March 31, 2025.
Shanda Hunt from UMN Libraries, Jacob Dunlap and Jamie Stenberg from the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, Wyatt Pickner from AICAF.
How to navigate research ownership, authorship, and data sovereignty
How can you ensure that credit is given when credit is due? How do you manage authorship concerns? What considerations should you have with data ownership and sovereignty when working with partners?
Slides | Recording | Evaluation - Please provide feedback even if you simply watched the recording
UMN Office of Native American Affairs (NAA) - tools and research resources
The Collaboratory for Indigenous Data Governance (indigenousdatalab.org)| Indigenous Data Sovereignty Networks | recorded Webinars
The CARE Principles of Indigenous Data Governance (Video)
Indigenous Data Sovereignty: How Researchers can Empower Data Governance (Video)
Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Governance – Stephanie Carroll (Video)
Indigenous Data Stewards: Bridging from Research to Community – Dr. Domonique M David-Chavez (Video)
Works in Progress Webinar Operationalizing the CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance (Video)
Owning and managing academic rights (UMN Libraries Guide)
Research data services and the NIH data management and sharing policy, Libraries
Consultations - Data management plans, data sharing, data management for specific projects, Libraries
Data Repository for U of M (DRUM) focused on being Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable (FAIR), Libraries
Center for Global Health and Social Responsibility (CGHSR) Research Toolkit - data sharing in collaborative research
Copyright ownership & Open Access to Scholarly Articles
Research Data Management: Archiving, Ownership, Retention, Security, Storage, and Transfer & Research Data Management FAQs
Research Misconduct "Research Misconduct: The fabrication or falsification of data, research procedures, or data analysis; destruction of data for fraudulent purposes; plagiarism; abuse of confidentiality; or other fraudulent actions in proposing, performing, reviewing, or reporting the results of research or other scholarly activity. It is particularly important to distinguish research misconduct from honest error and the ambiguities of interpretation that are inherent in the scientific and scholarly process, but are normally corrected by further research."
Defining the Role of Authors and Contributors (ICMJE authorship guidelines)
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Scientific Integrity - Best Practices for Designating Authorship
Harvard Medical School Authorship Guidelines
Center for Global Health and Social Responsibility (CGHSR) Research Toolkit - Best practices for research authorship, data collection, and data sharing in collaborative research
Each publication has authorship guidelines as a part of editorial policies. some. Individual and group or consortia authorship are often indicated. Examples:
AACR Journals - Editorial Policies
Nature Cancer - Authorship & Nature Portfolio Authorship
Council of Science Editors - Authorship and Authorship Responsibilities
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (CMJE) - Defining the role of Authors and Contributors, 4 criteria for authorship:
"Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work; AND
Drafting the work or reviewing it critically for important intellectual content; AND
Final approval of the version to be published; AND
Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved."
Authorship disputes are not considered research misconduct (video) in the National Institutes of Health - institutions or journals handle it, not the National Institutes of Health. NIH Definition of research misconduct, Research Misconduct & Detrimental Research Practices: Overview & Case Studies (October 14, 2022 NIH 2022 video)
UMN Libraries: Owning and managing academic rights
UMD: Writer's Workshop
UMN Twin Cities: Faculty Writing Hunkers
UMN RIO - Research Ethics Week | Reporting Research Misconduct
05/31/2024 17:31 minutes Audio: Indigenous Nations Are Fighting To Take Back Their Data, Science Friday, featuring
Stephanie Carroll, Director Collaboratory for Indigenous Data Governance
Krystal Tsosie, Co-founder of the Native BioData Consortium
02/06/2024 Article: Inside the Fight for Indigenous Data Sovereignty written by Kate Nelson
2019 Book: Good Data Practices for Indigenous Data Sovereignty Author Stephanie Russo Carroll Jennifer Walker Tahu Kukutai (373 pages) on the Native Nations Institute webpage
2017: Policy Brief: Indigenous Data Sovereignty in the United States by the Native Nations Institute
See Resources on the Collaboratory for Indigenous Data Governance and Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Governance of the Native Nations Institute
Collaboratory for Indigenous Data Governance, Stephanie Carroll, Director
08/12/2024 project: $1.5M grant will build global network to prevent exploitation of Indigenous data, University of Arizona News
05/23/2023 UArizona researcher at the forefront of Indigenous data sovereignty
Global Indigenous Data Alliance (GIDA)
CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance - Collective Benefit, Authority to Control, Responsibility, Ethics (CARE)
Go FAIR, Go FAIR US
FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship - Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable (FAIR)
Native BioData Consortium
Wayfinding through the Human Genome - Dr Keolu Fox
United States Indigenous Data Sovereignty Network (USIDSN)
Local Contexts Traditional Knowledge Labels and Notices - notices can be incorporated into data repositories (Notices: Biocultural, Traditional Knowledge, Attribution Incomplete, Open to Collaborate)
2021: Lydia Jennings to the National Center for Ecological Analysis & Synthesis.
See description in YouTube of the additional resources and chapters.
Dr. Keolu Fox's work was also mentioned (also see - Wayfinding through the Human Genome and Why genetic research must be more diverse)
2021 A 6:38 minute video by Dr. Stephanie Russo Carroll
23 November 2021 Ontologies in Agriculture
Transforming Big Data for Indigenous Futures - the CARE Principles of Indigenous Data Governance
Dr. Stephanie R. Carroll, DrPh, MPH
Talia Anderson, PhD Student
4:11 "Indigenous Peoples and Data 101:
Sovereignty Matters
Data are our relations
Data are critical to the exercise of tribal sovereignty and ensuring healthy, vibrant, communities
Only Indigenous Peoples / nations can exercise Indigenous data sovereignty
Enacting Indigenous data sovereignty includes both data for governance and the governance of data
Tribally-driven data work requires relationships with other data actors and experts for both stewardship and expertise
Assertions of Indigenous data sovereignty spur innovation and design in data and research policy and practice"
5:19 Our peoples have always been data experts
6.08 What are Indigenous Data?
15:00 Institutional Responsibilities for Indigenous Data Governance, Center CARE principles in the development of data policy and platforms
Enrich metadata (provenance, permissions, attribution, and protocols) [more at 15.36 and Local Contexts overview]
Recognize Indigenous intellectual property through appropriate authorship and acknowledgement [more at 19.21]
Protect both personal and community identifiable information [more at 21:00]
Formalize voluntary guidelines [more at 23.47]
Track data use and reuse [more at 25.16]
2020 OCLC Research
Meta Data Standards and Notices within repositories and data collections
2020 Jane Anderson, Associate Professor, Faculty of Arts and Science, and Stephanie Russo Carroll, Assistant Professor, Udall Center for Studies in Public Policy; Associate Director, Native Nations Institute at the University of Arizona