Synopsis: A species of prehistoric sand tiger shark evolved so that it became an actual Sand Shark, able to swim through sand like water and attack people on the beach, disrupting a big beach party the town was going to host.
Species Featured:
Sand Tiger Shark (Striatolamia macrota)
*one of the few times a scientific name was identified in the film
Overall thoughts: This movie was ridiculous, but as far as watchability goes it wasn’t the worst. The shark itself, however, was the least accurate. Even though a species was named, the shark depicted in the film was nothing like it. Science Fiction with a heavy preference towards fiction.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
The movement in the film is much floppier and overdramatic than the much more specific and controlled movement of sharks, especially for slow-moving species as the Sand Tiger
The film's shark growls, which is not a behavior sharks have
Taxonomy:
In the story, the sand sharks were brought up to the surface from earthquakes, which is why these prehistoric sharks are here. That is not how species de-extinction works.
Feeding:
Depicted targeting people as prey, both pulling people into the sand to eat or jumping out of the sand and intercepting people mid air
Chews on electric wires, which some sharks have been depicted doing due to the small electric current being emitted from the wires attracting the electroreception of sharks.
Morphology:
Their skin is depicted as scaly and lizard-like. S. macrota did not have reptilian skin, as they had dermal denticles.
The films depiction of S. macrota does not have a hetercercal tail
Social:
Shark is depicted hunting alone, which is accurate to the solitary hunting of Sand Tiger Sharks. However, only one shark is depicted as being around the area, where Sand Tiger Sharks are known to have complex social groups for some non-hunting behaviors.
Habitat:
The sharks are depicted swimming in sand. Sharks cannot do this, as they need to get oxygen from the water in order to breathe
Synopsis: While people are gathered on an island for a Singles Retreat, a toxic shark is haunting their waters. The shark bites and sprays people with an acidic toxin made mostly of arsenic. The toxin corrodes metal and turns people into cannibalistic zombies.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Overall thoughts: This movie is labeled as a horror but should be a comedy because of how bad it is. It is only above Sand Sharks because this shark swims in the water and isn’t as much of a horrendous leap in evolution.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
Depicted bursting out of the water roaring, but real sharks do not roar threateningly
The swimming depicted is innacurrate to the real locomotion of Great Whites
Taxonomy:
There were very few clear or accurate defining features of this shark to properly identify which species it was. It is classified as a Great White due to the countershading present and the general body shape, and based on the pattern of most shark films using Great Whites as their beast
Feeding:
Targets people, which is incorrect
Eating mechanism is all wrong, the shark is depicted chewing which sharks do not do
Morphology:
The Toxic Shark is depicted with a dorsal spout anterior to its dorsal fin from which green toxic ooze shoots from. There is no known shark species that have, let alone spray, toxins like this. There is also never a scientific justification offered in the film about the presence and development of this specialized toxic organ.
The toxin corrosive and later revealed to be comprised mainly of arsenic. Therefore, it is depicted turning people into cannibalistic mindless zombies under the guise of arsenic poisoning, even though the behaviors displayed by the infected are not in line with real symptoms of arsenic poisoning.
The toxin is also depicted as being able to spread between people via bites
Social:
Depicted as a solitary hunter, which Great Whites are
Habitat:
This shark is at least in the water, placing it above Sand Sharks (2012)
The temperate to warm waters around the island would be a place that some juvenile to adult Great Whites could be found
Synopsis: A huge storm picks up in Santa Monica, CA, bringing hurricanes and tornadoes of sharks flying everywhere and eating people.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Great Hammerheads (Sphyrna mokarran)
Tiger Sharks (Galeocerdo cuvier)
Thresher Sharks (Alopias pelagicus)
Overall thoughts: This movie was worse than I remember it being. It was also infinitely funnier with the bad CGI. But, it terribly miscategorized shark behavior.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
Sharks would not fly through the air and still be actively alive and hunting
They move like a sine wave and not like a shark
At one point, a shark lands on the asphault and leaves a shark-shaped dent in the ground. Shark bodies are not stronger than the ground, so this would not happen.
