Elementary AI Guidance
1st-5th Grade
1st-5th Grade
We strongly advise against letting elementary level scholars use AI tools and AI chatbots for any instructional, counseling, or recreational purpose. Teachers are encouraged to try to AI tools to enhance instructions or reduce workload, evaluate output using SAFE.
Rationale:
Kids can't distinguish fantasy from reality. Children at young age can't reliably tell the difference between AI and real people, which could lead to unhealthy attachments or confusion about relationships.
They're in crucial developmental stages. Early childhood requires hands-on exploration, physical play, and human interaction that AI simply can't provide.
Their personality is still forming. Young children are especially vulnerable to influences that could impact healthy development.
They need human connection. Young children need responsive human caregivers, not AI interactions that could interfere with natural bonding.
Research shows links between heavy social media and digital device use and increased rates of depression, self-harm, and other mental health harms among children and adolescents. These effects are strongest when use is excessive or involves appearance-focused or passive engagement. PMC+1
Government and public health reviews highlight both risks and gaps in evidence and recommend caution, age protections, and active adult supervision when children access social platforms. HHS.gov
Emerging clinical reports, psychiatry commentary, and legal actions document cases where extensive use of conversational AIs and companion bots has been associated with worsening mental health, delusional thinking, or being implicated in tragic outcomes. This risk is heightened for vulnerable youth who may treat chatbots as therapeutic substitutes or intimate companions. Psychiatry Online+1