Power in Open Access Publishing

"By applying these bases of power to current discussions about open access and scholarly publishing we can gain a better understanding of interrelationships among groups"


Five Bases of Power

(French & Raven, 1959)

Black ink illustration of a lightning bolt.

Coercive

Power to threaten others with consequences if they do not do what you want.

Black ink illustration of a gem stone.

Reward

Power to grant a reward on others for doing something you want, and to withhold a reward for not doing what you want.

Black ink illustration of a scroll tied with a ribbon.

Legitimate

Power obtained through a position or role granted to you.

Black ink illustration of an apple.

Referent

Power obtained by association with a powerful group, stemming from the desire to please or respect that powerful group.

Black ink illustration of a book with a ribbon bookmark.

Expert

Power exercised through perception of your knowledge and trustworthiness as a source of information.

Stakeholders

As you think about the problems below, continue to keep these stakeholders in mind, and which type of power they exercise in relation with each other.

Black ink illustration of a clipboard with a vague graph.

Researchers

Black ink illustration of a laptop with squares and lines on the screen.

Librarians

Black ink illustration of a book with a lined globe on the cover.

Publishers

Black ink illustration of two speech bubbles overlapping slightly.

The Public

Examples:

Black ink illustration of a book with a lined globe on the cover.

Publishers


and

Black ink illustration of a clipboard with a vague graph.

Researchers

hold expert power over

Black ink illustration of two speech bubbles overlapping slightly.

The Public

Black ink illustration of a book with a lined globe on the cover.

Publishers

hold reward power over


Black ink illustration of a clipboard with a vague graph.

Researchers