Taxonomy:
Most of the shark designs are too nondescript to confidently identify them. The Great Hammerhead was identified due to the distinct head shape, the Tiger shark was identified due to its head shape and coloration, and the Thresher shark had its unique large upper caudal lobe. But the body shapes, fin shapes, and size differentiation of the sharks in the Sharknado are not very detailed.
Feeding:
A lot of the feeding happens out of the water, whether the sharks are flying and intercept their prey mid-air , or the sharks are jumping up onto boats and eating people there, the sharks are targeting people specifically.
It appears as though the sharks are ready and eating at almost any time, as anytime something intercepts their path while flying, it gets eaten. This is not at all how feeding works.
Sharks also would not attack a beach full of people in a coordinated mass-effort, which they are shown to do in the film.
Sharks would not swarm the beach, attack a bunch of people, then simply swim right back out into the open ocean
A shark would not bite through metal, like a car roof, in order to open it and eat the people inside. That would be too energetically costly and harmful to the shark.
Morphology:
The CGI shark models are very smooth and more carry the idea of a shark than the accuracy of one.
Social:
The film mentions the sharks moving in "a pod of 20,000 sharks". Only a few species move in large groups, and even then none of those shark groups get anywhere near 20,000 individuals.
The "pod" was also made up of multiple species that are not known to travel together
Habitat:
This film takes place off of the coast of Southern California, with the storm coming up from Mexico. Two of the most easily identifiable species in the film are the Great Hammerhead and the Tiger shark, neither of which are found in California.
Sharks are also shown to swim in the beach because of the storms, which has been documented to happen in places where hurricanes hit, such as Florida.
A storm like this would not happen in California.
Synopsis: A giant two-headed shark is terrorizing the oceans around a group of Semester at Sea students, trapping them on a sinking atoll.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Blue Shark (Prionace glauca)
Overall thoughts: Hard watch. It’s ranked above Sharknado because this one nerd character carried with the scientific explanations that weren’t absolutely abhorrent.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
The shark roars, growls, and snarls constantly. It even curls its lip back at some point. Sharks do not do this.
The tail movement is very floppy, swinging too far side to side rather than the focused powerful movements of a real Great White tail.
The two heads of the animal appear to think and operate independently, as they are shown to work together to tear things apart.
Taxonomy:
Evolutionarily, since this shark was shown to be a voracious hunter due to its two heads (and therefore heightened senses and twice the teeth), is it possible that if the shark had lived long enough to reproduce, this mutation would lead to a subpopulation of two-headed sharks?
Feeding:
Shark is shown to follow and specifically attack boats, at some points even eating the boat itself.
When the 2-Headed Shark hunts, it's eyes do not roll back into its head, which is a distinct feature of Great Whites to protect their eyes from damage while they hunt
The film also plays heavily on the fact that the motor of the boats was attracting the shark, making it want to eat the boat and the people on it. Their justification is that since the shark has two heads, it has even more sensory input. However, if the shark did have heightened senses, the motor would likely not attract it as a prey item, but rather overwhelm it and make it avoid the motors, as most animals do not like ship noise.
Morphology:
This shark is gigantic, so much so that it was unclear if it was a Megalodon or not. However, after some pondering, it was more clearly (poorly) modeled after a Great White.
It does however have 5 gill slits, which is accurate to Great Whites
The two-headed mutation is a complex one, as they are split and developed enough to be more like Siamese twins. I do not think this has been observed in any adult sharks in the wild, but that does not mean it could not happen in some extreme cases. However, an individual like this would not be likely to survive in the wild (this is commented on in the film!).
The jaws move like autostylic jaws, but Great White sharks have hyostylic jaws
The 2-Headed Shark is depicted with correct fins, and do not have claspers. The shark is referred to as female in the film, so at least they got that part correct.
Social:
The 2-Headed Shark is a solitary hunter, which is accurate for Great Whites
Habitat:
Found circling the atoll in warmer waters, which is a place Great Whites can be found
Often depicted in waist-deep water, which would definitely beach an animal the size of the 2-Headed Shark but is never shown to be an issue in the film.
A Blue Shark is mentioned in the tragic backstory of our final girl, where she mentions that it came right up to her when she was at the beach as a child, but Blue Sharks are open water species and do not tend to approach the beach. If they absolutely have to, they might be found in shallower waters, but they would not choose to be there to hunt.
