How does Gifted Education Affect a Students' Wellbeing?
How does Gifted Education Affect a Students' Wellbeing?
You may be thinking, what makes a child gifted anyway? According to Sampson (2018), a gifted student is intellectually superior to their peers, but requires special care to support their emotional, social, and scholastic intellect. One of the most important things to remember is that while gifted kids may be intellectually beyond their years, their mentality may not be as mature as their intelligence (Jacobs, 2018). A kid could be solving college level math problems as a freshman in high school, but may be unable to deal with the loss or rejection of a friend. Out of all the children in this world, gifted kids make up 6% of the student population (Trotter, 2019). Unfortunately, there is little to no research on what happens to these gifted kids once they leave school, so we are forced to focus on students while they are still in school, specifically middle to high school students (Kaufman, 2019).
As pre-service educators, we should know what to look for in our students while also understanding what they are going through. In a study provided by the Archives of Neuropsychiatry that determined what mental health struggles were common in students, gifted students were tested for social isolation, sensitivity, adaptation, various forms of anxiety, attention deficit, ect. (Eren et al., 2018). These students were given tests, such as the Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory (PedsQL) and the Children Depression Rating Scale Revised (CDRS-R), that were specifically designed to uncover and locate where students were having the highest amounts of mental health difficulties (Eren et al., 2018). One of the most obvious challenges that gifted students face is being socially excluded, causing them to choose between a social life and their academic future (Jacobs, 2018). When a child is identified as gifted, they are then placed into classes with like minded students and do not mingle with the rest of their peers causing an imbalance in their friend groups. If schools place academically proficient kids with other kids of the same mindset, they then feel forced to perform on the same academic level as their friends. It is not on purpose, but it is what happens when gifted children become isolated from their peers. With the constant pressure placed upon them to overachieve, it would make sense that those same students would feel an overwhelming sense of failure if they don't meet or exceed school expectations as well as their own (Sampson, 2013). I know I would constantly be asking myself if I was doing enough because I would compare my work ethic to my classmates. If gifted students continuously keep having to ask themselves if they are enough, they are more susceptible to having poor mental health. Studies show that gifted students were said to have poorer emotional health when compared to their peers (Eren et al., 2018). Eventually, these students can end up being disinterested in schooling because of the lack of moral support that they are given. With everything being thrown at them, it further proves why these students have higher rates of suicide due to the overwhelming pressures and lack of support they are given to combat these struggles that they face (Kaufman, 2019).
Thankfully, there was research conducted by Sampson (2013) that gave us insight into the inner workings of gifted children and what makes them different from their peers. There are five traits that can help identify gifted children and give us a better understanding of how they think and why they react the way they do.
Psychomotor intensity is an “oversupply of energy” that describes the hyperactivity that gifted students often experience (Sampson, 2018). Some examples of this can be the shaking of a leg, constant squirming, nail biting, and speaking out of turn.
Sensual Intensity, according to Sampson (2018), is when a gifted child experiences an increased awareness of the five senses: hearing, seeing, smelling, tasting, and touching. An overwhelming amount of stimuli from any of these five senses can trigger a sensory overload that can result in a gifted student acting out in the classroom.
Intellectual intensity is the most known trait of a gifted child as it describes the elevated scholastic ability that they possess (Sampson, 2018). Within this overexcitability is strengthened reading and observational skills that are ever so present in kids that exceed in scholastic affairs.
Imaginational intensity describes the “vast imagination and the ability to immerse themselves in imaginary adventures” (Sampson, 2018). The ability to create a reality beyond themselves can prove useful when it comes to critical thinking and problem solving.
Emotional intensity is the most difficult trait to understand because it describes the abundance of emotions within gifted students and is a double edged sword (Sampson, 2018). For example, these students can experience a massive boost of serotonin when they get an A on a project or help someone in need, but can also experience intense sorrow that can lead to an emotional trauma from rejection or underperformance.
With mental health awareness no longer considered to be taboo, we should be actively looking for tell tale signs in our future gifted students. As future educators, knowing what to look for can help us identify those students who need the extra help trying to get their mental health on track. As I had mentioned before, they tend to feel isolated from their peers, with gifted boys scoring higher than gifted girls on the CDRS-R (Eren et al., 2018). This does not mean that gifted boys are the only students facing isolation. These results allow educators to be wary of what type of student is more vulnerable to certain types of struggles. This feeling of isolation can be seen in gifted students who tend to keep to themselves and are not as socially active either in class or around school. This may be hard given that most teachers do not typically see their students outside of class, but there are still other characteristics to look for. Gifted students may see themselves as being physically unfit when compared to their peers of normal intelligence and consider themselves to have an unhealthy lifestyle, which may be a direct result of feeling like their only strengths and capabilities come from their intelligence (Eren et al., 2018). Some gifted students may seem overly pessimistic (Kaufman, 2019). When gifted students are struggling with their mental health, oftentimes, they give off cues that alert others of their internal oppositions. Students who openly reject the feeling of being happy is one of the most obvious cues that tell us, as preservice educators, that something is wrong and we need to act. Most of the time, people assume that gifted children do not act out and are emotionally mature, but this is not always the case. Some students who are struggling can still produce the best grades, but their classroom ethic may not match their work ethic. What may come as a surprise is that gifted students can be disruptive, headstrong, and difficult, so it is not safe to assume that a gifted student's emotional state is as mature as their intelligence (Sampson, 2013). When tested, both gifted boys and girls, had higher tendencies for hyperactivity and being absent minded than their peers with normal intelligence (Eren et al., 2018). Some students draw back and act out when they feel the pressure placed upon their mental health. It is not a sign of defiance, but should be seen as an indication that a gifted student is facing difficulties with their mental health.
