Kinda sorta updated 01/20/2016 (as always, I'm sure I forgot to remove something from my most recent trades!!!)
Set Name Card # Description
1984 Fleer 131 Don Mattingly RC
1985 Donruss 295 Don Mattingly
1985 Leaf/Donruss 140 Dave Winfield/Don Mattingly/Two for the Title
1985 Topps 665 Don Mattingly
1986 Donruss 173 Don Mattingly
1986 Donruss Highlights 53 Don Mattingly
1986 Fleer 639 Wade Boggs/D.Mattingly
1986 Fleer Limited Edition 27 Don Mattingly
1986 Fleer Sluggers/Pitchers 21 Don Mattingly
1986 Kay-Bee 19 Don Mattingly
1986 Topps 712 Don Mattingly AS
1987 Boardwalk and Baseball 32 Don Mattingly
1987 Donruss Highlights 23 Don Mattingly
1987 Fleer 104 Don Mattingly
1987 Fleer 638 Don Mattingly/Darryl Strawberry
1987 Fleer All-Stars 1 Don Mattingly
1987 Fleer Award Winners 24 Don Mattingly
1987 Fleer Exciting Stars 33 Don Mattingly
1987 Fleer Star Stickers 74 Don Mattingly
1987 Topps 500 Don Mattingly
1987 Topps 606 Don Mattingly AS
1987 Topps Mini Leaders 65 Don Mattingly
1987 Woolworth's Topps 15 Don Mattingly
1988 Classic Blue 211 Don Mattingly
1988 Donruss 217 Don Mattingly
1988 Fleer Baseball MVP's 22 Don Mattingly
1988 Fleer Headliners 1 Don Mattingly
1988 Fleer League Leaders 25 Don Mattingly
1988 K-Mart 15 Don Mattingly
1988 Score 650 Don Mattingly/Jack Clark
1988 Topps 2 Don Mattingly RB
1988 Topps 300 Don Mattingly
1988 Woolworth's Topps 4 Don Mattingly
1989 Cereal Superstars 11 Don Mattingly
1989 Fleer 258 Don Mattingly
1989 Fleer Exciting Stars 31 Don Mattingly
1989 Fleer League Leaders 25 Don Mattingly
1989 Score Hottest 100 Stars 10 Don Mattingly
1989 Scoremasters 6 Don Mattingly
1989 Topps 397 Don Mattingly AS
1989 Upper Deck 200 Don Mattingly
1990 Bowman 443 Don Mattingly
1990 Fleer 447 Don Mattingly
1990 Fleer 626 Don Mattingly '85
1990 Fleer League Standouts 2 Don Mattingly
1990 K-Mart 17 Don Mattingly
1990 Score 1 Don Mattingly
1990 Starline Long John Silver 1 Don Mattingly
1990 Topps 200 Don Mattingly
1991 Bowman 178 Don Mattingly
1991 Classic I T33 Don Mattingly
1991 Donruss 107 Don Mattingly
1991 Leaf 425 Don Mattingly
1991 Score 23 Don Mattingly UER/First line, ' is missing from Yankee
1991 Stadium Club 21 Don Mattingly
1991 Upper Deck 354 Don Mattingly
1992 Classic I T58 Don Mattingly
1992 Donruss 596 Don Mattingly
1992 Fleer 237 Don Mattingly
1992 Fleer Citgo The Performer 16 Don Mattingly
1992 Leaf 57 Don Mattingly
1992 Score 23 Don Mattingly
1992 Stadium Club 420 Don Mattingly
1992 Topps 300 Don Mattingly
1992 Topps Gold Winners 300 Don Mattingly
1992 Topps Kids 84 Don Mattingly
1992 Triple Play 159 Don Mattingly
1992 Ultra 105 Don Mattingly
1992 Ultra Award Winners 19 Don Mattingly
1993 Bowman 595 Don Mattingly
1993 Flair 249 Don Mattingly
1993 Fleer 281 Don Mattingly
1993 Fun Pack 208 Don Mattingly
1993 Hostess 28 Don Mattingly
1993 O-Pee-Chee Premier 46 Don Mattingly
1993 Pinnacle 23 Don Mattingly
1993 Score 23 Don Mattingly
1993 Select 24 Don Mattingly
1993 SP 265 Don Mattingly
1993 Topps 32 Don Mattingly
1993 Topps Gold 32 Don Mattingly
1993 Ultra 244 Don Mattingly
1993 Ultra Award Winners 12 Don Mattingly
1993 Upper Deck 134 Don Mattingly
1994 Bowman 25 Don Mattingly
1994 Bowman 386 Don Mattingly FOIL
1994 Collector's Choice 192 Don Mattingly
1994 Donruss 340 Don Mattingly
1994 Donruss Special Edition 60 Don Mattingly
1994 Flair 84 Don Mattingly
1994 Fleer Sunoco 17 Don Mattingly
1994 Pinnacle 23 Don Mattingly
1994 Score 23 Don Mattingly
1994 Select 23 Don Mattingly
1994 SP 198 Don Mattingly
1994 Stadium Club 195 Don Mattingly
1994 Stadium Club Golden Rainbow 195 Don Mattingly
1994 Stadium Club Team 181 Don Mattingly
1994 Ultra Award Winners 2 Don Mattingly
1994 Upper Deck 290 Don Mattingly HFA
1994 Upper Deck Electric Diamond 90 Don Mattingly
1995 Bowman's Best R46 Don Mattingly
1995 Collector's Choice SE 240 Don Mattingly
1995 Fleer 76 Don Mattingly
1995 Leaf Cornerstones 3 D.Mattingly/W.Boggs
1995 Leaf Great Gloves 10 Don Mattingly
1995 SP 175 Don Mattingly
1995 SP Championship 171 Don Mattingly MLP
1995 UC3 In Motion IM9 Don Mattingly
1995 Ultra 311 Don Mattingly
1995 Upper Deck 210 Don Mattingly
1996 Collector's Choice 100 Don Mattingly TT
1996 Collector's Choice 237 Don Mattingly
1996 Metal Universe 90 Don Mattingly
1996 Stadium Club 73 Don Mattingly
1996 Topps 185 Don Mattingly
1996 Topps Profiles AL17 Don Mattingly
2002 Diamond Kings 150 Don Mattingly SP
2003 Topps All-Time Fan Favorites 40 Don Mattingly
2004 Greats of the Game 22 Don Mattingly
2005 SP Authentic 33 Don Mattingly
2012 Topps Heritage 154 Don Mattingly MG
2015 Topps Archives 276 Don Mattingly
2015 Topps Heritage 116 Don Mattingly
2016 Donruss 186A Don Mattingly
2017 Topps Update US270B Don Mattingly SP