Synopsis: A kid named Max is called to action to save his dream world Drool from The Darkness. Sharkboy is a boy raised by sharks because his Marine Biologist dad was separated from him as a child.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Knifefish “Electric Eel” (Electrophorus electricus)
Overall thoughts: Personally, this was my favorite watch of this project. I had to suspend a bit of disbelief since the setting of this film is in a child’s dreams, so the fact that the sharks talk is disregarded from scientific accuracy as part of the worldbuilding.
I have a Film Theory that the storm that separated Sharkboy from his father is the same storm as the Sharknado, but that's a conversation for another day.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
Sharkboy can run, swim, breakdance, and sing. Most of these features are attributable to his human side.
He has super speed and super strength, neither of which are shark features.
His dorsal fin sliced through a block of solid, magic ice with no damage. Cartilage is not that strong.
Taxonomy:
Sharkboys existance raises the age old Icthyological question "Are Humans Fish?" Some phylogenetic classifications include humans, whereas others do not. But, would Sharkboy be the type of blend to confidently answer that with a yes? Where is the line drawn before a no becomes a yes?
This film features Electric Eels as well, which look like eels (Anguilliformes) with lightning around them in the film, but Electric Eels are actually Knifefishes, therefore this representation is innacurate.
Feeding:
The Great Whites sit up in the water like seals when being fed by Shark Boy, a behavior that they do not exhibit in real life.
Morphology:
As Shark Boy grew from being raised by the sharks, he started to develop shark features:
Shark Boy grew gills, but they were placed on his ribs and not on his neck nor near the preauricular pit, which is a hole on the top of the ear that some people have as remnants of gills.
Shark Boy grew talons for claws, but sharks do not have claws nor talons
Shark Boy's teeth sharpened, but only the bottom ones. The teeth were depicted in rows, though, so that is not totally bogus.
Shark Boy grew fins, "all sorts of fins"; from what is seen, he grew a dorsal fin, but from what is implied, he grew many of the rest of them as well. Therefore, it is reasonable to believe that Shark Boy might have claspers.
Social:
This film does beautifully portray sharks as gentle and curious rather than as the monsters of the sea, which is appreciated.
They are, however, shown to exhibit parental care in the film, which Great Whites do not do.
They are also shown to talk. This part was not weighed in this ranking, since that was lumped into suspending disbelief in the worldbuilding of this story being a dream.
Sharkboy says that "his instincts tell him so" after knowing something about a character that otherwise wouldn't be known, implying that his instincts make him psychic. As far as science knows, sharks are not psychic. That would be really cool though.
Habitat:
The sharks are shown to live in a massive group in a cave. Great Whites are a pelagic species and must constantly be moving in order to keep water over their gills (a fact they mention in the film!), so they would not be using water caves as their home.
Synopsis: Drug dealers had to recover their drop from a spot in the ocean, but the main character is an undercover government agent there to bust their system. Also, the area of the drop is surrounded by Great Whites.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Overall thoughts: Since it's the same director as Sharknado, it has about the same level of CGI, but this one is a bit more down to Earth. Still not incredibly accurate portrayal of shark behavior, but it clearly wasn’t the worst.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
The shark is shown to ram the boat to jostle the people on it, which sharks would not do.
The shark is shown to jump out of the water and hold onto the crate of drugs with its jaws and hold on as the helicopter flies away. Sharks would not do this, as it is a waste of energy, would take them out of the water, and not benefit them in any way.
Taxonomy:
The sharks look mostly like a real Great White does.
Feeding:
Sharks pull people under and purposefully hit the boat in this movie in order to get to the people to eat them, which is a behavior sharks do not exhibit.
They are also shown to jump out of the water and eat people, which is wrong
A shark is shown to slowly glide towards a person with its mouth open and eat them. If a shark wanted to eat something, it wouldn't cruise towards them, mouth already open. A Great White would attack fast and purposeful.
Morphology:
The build of the shark is mostly accurate. The fins were on the more nondescript side but from what was visible everything was there. Some might have been missing claspers, but those also could be female.
Social:
The opening scene depicts a large group of Great Whites swarming the boat to hunt, when Great Whites are not pack hunting animals.