After reading all this, you may be asking, “After knowing what to look for, what can I do to help gifted students?” In my experience, a little goes a long way. Because gifted children often forget to be kind to themselves, it may be beneficial for you to show them the compassion that they lack or teach them how to practice self compassion (Kaufman, 2019). It is also beneficial to create an atmosphere that would promote a healthy mind by implementing Social and Emotional Learning into the classroom setting. Social and Emotional Learning is ‘the process through which children and adults… show empathy for others, establish and maintain positive relationships, and make responsible decisions” (Hansen, 2019, p. 32). In the classroom, this can be implemented by doing projects involving the community or group projects that promote each individual's strengths. At the school level, it may take a long time for teachers and school officials to be educated in SEL, but it is possible. For example, in the state of Alabama, presentations and trainings were given on SEL at state and district level conferences in order to spread and educate the idea as conveniently as possible (Jacobs, 2019). A worry that accompanies the implementation of mental health trainings could involve money or time, but Alabama seemed to have solved the problem by adding them to already existing meetings for school officials. Based on what Alabama has done, schools can implement SEL in the standards that already exist. Schools can include SEL objectives in their trainings that occur throughout the year as well as having trained GATE counselors available to students. They may even attempt to train teachers on this type of learning by having the teachers practice SEL amongst themselves. Pre-service educators would then be able to practice and implement a SEL environment in their classrooms by assigning projects that go beyond the classroom. Educators could ask students to use what they have learned in a way that would help the community around them. Projects and assignments would allow for every student to express and show their own individual strengths and educators would be showing their schools that SEL is important, giving them the support they didn't have before. In classrooms that promote Social and Emotional Learning, gifted students would be able to grow emotionally in an environment that promotes emotional maturity.
Another way to curve the detrimental effects on their mental health is to take advantage of the amazing skills that these students possess. The five overexcitabilities mentioned above are very useful tools not only for students, but for pre service educators as well. Now that we know how their minds work, we can then implement strategies that promote and encourage their abilities. For example, if a gifted student is restless, giving them some type of physical activity would calm them, such as a ball to fidget with or having them deliver a note to another teacher (Sampson, 2018). Being able to fulfill, but not overwhelm a students senses comes into play when creating the aesthetic of the classroom. If the decorations are too bright or if group projects get too loud, a gifted student could shut down and have difficulty taking in new information because their mind is overwhelmed. Two skills that work great together are their intellect and imagination. Allowing students to utilize these skills are essential and we can further encourage them by giving more flexibility to assignments and not forcing a repeated framework. In an english class, giving students the opportunity to perform or interpret a piece of literature that would demonstrate their understanding would encourage them to use the skills that make them special. Just being aware of what makes gifted kids special is not enough. Schools should be willing to provide educators with the supplies and flexibility they need, so that their GATE students can thrive and fully utilize what is being offered. Pre-service educators must use what they know about their gifted students and create lesson plans that would stimulate these five traits, so that students stay focused and are pushed to levels that these abilities would allow them to achieve.
The main focus for pre service educators is to understand gifted students and utilize the skills they have to better help them learn to deal with both the challenges of school and their mental health. After learning what makes a child gifted, educators can leave behind all the assumptions about their students that would create an unfair playing ground, giving gifted students and educators a clear understanding of what it means to be gifted. By knowing what they face and how they present these struggles in class, we can go the extra mile and teach them how to take care of themselves and their grades at the same time. This does not need to be achieved by completely restructuring a class. If you see that your gifted students are struggling mentally, give them the tools they need to become stronger. Make the classroom SEL friendly and use their overexcitabilities to launch their learning. Students have the capability to become great citizens, but as educators, we need to be willing to change our classroom to foster their gifts. Educating ourselves is not enough, we need to also be willing to make the changes that our future students need. By giving them a safe, uplifting, and stimulating environment, we can teach gifted students how to deal with the pressures that come with participating in gifted education and teach ourselves to be more understanding of the struggles that they face.
Further your Understanding
Eren, F., Çete, A. Ö., Avcil, S., & Baykara, B. (2018). Emotional and behavioral characteristics of gifted children and their families. Archives of Neuropsychiatry, 55(2), 105–112. https://doi.org/10.5152/npa.2017.12731.
Hansen, C. B. (2019). The heart and science of teaching. New York: Teachers College Press.
Jacobs, L. (Host). (2018, December 5). Gifted children and the value of SEL education [Audio podcast]. Education Talk Radio. American Consortium for Equity in Education.Retrieved from https://www.blogtalkradio.com/edutalk/2018/12/05/gifted-children-and-the-value-of-sel-education.
Kaufman, S. B. (2019, February 8). Are intellectuals suffering a crisis of meaning? Scientific American. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/beautiful-minds/are-intellectuals-suffering-a-crisis-of-meaning/.
Sampson, C. (2013). Social and emotional issues of gifted young children. APEX: The New Zealand Journal of Gifted Education, 18(1). Retrieved from www.giftedchildren.org.nz/apex.
Trotter, A. (2019, October 3). Gifted kid burnout-social media phenomenon or mental health pandemic? Spire Magazine. https://spiremagazine.com/2019/10/03/gifted-kid-burnout-social-media-phenomenon-or-mental-health-pandemic/.