AAUW’s mission is to advance gender equity for all girls and women as girls and women have historically been marginalized on the basis of gender. But feminized and gender-based forms of marginalization are intersectional, which means that, for some, marginalization occurs in many ways at the same time. For transgender women and girls they must, at the very least, deal with the same kinds of misogyny that many cisgender (1) women face on a daily basis AND, at the same time, deal with the kinds of hatred and erasure that comes along with being trans and nonbinary in the United States in this political moment.
When AAUW says that we support ALL girls and women, that means we always support transgender girls and women, and that we offer them extra support right now, at a time when their need is greatest.
As AAUW California has responded by engaging in personal and public advocacy for transgender rights and protections, the Public Policy team has also been fielding questions about how to best have conversations about transgender rights and issues. We started this guide to share out some of this guidance more broadly.
This guide is for anyone who wants to continue to be an ally to transgender and nonbinary people. It is meant to be a complement to existing guides, such as those produced by well-known gender equity and transgender and nonbinary support organizations such as:
While some of the existing guides already contain important information about inclusive language and terminology, the AAUW of California Public Policy guide is unique in that it specifically focuses on how to have everyday conversations about transgender and nonbinary social and policy issues, offering sample responses to common questions that members have encountered as they are engaged in allyship and advocacy work.
This guide is also a living document that will be updated regularly, based on AAUW California members’ and users’ questions. So if you have questions that you would like to see addressed, questions that you have as someone trying to be a better ally to transgender and nonbinary people and/or questions that you have encountered that you were not sure how to answer, please click THIS LINK to submit them. You can also access this link using the "Question Submissions Form" button below.
Being a good ally involves a lifetime of unlearning and relearning. This means that allyship work should be active, engaged, and ongoing. It should be driven by the wants and needs of the communities that you seek to be an ally to, for, and with.
Doing public policy, advocacy, and allyship work will most certainly require you to have conversations across difference. These conversations can be uncomfortable and difficult, but they are extremely important.
We thank you for having these conversations with others, for engaging in advocacy, and for using your power and privilege for the benefit of all. We hope that this guide is useful for you as you continue to engage in this important work.
(1) Cisgender or “cis” refers to anyone whose internal understanding of their gender aligns with both the sex they were assigned at birth and their external expressions of gender through things like clothing, hairstyle, and body. See the linked allyship guides for more information on sex/gender terminology.
The current socio-political climate in the United States is not supportive of, and is often openly hostile to, transgender and nonbinary people, a very small and increasingly targeted minority group in the United States (1.6% or less of the population). This hostility manifests as different kinds of overt exclusion and marginalization based on persistent beliefs about binary gender and subsequent gender stereotyping.
We have all encountered a moment when we have been told to dress, speak, or act in a certain way based on others’ assumptions about what we should be doing to live up to the ideals of a particular group: at work, at school, with friends, or at home. If the way you speak or act has ever been labeled as “too much” or “not enough”–too feminine, not masculine enough–you have been impacted by gender stereotyping.
However, while we may all be confronted with the constraints and impacts of gender stereotyping as we pick out our clothing, make decisions about our safety and health, or try to figure out how to advocate for ourselves at work, widespread stereotypes about gender disproportionately and more negatively impact transgender and nonbinary people.
The AAUW of California Public Policy guide specifically focuses on how to have everyday conversations about transgender and nonbinary social and policy issues. The bulk of this guide focuses on answering common questions about transgender rights and common statements in opposition to transgender rights, with an emphasis on areas that are currently the focus of legislative and policy attack, such as sports and youth healthcare access.
See the links in the "What & Why" section for access to more general allyship guides
See the "Why Trans Allyship Now" section for more information about why all women's and gender equity organizations should be invested in trans allyship
See the links in the "Common Questions" section for sample responses to common questions & statements that members have encountered as they have engaged in allyship and advocacy work.
Question & Statement Set 1: Fairness in Sports
Question: Trans girls should absolutely be allowed to participate in girls’ sports, if they transitioned before they reached puberty. Someone who goes through puberty as a male and then transitions to be female has gone through musculoskeletal development that makes them bigger and stronger. Isn’t this unfair to the girls they compete against?
Statement: Women who have worked hard to excel in athletics all their lives can lose opportunities like scholarships if they have to compete against a trans woman who transitioned after puberty. I think this is really unfair.
Statement: I want to support young trans girls participating in girls’ sports. But I don’t want to take away opportunities from young women who are trying to get into the Olympics, or young women trying to get a college scholarship, because they have to compete against a trans woman who has physical advantages. I don’t know how to reconcile these things.
CLICK HERE FOR SET 1 MODEL RESPONSES
Question & Statement Set 2: Safety in Sports
Statement: I think it’s unsafe for women to be in sports with trans women, who are much bigger and stronger.
CLICK HERE FOR SET 2 MODEL RESPONSES
Question & Statement Set 3: Advocacy Focus on Transgender Women & Girls
Question: Why should we focus on transgender women, when cisgender women are also under attack? I support the LGBTQ+ community but why do trans people need all the support right now?
SET 3 MODEL RESPONSES COMING SOON
Question & Statement Set 4: Young People & the Right to Transition
Question: Aren’t kids too young to make decisions about transitioning?
SET 4 MODEL RESPONSES COMING SOON