Habitat:
This film takes place off of the coast of Miami, Florida, which is a place where Great Whites are technically able to be found, though sightings are rare. Great Whites would likely not be the shark causing issues for the characters in this film.
Synopsis: The US Navy is secretly breeding sharks to be used as weapons in the war, and all of these people are stuck on a submarine that keeps getting attacked by sharks.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Overall thoughts: Even though it made it to top 5, the sharks are still depicted inaccurate and monstrous. Generally, not a particularly captivating movie either.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
The sharks are depicted smashing into the submarine hull that holds the people inside, which it would not be compelled to do. A shark would not injure itself by ramming into a solid large object in the hopes that there was something inside. Too much risk, too low reward.
The sharks snarl and rattle like dinosaurs, which is not a vocal behavior that sharks exhibit.
The people are able to "electronically subdue" the sharks, making them unreactive to external stimulus and therefore preventing them from attacking the people. This could be attributed to the fact that these sharks are trained by the Navy to be weapons, but that fact is not explicitly tied to the subduing in the film. Sharks cannot be electronically subdued in real life.
Taxonomy:
The sharks in this film are able to be trained, which is underexplored in sharks. Some behavioral studies with other shark species (not other mackerel sharks, but reef sharks and perhaps others) have been done, which raises the question: Would people be able to train sharks to be weapons as depicted in this film? And if they could, should they? No.
Feeding:
Great White sharks are depicted purposefully eating people. Which again, is wrong.
The eating mechanism itself is wrong, whether it is from a CGI error or the poor understanding of how sharks eat, but it looked like chewing.
Morphology:
The sharks themselves did look accurately like Great Whites, even with the mediocre quality of the shark special effects.
Social:
At one point, the characters exclaim that the sharks hit the submarine in a "coordinated sub attack". Sharks are not known to coordinate their attacks like some marine mammals do, especially not the solitary hunters that are Great Whites.
Habitat:
The sharks are kept in large tanks in the submarine, though some are in the surrounding waters. Great Whites are famously difficult to keep in captivity due to their constant need for movement, therefore this captivity would not be possible.
Synopsis: A new ecosystem is discovered under a false ocean bottom of hydrogen gas. Once scientists breach it, the Megalodon that has been living down there is released to the surface.
Species Featured:
Megalodon (Carcharocles megalodon)
Overall thoughts: As a more modern movie, this one did have a decent amount of scientific accuracy. There were a few blaringly obvious things that wouldn’t really work, but overall it wasn’t abhorrent. Enjoyable watch as well.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
In one scene, the Megalodon jumps out of the water to eat the carcass of another animal, then lands on the boat and writhes itself off. The large size and build of the Megalodon, alongside its typical prey choice of large cetaceans and other sharks, suggest that the Megalodon would not breach in order to feed, especially if the prey was a carcass.
The swimming mechanism of the Megalodon was well done. The gliding through the water and swimming up from below was overall well done.
Taxonomy:
The Megalodon is referred to as a "living fossil", which is an inaccurate oxymoron. Even though a Megalodon being alive today would imply that it has not evolved much beyond how it was in the Early Miocene to Early Pliocene epochs, it is still not going to be exactly the same as it was during that time period.
Feeding:
The Megalodon is depicted targeting and feeding on people. The size of the Megalodon suggest that it is an adult, and therefore would require larger prey items to sustain itself. It would likely not waste energy chasing and eating people.
Specifically, there is one scene where there is a beach full of people, and yet the Megalodon swims past hundreds of them to eat this one guy in a giant floatable hamster ball. A shark would not choose the one item wrapped in plastic in order to eat when there was a plethora of food.
Morphology:
The design of the Megalodon in this film was surprisingly well done. It is distinctly not an oversized Great White, as many other media wrongly depicts Megalodons, and it was built as a Megalodon likely would be.
Social:
The Megalodon is depicted as a solitary hunter, which is accurate based on what is known about their hunting behavior.
Habitat:
This film follows the theory that the Mariana Trench is a false bottom and that there is a whole ecosystem below, which is where Megalodons are. Even if there was a secret deep sea bottom, the Megalodon was not a deep sea species. The environment of a secret deep sea pocket would not be ideal for the Megalodon to live, and even if it was, Megalodons fed on large megafauna such as whales, which would not be able to live in these deep sea pockets. Therefore, there would be evidence of a Megalodon existing if they did due purely to the impact of the ocean around them.
