This blog (if you can even call it that) exists for me to share my definitive rankings of discographies based on my patented FSONS systems. FSONS stands for "Five Stars Or No Stars." As a musician, music historian and all-around affable fella, I've come to the conclusion that songs are more important than albums. For what is an album if not a collection of songs? (Made you think, didn't I?) I've also recently finished editing all the ID tags for 77 terabytes worth of music files on Plex, a Sisyphean task I thought I'd never accomplish. To celebrate this fact, I've decided to actually listen to (at least some of) this music I've downloaded over the years (and paid a small fortune for, of course, naturally). But I simply cannot 'listen to music' — I have to gamify this simple, what-should-be-joyous human experience like a damn lunatic. Hence: this blog.
I've started with The Beatles because that feels like an appropriate place to start. I could have started with Bon Jovi or Joey Bada$$ or Freddy Fender or Paris Hilton, but I went with The Beatles (we'll get to those other guys, as well as every other guy, soon). So let me explain my process (using The Beatles as an example): I listen to every album in chronological order, marking all the 5-star songs on the Plex Amp app. I created a "smart playlist" within Plex so that all of these tracks are immediately added in perpetuity. I usually know within the first 30 seconds whether or not a track is 5-star caliber. I cannot really define what makes a song "5-star." The best way to explain it is like this: I think to myself, would I ever skip this track if it came up on shuffle via the aforementioned playlist? If the answer is yes or even maybe, then it is not a 5-star song. However (Part 1), if I'm on the fence about this, I will always push myself over the fence and err on the side of inclusion over exclusion. Because I always reserve the right to remove the 5-star rating at any point in the future, so why the hell not? However (Part 2), If I'm still on the fence at the ~1-minute mark, then I am not listening to a 5-star song. The 5-star songs — regardless of genre, mood, run-time — should be easy and obvious to identify. If I'm struggling after sixty seconds, then it's not 5 stars. Simple as that. For a band like The Beatles, the majority of their songs are going to register as 5-star based on my system. Now, not all 5-star songs are created equal, of course. This brings me to my next point...
The second component of this site (and perhaps the more important one) is to rank the discographies of these artists. I've had plenty of internal turmoil about how to go about this. But I think I've landed on a purely mathematical equation: albums will be ranked by the % of 5-star tracks on each LP. Now, but four albums into my initial discography run-through, I noticed what appeared to be a horrible glitch in the system (at first glance). The only 100% 5-star record was A Hard Day's Night and, conversely, Beatles for Sale, the 4th and most recent (to date) record, was in dead last. Is this also what I thought of the music? The full breakdown went as follows:
A Hard Day's Night - 13/13 FIVE-⭐ (100%)
Please Please Me - 12/14 FIVE-⭐ (86%)
With the Beatles - 11/14 FIVE-⭐ (79%)
Beatles for Sale - 10/14 FIVE-⭐ (71%)
To be honest, the first thing I think of when I look at that current ranking is WHO THE F CARES. This is arbitrary and meaningless to begin with, right? (Also, all of these albums are gonna get lapped by the later records and rightly so.) Still, I couldn't shake the feeling that this wasn't right, something was amiss. Until I looked closer.
Beatles for Sale certainly contains the best songwriting yet from the band, in isolation/microcosm (e.g., "I'm a Loser"), but it also features one of the most obnoxious Ringo-sang tunes: "Honey Don't" which is the first of two decidedly NOT 5-star Carl Perkins covers. The other no-brainer NOT 5-star tracks are also covers: "Mr. Moonlight" (Roy Lee Johnson) and "Kansas City/Hey-Hey-Hey-Hey!" (Leiber & Stoller/Richard Penniman). Conversely, A Hard Day's Night is the rare early LP that doesn't feature a single cover. Maybe this systems works after all, I thought.
There will inevitably be ties, %-wise. In the case of The Beatles there will almost certainly be multiple 100%-scoring albums. In this case, I will use my best judgment to decide the ranking. All 5-star songs are not created equal, after all. There are certain apex predator 5-star songs lurking. Of the 55 songs I've assessed thus far, I doubt there have been more than seven or eight which would garner this mysterious, intangible GOD status. (One non-Beatles 100% apex 5-star collection that comes to mind is Weezer's The Blue Album, for example.) These great white sharks of the 5-star song world will reveal themselves to me and only me. I will not be making their presence known. I've always felt intimidated when trying to write music criticism, in part because the very nature of it forces one to reveal or, rather, make sense of this almost cosmic force. It's always felt too big to unpack. That's why I've landed on this method, which is hardly more than a collection of lists. It feels both easy and wholly appropriate: AKA "The Sweet Spot". I'm excited to start listening to music again. This website has now given me permission to do so and I'm no longer embarrassed to admit that.
A note on non-album tracks: again, The Beatles are a good first artist to sort through this specific problem, because they have countless 5-star tracks that never appeared on their official albums (e.g., "She Loves You," "We Can Work It Out," etc.). In this case, I have isolated the collection Past Masters to include among the proper LP discog. This 1988 comp contains 33 tracks, which should include every relevant non-LP song release that would likely garner 5 stars. I will have no set way of handling this going forward. Whatever makes sense for each particular artist.
Thanks for checking out this website.
-MGMT