#1 1986 complex, coffee, coffee, brilliant, clean, wow! 25 points against
#2 1996 perfumed aroma, impeccable balance, a cornucopia 50
#3 1982 sweet, coffee and cherry, 60
#4 2000 rich dense and complex, needs 10+ years 90
#5 1985 chocolate cherry, focused and brilliant layers 110
#6 2001 Mouton terroir, balanced, not as complex 122
#7 1989 still with tannins to resolve, spice, long finish 127
#8 1970 sweet, red currents, fresh, coffee, great finish 129
#9 2003 volatile aromas, spice, minerals, ripe fruits 133
#10 2006 cassis/yeast bouquet, jammy, very young 143
#11 1999 surprisingly rich, balanced, excellent acidity 151
#12 1995 clean with some mild soft tannins - restrained ? 153
#13 1983 mineral/spice aromas, a little thin in the middle 161
#14 1978 restrained aroma, soft/light fruit, a little dry at end 187
#15 1990 disappointing tonight - light/thin fruit 194
#16 2004 cherry/cassis/cream brulee' - undeveloped 217