Do Child Marriage Bans Protect Girls? Evidence from Colombia
Child marriage bans aim to protect girls, but their consequences may depend on the conditions girls face outside a union. Girls who enter early unions often come from vulnerable households, and for some, a union may offer a way out of poverty or violence at home. I study how Colombia’s 2024 reform, which raised the minimum age for both marriage and the legal recognition of cohabitation to 18, affected girls’ well-being. Because the ban applied nationwide, I compare girls in municipalities with high versus low pre-reform adolescent cohabitation, before and after the reform. Using household surveys and administrative records, I find that formal marriages involving minors fall to nearly zero and adolescent cohabitation declines by 45 percent. School enrollment and residence with parents increase, while adolescent births fall. However, recorded partner violence does not significantly decline despite fewer unions, and the estimate for family violence is positive but imprecise. These findings suggest that child marriage bans can improve important dimensions of girls’ well-being, while leaving unaddressed the risks some may face in their family homes.
Supplying Contraceptives to Adolescents: When Pure Access does not Breed Use (with Jennifer Seager and Manisha Shah)
Sub-Saharan Africa has the highest adolescent birth rates globally, alongside some of the highest rates of unmet need for modern contraception. This paper evaluates the impact of a randomized controlled trial that offers adolescent females free medical contraceptives on contraceptive adoption and sexual behaviors among adolescent females. Contraceptives are distributed by nurses at pre-existing adolescent clubs every other month for approximately one year. We estimate a null treatment effect from this supply side treatment. We explore heterogeneity in treatment effects based on dimensions cited in the literature and find little evidence of heterogeneous treatment effects. We conclude that providing access to contraceptives alone is not sufficient to increase adolescent contraceptive use.
Learning Gender Norms at Home: Working Mothers and Congressional Voting on Gender Policy
Gender gaps in economic participation, political representation, and legal rights vary substantially across countries and persist over time. While the literature has traditionally focused on economic factors to explain these gaps, more recent research has highlighted the role of gender norms. Yet less is known about how these norms are formed and transmitted, and how they influence public policy. I examine one potential channel by studying whether members of the U.S. Congress who grew up with a working mother vote differently on gender-related legislation. Maternal employment is particularly relevant because women’s participation in the labor force may shape beliefs about gender roles (Xue, 2021). Policymakers are also important because laws can shape gender norms, legislators can advance women’s legal rights, and politicians may contribute to the oblique transmission of gender norms to the broader population. I link members of Congress to historical census records to measure their mothers’ employment during childhood and classify bills by their gender content. I find that members who grew up with a working mother are more likely to support gender-related legislation. The results are similar when I instrument for maternal employment using cross-state variation in World War II mobilization. These findings suggest that changes in women’s employment can shape gender norms and, through the next generation of policymakers, influence gender-related policies.
¿Fin de la guerra, fin de la violencia? Evidencia del Acuerdo de Paz y homicidios en Colombia (End of War, End of Violence? Evidence from the Peace Agreement and Homicides in Colombia). Documento CEDE No. 22, 2020.