Synopsis: Based loosely on the 1916 Jersey Shore Attacks, a Great White is attacking the small town of Amity Island, and some fisherman are tasked to find it and kill it.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Overall thoughts: Though it is an older film that put shark films in the limelight, this is a cult classic and I really enjoyed this movie. The shark is not the most accurate, but they actually built it rather than editing it in later, and thats neat. Bruce my beloved animatronic.
Fun fact: the shark on the poster is not a Great White, its a Mako!
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
Since this film is from 1975, the shark is made from an animatronic. Therefore, the swimming and jaw movement mechanics are clunky and inaccurate, but were pretty high definition for the time.
Taxonomy:
The Great White in the film was overall mediocrely designed, but it was clear enough what shark it was.
Feeding:
The Jaws shark is shown to chew, using an autostylic jaw rather than the hyostylic jaw that Great Whites have.
The Great White also targets people, chasing boats and eventually doing enough damage to sink the boat. Even though this film was based loosely on a true story, those were beach attacks and not boat attacks.
Morphology:
Some key fins and body parts were missing in the design of the shark, such as anal fins and claspers.
The eyes were beady and entirely black, not showing any of the white.
Social:
The shark is a solitary hunter, which is accurate.
Habitat:
The shark is found off of the coast of Amity Island, in warm to temperate waters and coming up to shallower beaches as well as being further out, which is accurate.
Synopsis: Two sisters, one of which is not dive certified, go on a tourist cage dive with sharks when the cage snaps and drops them to the bottom of the ocean where they must do what they can to survive.
Species Featured:
Great White (Carcharodon carcharias)
Overall thoughts: This movie did decently well with the scientific accuracy. There were still some more minor inaccuracies and exaggerations, but overall not a bad movie.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
The swimming, speed, turns, etc. are all pretty accurately depicted.
Taxonomy:
The design of the sharks are clearly Great Whites, exhibiting features of mackerel sharks.
Feeding:
The Great Whites are depicted hunting near the seafloor, hence why the girls are so afraid. Great Whites are not benthic hunters, as most of their preferred prey are pelagic.
The sharks are specifically targeting people, which is inaccurate.
The sharks are also shown to eat inanimate objects, mainly for fear factor.
Morphology:
One character mentions that he sees Great Whites get up to 28 feet long. However, the largest recorded sharks is ~20ft long, and her name was Deep Blue.
Social:
The Great Whites in this film are shown in small groups, which is not unlikely. When they hunt, they are hunting by themselves. Therefore, occasional group travel but solitary hunter, which is accurate.
Habitat:
Great Whites would be found in the warmer tropical waters off of the coast of Mexico, as shown in the film.
This note is not about the sharks, but when the cage that the girls were in dropped to the seafloor, the rapid pressure change would kill them. Overall, though, the processes of SCUBA diving and the concerns that come with it were pretty accurate. Most of the issues with this film were the inaccuracies with the people, not so much the sharks.
Synopsis: Tells the true story of Bethany Hamilton, a professional surfer who loses her arm in a shark attack then relearns to surf.
Species Featured:
Tiger Shark (Galeocerdo cuvier)
Overall thoughts: Though the shark in this film was not featured very often, the parts where it was were tasteful and accurately reflected real shark behavior. There was no fear mongering around sharks, and the attack was presented as part of the occupational hazards of surfing.
hehe spaceholder secrets
Movement:
There was no crazy thrashing, no growling, no gnashing. The shark quietly came up, took a taste, and left once it didn't want the people.
Taxonomy:
The Tiger shark was accurately depicted.
Feeding:
The Tiger shark came up from below curiously and took a bite of her arm, which is accurate to how many shark attacks happen. To the sharks, they are just taking a taste. To weaker human bodies, that often means permanent injury and sometimes death.
The shark was not weirdly targeting people!
Morphology:
Only the head of the shark was shown in the film, but it had the Tiger Sharks wider square face, big eyes, and distinct coloration.
Social:
The shark is shown alone, which is a common way to find Tiger sharks despite their complex social groups.
Habitat:
Tiger sharks are commonly found in the warm waters off of the coast of Hawaii.