ, MC, MD, EM series and a large set of TLKR and T-series radios.
• Best for long shifts with movement → PZYPYM All Black Listen. The metal swivel clip, coiled cord and silicone earmolds are aimed at staying put during strenuous activity.
• Best for left- or right-ear flexibility → abcGoodefg 1. The G-shape hook is designed to fit either ear.
• Best for a low-profile, all-black look → PZYPYM All Black Listen. Black earpiece, black acoustic tube, black earmolds — a deliberately subdued package.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to one question: do you need to talk back? If yes, I'd buy the abcGoodefg 1 — it's the only one of the two with a mic and PTT, it fits either ear, and the 10-pack is genuinely useful if you're outfitting more than one person. If you're on a Harris XL-200 shoulder mic and your job is to receive quietly without any chance of transmitting, I'd buy the PZYPYM All Black Listen instead. Its listen-only design, swivel clip, coiled cord and spare earmolds read like they were built for exactly that role. Buy the one that matches how you actually use your radio — not the one with more features.
FAQ
what is ear pieces
what are ear pieces for singers
Singers use in-ear monitors, which are a different category from radio earpieces. They're fed by a monitor mix so the performer hears the band and their own voice clearly on stage. The two products here are radio communication earpieces on 2.5mm jacks, not stage monitor systems, so they serve a different purpose.
what are ear pieces
Ear pieces are the small speaker components worn in the ear that carry audio privately to one person. The abcGoodefg 1 uses a G-shape ear hook with an in-ear tube and a hidden mic in the PTT button, while the PZYPYM All Black Listen uses a soft silicone acoustic tube and earmolds with no mic at all.
what do the earpieces in singers ears do
They let a performer hear a controlled monitor mix without stage noise overwhelming it. Radio earpieces do something similar but for communication: the PZYPYM All Black Listen feeds audio from a Harris XL-200 shoulder mic into the ear for discreet listening, and the abcGoodefg 1 lets you both hear radio traffic and talk back through its push-to-talk button.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Symphonized Earbuds 3.5mm vs WESEARY Gaming Headset, JLab Go Air Pop+ vs Apitiong 3-in-1: Fast Charge Headphones, AFGHOA Earbuds vs AESIGN 3: Wired in Ear Earbuds, EPOS Adapt 660 vs Creative Zen Hybrid Gen: Hybrid ANC