Data tables include: 1) insect pest counts and management information (plant stand density, stem density, stand age, total alfalfa weevil insecticide sprays, total other sprays) dataframe across the growing season for different plots/fields (Table 1), and 2) daily weather parameters and calculated values (growing degree days and previous 7 days of precipitation) data compiled from local weather stations (Table 2). Table 2 was joined with Table 1 when conducting redundancy analyses.
Table 1 - Heading of dataset for different alfalfa seed fields, insect counts, yield, plot plant stand paramets, and insecticide sprays.
Table 2 - Heading of dataset for daily weather data obtained from either Environment Canada or Alberta Climate Information Service, with growing degree days calculated for alfalfa weevil with a base temperature value of 9°C and for Lygus with a base temperature value of 7.9°C.
Insect pest abundances varied across years and sites in southern Alberta (Figure 3), indicating that local scale differences are important for pest management. Insecticide management decisions made by individual farmers confound the differences in insect pest populations, yet even untreated areas had variable insect pests and yields across and within fields (Figures 3 and 4). This real-world variability makes it difficult to determine the impact of both insect pests and insecticide applications. Farmers used different insecticide treatments in both number of sprays and active ingredients used, making it difficult to parse out results, particularly with areas with insecticide resistance issues for alfalfa weevil [4,6]. Therefore, for examining regional weather predictors on insect pest communities and clustering of insect pest communities, analyses were conducted on unsprayed plots only. Sprayed plots were only used in analyses that related to insecticide application practices. Lastly, paired insecticide sprayed and unsprayed plots were considered a block, therefore insect pest classes that were determined from unsprayed insect pest community data were assumed to be the same class for the corresponding sprayed plots given the proximity.
Figure 3 - Boxplots for alfalfa seed field and insecticide plot treatments, separated by year, for average counts across the growing season of A) alfalfa weevil larvae per 10 sweeps (top), B) alfalfa plant bugs per 10 sweeps (middle), and C) Lygus nymphs per 10 sweeps (bottom).
Figure 4 - Boxplots by alfalfa seed field, insecticide plot treatments, and year for plot yields in kilograms per hectare.
Generally, year-to-year differences were observed, with lower pest pressures and higher yields in 2023 and more pest pressure in 2024 (Figures 3-6). In 2023, insecticide sprayed plots typically had lower pest pressures (Figure 5), while sprayed plot were more variable in 2024 (Figure 6). Generally, the first year fields had lower pressure in 2024.
Figure 5 - Principal Component Analysis for scaled and centred average pest counts across each plot and field for 2023, with shape size representing plot yields in kilograms per hectare, different shapes representing the age of the field and colours representing sprayed and unsprayed plots.
Figure 6 - Principal Component Analysis for scaled and centred average pest counts across each plot and field for 2024, with shape size representing plot yields in kilograms per hectare, different shapes representing the age of the field and colours representing sprayed and unsprayed plots.
Given this work is real on-farm data, there are limitations in interpretting insecticide controls due to the different number of applications, timings and mode of actions used. Further, there are other confounding effects that cannot be accounted for here, including yield losses due to other pests, such as pathogens and weeds, and damage from hail and adverse weather conditions. Lastly, other factors influence the survival and success of insect pests, including the ability of an insect to overwinter, changes in seasonal temperatures, availability of alternate hosts and surrounding crops, insect competition, beneficial predators and parasitoids, and insecticide resistant populations.