November 17 and 18, 2022

Epistemic Injustice in the Medical Context

Hybrid Conference -- online and in-person

About

One manifestation of epistemic injustice occurs in asymmetric relations, such as between patients and physicians. Indeed, expert testimony is often deemed more credible than the testimony of non-experts, putting patients at a disadvantage.



Yet the medical context is unlike many other social contexts, in that the asymmetrical relationships between physicians and patients are maintained with good reason. Physicians help patients make choices. Yet, there are agential and structural prejudices against patients that put patients at risk of being misunderstood, not listened to, or denied proper medical care.



The conference will deepen investigations into the ways that injustice manifests in asymmetric relations. It will focus on complex identities in epistemic injustice with the aim of questioning how patients can evaluate the testimony of physicians, including when is it rational for laypersons to believe authority, under what conditions can a listener gain knowledge by testimony, on what basis should we trust the testimony of others, and when testimonial exchanges are unjust.

In particular, this conference asks

How can we ensure a healthy relationship between patients and physicians?

What other harms are inherent in asymmetrical relationships?

How can medical institutions ensure patients are not disadvantaged?

This conference brings together a diverse group of thinkers from across the U.S., Europe, and South America.

The Participants

Gloria Andrada

Nova University Lisbon

Sven Bernecker

University of California, Irvine

Havi Carel

University of Bristol

Annalisa Coliva

University of California, Irvine

Eric Bayruns Garcia

Harvard University

Rena Beatrice Goldstein

University of California, Irvine

Ian James Kidd

About this person

Rebecca Anne Korf

University of California, Irvine

Anna Lewis

Harvard University

Natalia Nealon

University of California, Irvine

Tanuj Raut

University of California, Irvine

Janyne Sattler

Federal University of Santa Catarina

Lucienne Spencer

University of Birmingham

Heather Marie Stewart

Oklahoma State University

Gustavo Velázquez-Quintana

University of California, Irvine

Alistair Wardrope

University of Sheffield

Where

HG 1002

University of California, Irvine