The Case of the Pilfered Pie

You've just finished your Thanksgiving feast and it's time for dessert...but a pie has gone missing! Oh no! All of your friends and family are bewildered - none of them took the pie.

You realize that one of the other foods must have been the Thanksgiving thief and that there are clues scattered around the table. Using your handy dandy notebook, can you deduce the who, what, when, where, and how of this mystery so that everybody can enjoy Thanksgiving? Each clue will give you hints as to what you can eliminate, which will lead you to the final lock. This lock is the key to cracking the case for good!

(If the table is cut off, click here to view the full table)