You need a p-value, and badly. How do you figure out which test to use?
> cheat sheet file for you to print: 'which test do i use' - will give you a fast summary of typical choices for which stats test to use. There are most definitely more sophisticated decision trees, but this will get you started.
> Read a whole (free) text book: Openstax Intro to Statistics
> Complete a whole (free) Online courses:
Penn State has a great online Stats program:
Psych folks like Likert scales:
Likert scales can be tested with parametric tests: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3886444/
The Personality Project has a complete R package with all the psych test functions evaR! They even have a get staRted page, too.