By Madeline Naber
The book Caraval by Stephanie Garber is an amazing read, especially if you're bored over winter break. It’s a young adult fantasy and a very mysterious adventure. Caraval is the first in a trilogy, and the other two books are Legendary and Finale. There's also a new book that came out in 2024 called Spectacular.
Ever since she was a child, Scarlett has dreamed of participating in Caraval, the magical game
put on by the “Legend,” the leader of the game and his band of performers. Year after year, she has written to Legend asking him to bring Caraval to her tiny island of Trisda, but every letter she has ever sent has gone unanswered–until now. Legend has finally responded to one of her letters and has invited both her and her sister, Tella, to his private island to take part in Caraval. Only Caraval is not quite what she imagined it would be. The line separating reality from fantasy is blurred in Caraval, and when Tella is kidnapped as part of the game, the stakes become much higher than Scarlett had anticipated.
Caraval by Stephanie Garber is about Scarlett trying to find her sister and go home, and is set in the 18th/19th century in a carnival. Scarlett has to figure out what is real and what is an illusion, and some of the things she sees aren’t real. The genre of the book is a young adult fantasy and a little romance. It’s also very mysterious and contains many plot twists.
Another important element of Caraval is Garber’s writing style, which is rich, colorful, and sensory. She uses descriptions of colors, textures, and emotions to make each scene feel almost real. This fits perfectly with the book’s central idea that Caraval is a performance. The setting is not just the place where the story is, but a character of its own, alive, changing, and constantly influencing the story. This immersive style helps readers understand why Scarlett struggles to tell what’s real. Many scenes feel magical but also slightly unsettling, which adds depth to the story and makes the stakes feel more serious.
Although the book contains hints of romance, the heart of the story is Scarlett’s inner growth. At the beginning, she is someone who follows rules, avoids risks, and believes safety is more important than freedom. Throughout Caraval, she is forced to make difficult decisions, trust people she barely knows, and confront fears she has carried for years. By the end of the novel, Scarlett is braver, more confident, and more willing to take control of her own life. This character development makes her a relatable and compelling protagonist, especially for teen readers who may also be learning to trust themselves and make independent choices.
Overall, Caraval is a beautifully written fantasy novel that combines mystery, adventure, and emotional depth. Its imaginative setting and suspenseful plot make it engaging from start to finish, while its focus on family, bravery, and personal growth gives it meaningful substance. Stephanie Garber creates a world that feels both magical and real, encouraging readers to question what they see and to believe in the power of hope and love. For anyone who enjoys fantasy stories with twists, puzzles, and strong character journeys, Caraval is an excellent and memorable read and perfect for the upcoming winter break.