Investigating and comparison of Affordances on popular Open Source Learning Management Systems and undergraduate students’ usability evaluation of Moodle at the University of Zambia.
Investigating and comparison of Affordances on popular Open Source Learning Management Systems and undergraduate students’ usability evaluation of Moodle at the University of Zambia.
The aim of this study is to discover the teaching and learning features available of popular free and open source (FOSS) LMSs and understand the UNZA undergraduate student’s usability evaluation of Moodle.
Determining the affordances available on popular FOSS LMSs
Investigate the University of Zambia student’s usability evaluation of Moodle.
Understand the undergraduate’s usability evaluation of Moodle.
GAINING AN INSIGHT
Learning Management System, generally addressed as LMS system that makes advanced training easy and accessible. LMS is an application that can be deployed for the administration, management, and delivery of educational programs, training programs, or development programs. On any device, you can create, distribute, and track from anywhere by making use of LMS.
Teachers
Teachers use LMS software to upload and house digital course content. Those who teach online courses often use only an LMS for all of their teaching-related needs. In an LMS, teachers can upload and collect assignments and assessments, update student grades, track student progress, and more.
Students
Students use LMS tools to access course material, take online assessments, submit assignments, and track their progress throughout the duration of a course. The LMS, particularly for an online student, acts as the hub for all school-related activities.
Administrators
School administrators use the data gathered by LMS software to track student progress and report on key metrics. Often, administrators may integrate existing student information systems (SIS) with the LMS to facilitate a seamless transition of data from one system to another. In this way, they use an LMS to maintain a holistic view of student performance throughout their tenure at the educational institution.
What Types of Learning Management System (LMS) Exist?
Proprietary LMS
A proprietary LMS is a closed-source platform sold and maintained by a vendor. These LMS products are often more expensive than closed source due to the licensing fee that must be paid per user, in addition to annual and ongoing fees related to the subscription. Proprietary LMS is hosted by vendors on their own server, and they are responsible for managing and maintaining the platform. They also offer the benefit of strong external support in terms of tech support if anything goes wrong with the product, though this comes at an additional cost. The downside to a proprietary LMS is the limited integrations and customization, and that security and stability rests in the vendor’s hands.
Open-source LMS
An open-source LMS is freely distributed, does not require a licensing fee, and can be maintained and customized by the user. Compared to proprietary products, these open-source solutions allow for a greater level of accessibility and control. Users can personalize the platform to suits their specific needs, with plugins and new functionalities able to be added immediately and for free. The caveat is that organizations must have the infrastructure in place to run and support their open-source solution, as well as an IT team that is familiar with the platform. Managed service providers do exist for open-source LMS, though. While there are no hard costs with an open-source LMS, organizations may still find themselves spending just as much, if not more, as a proprietary LMS to implement and manage an open-source platform.
There are a lot of LMSes that exist on the public domain, both free and propriatory. Here are some examples;
Adobe Captivate Prime
Litmos LMS
Tovuti LMS
Paradiso Solutions
Moodle
Thinkific
iSpring Learn
ProProfs LMS Software
LearnWorlds
CANVAS LMS
Docebo
Knowledge Anywhere
Schoology
NEO LMS
eLucid
Innform
MagicBox
JollyDeck
Mintbook
Lessonly
D2L
Edmodo
Skillo
IPIX LMS
Chamilo LMS
Open edX
Blackboard LMS
LearnUpon
Teachable
LearningStone
Thought Industries
LatitudeLearning
Absorb LMS
Totara Learn
Inquisiq LMS
eFront
EduBrite
Trainual
WizIQ
Kiwi LMS
By using the LMS to share class materials, all students—regardless of whether they are in class or learning remotely—will have access to the lesson including objectives, activities and resources. Textbooks can even be shared online via software applications. Instead of students purchasing and lugging one giant textbook to and from school everyday, an up to date product can be integrated into the class page.
Resources are able to be sourced and disseminated in a diverse range of formats. This allows teachers to gather multiple resources on a topic or skill that will help students understand the context in a way that suits them. Videos and external sites can be embedded easily into the class pages to allow students ease of access as well as aesthetically engaging learning pages.
Parents and guardians can have access to their child’s calendar, class timetable, outline and assessment dates. This creates opportunities for conversation to meaningfully occur outside of class time and parents or guardians can actively engage in their child’s learning. For students who need help with organization, this can be a big help.
