For Much Ado About Nothing:
"Miller was an efficient Leonato. The three actors never had a dull moment on stage..."
For Murder on the Nile:
"The talented actors who accomplished this were Lincoln Hudson, Palmyra Mattner and Toby Miller. If they had been members of a company of 13, I would be saying that they did a great job with their characters; the fact that they all pulled off all of them, shifting with lightning speed, made this a very unique and most memorable production."
"Lincoln Hudson, Palmyra Mattner and Toby Miller,playing BBC radio actors, have discovered that they are the only ones to have made it to the studio and they along must portray the entire dramatis personae of this play. These three actors deliver expert performances."
For Dracula:
"Dracula may very well be the single best piece of work I have seen in three years of Nantucket theater-going....Toby Miller as Count Dracula is simultaneously incredibly terrifying and distinguished...[his] accent was absolutely flawless."
For The 39 Steps:
"Toby Miller is dashing as Richard Hannay...."
"Leading man Toby Miller has brilliantly executed the part of Richard Hannay by carefully balancing narrator and protagonist. We never lost the lines (a difficult thing to do when talking about a British comedy piece). Miller enunciates and flashingly delivers his bits with astounding timing and well-crafted character."