The threshold concepts can be found overlapping in a variety of ways: transfer, genre, rhetoric, process, and inquiry work together and allow writers to enhance their ways of communicating with different audiences. I discovered many different examples of this throughout my first semester of college, especially in my English 1001 class.
For instance, transfer can be seen in the ways the other four threshold concepts bleed into other aspects of both education and everyday life. Anytime skills learned in a different realm are used, transfer is occurring, and this therefore includes genre, rhetoric, process, and inquiry.
I have found the concept of process transferred into many of my college classes this semester. We used this concept vastly in English class as each of our Artifacts (major projects) required a proposal submitted, a peer review day in class, and a final submission. This process remained the same, even though the genre for each project was different. This is similar to my final paper process in my philosophy class: we submitted outlines for feedback, composed rough drafts to be reviewed by our peers, and finally revised and submitted final copies. The process concept, and the way I viewed it and participated in it, transferred over from one of my classes to others.
Furthermore, inquiry can be seen as part of the process when composing. For example, part of the process for my Artifact 2 project (an annotated bibliography and synthesis paper relating to communication within our intended fields) involved researching, which starts with a question. Inquiry is all about keeping an open mind and asking questions about both the topic at hand and the world around us. When beginning work on Artifact 2, or the first step in my process, I had to come up with a more specific question in order to conduct my research.
One way we looked at rhetoric in a different perspective was by going around campus to try and find pictures of objects around campus that represented rhetoric by embodying Fairfield University. On my journey, I stumbled upon a group of patio chairs in the quad (the area in the center of some of the residence buildings) that had been rearranged to form a circle. I believe this represents rhetoric because it demonstrates the community built at this school. Additionally, the concept of inquiry can be seen here because this picture caused me to wonder: who moved these chairs, when, and with what purpose?
Photo Credit: Hannah Salsbury
September 2023
As I mentioned previously, each Artifact was a different genre: we wrote persuasive narratives, annotated bibliographies with synthesis papers, and group presentations which involved interactive audience activities. While we clearly experienced a variety of genre writing, these are all rhetorical because they involve communication with others. Furthermore, the process for each of these Artifacts was roughly the same, which demonstrates how processes can be transferred from one genre to another.
The threshold concepts of transfer, genre, rhetoric, process, and inquiry can overlap in realms other than education. For example, in the field of journalism, all of these concepts are used cohesively to develop and report news stories. Journalists transfer their own personal knowledge of the world, their journalistic skills, and research or interviews into their writing - writing which is a form of rhetoric. Rhetorical appeals may also be used; an important aspect of journalism is reportedly in a timely manner, which is an example of kairos. Additionally, journalists may choose to write in a variety of genres, such as opinion pieces, photo essays, or news articles. Finally, journalists follow a specific process in gaining information for a story, which includes inquiry as they conduct research and interview sources.
All of these threshold concepts overlap because they build off of one another in order to develop strong forms of communication and allow writers to convey ideas in the most effective and persuasive way possible.