4. Enables diverse assessment options
Assessment can take place online via multiple formats in an LMS. Short quizzes, multiple choice, questionnaires all provide the opportunity to deliver immediate feedback. Teachers can also reference an external site including video formats and apply questions or topics from that stimulus. Students have the option to upload their work in multiple formats including screencasts, podcasts or video.
Feedback from a teacher for formative and summative tasks can be easily shared with the student via the class page of an LMS. These can also be sent onto the parental page and allows all feedback to be kept and stored so students can easily access and action in later tasks.
Schools can set up a variety of access points and groups to communicate learning via the Learning Management System. Class pages, home rooms, year level or house pages are common.
7. Tracking student data
Data from student assessment and attendance can be stored in the LMS and used to provide progression with learning. Those students who need extra support across subjects can also be easily identified. Likewise, students who are gifted and talented in more than one subject can be highlighted.
When uploading assessments, due dates, task requirements, criteria and information regarding a formative or summative task, an LMS allows teachers to automatically populate into the students’ calendar. This then helps students plan their homework and assignment time as they can see all of their tasks for the week, month and term and also add in extracurricular and personal commitments. It is also possible to share the calendar with parents or guardians.
By digitizing curriculum, students have access to the same unit outlines and resources regardless of what class they are in and creates cohesion and equitable access across the grade. Units can also be archived for the following year, eradicating the notion of recreating work. Teachers can then use this archive feature to reflect upon, review and improve units for the following year.
And finally, using an LMS enables learning to take place in a variety of places, including the child’s home. Setting up digital spaces to deliver education acts as a safeguard to provide continuity to students in instances where schools need to transition to remote teaching with little warning.
ourse creation and management:
Instructors can create and manage structured learning content and set user permissions to control how students access content. With an LMS, instructors can add a variety of media to enhance their syllabus, including text, images, videos, links, interactive tests, slideshows, and more. Teachers can upload entire courses and modules, enroll students or enable self-enrollment, and see individual reports on each student. These learning materials can be uploaded all at once, allowing students to follow along with content for the course's length synchronously or asynchronously.
Course calendars:
Instructors can set all upcoming course activities on a calendar for student access. This allows students to stay on top of all assignments and upcoming tests, and to see real-time updates when due dates change.
Online assessment:
Instructors can create and customize tests for students to access and submit online. Most platforms will support a variety of question types, such as multiple choice, drag and drop, essay, true or false, and agreement scale. From there, instructors can grade assignments and post scores online for students to access. Additionally, in-person assessments can also be uploaded and graded on the LMS.
Attendance management:
Some LMS products allow instructors to track student attendance for classes and events, whether the student was late or absent. These attendance reports can then be viewed online by students to see where they stand in the class.
Discussion boards:
Instructors and students can create discussion topics for the purpose of completing specific assignments, continuing in-class discussions, or soliciting end-of-semester feedback. Students can respond to individual threads and edit their comments. Instructors can also set time limits on discussion access, which motivates students to respond within the given timeframe. Typically, all discussions will also be timestamped. Discussion boards give teachers one more tool to assess overall student competency in a particular subject.
Gamification:
Certain LMSs contain gaming elements, which may include badges and leaderboards. The gamified environment is designed to create a more engaging learning experience for students and promote social learning. In addition to tracking their grades, students are encouraged to work toward acquiring various pieces of digital approval directly in the system.
Teacher communications:
Instructors can send messages to students directly within the LMS or via email, which usually integrates with the LMS. This allows teachers and students to have 1:1 discussions related to student performance or further discussion of class topics. Teachers can also set reminders and notifications to alert students of upcoming deadlines whenever they access the LMS.
Dashboards:
Dashboards allow instructors to organize all relevant information and keep it clean for viewing and tracking specific data. These interfaces can be customized to suit user needs and could include data such as average class grade, student attendance, assignment submission statistics, and student access time.
Reporting:
All LMS products contain some type of reporting feature. These reports are either prebuilt (in which case the user has only a limited number of offerings that are already in existence) or customizable. These may include reports on participation, learner progress, access time, quizzes, course activity, and more.
Student profiles:
Students can create and manage their own user profile within the LMS, which helps build social relationships with classmates during discussions and helps instructors to recognize their students more easily. These profiles can also contain contact information if teachers or classmates need to reach out to them.
choosing the right LMS may not be an easy task. it may help to consider the qualities of a good LMS on the table below.
Click Table 1 to view table.
Some most popular free and open source LMSes
Moodle
Canvas
Sakai
Chamilo