Review Form

Title of Paper:

Authors:

Your Name:

What are the most important points made in the paper?

Come up with at lease three.

What are the main weaknesses of the paper? Do you believe the assumptions and results? If not, why not?

If possible, compare this work with other work that you have heard about. If you chased down additional information on this topic, what was it?

List three questions or points that you plan to bring up in the discussion.

1.

2.

3.

Place a number for each item below corresponding to your evaluation.

Scale: 1 poor, 2 fair, 3 medium, 4 high, 5 outstanding.

Quality of presentation (writing, exposition, etc.):

Technical contribution:

Novelty of ideas:

Overall: