Post date: Aug 27, 2015 11:12:56 AM
Change! - Overcome Disruption
The first thought coming to my mind has been the
everlasting message “The times they are a-changin’”.
This song contains the essential elements behind
change. First comes the perception that something
around you is being changed, “admit that the waters
around you have grown” and that this endangers
and frightens you … ”accept it that soon you’ll be
drenched to the bone or you’ll sink like a stone …”
then the assessment of your position “is worth
savin’” and last the course of action “Then you
better start swimming, and keep your eyes wide”.
The urgency, the rigorous consequences and the
radical change of order are also described: “The
slow one now will later be fast, as the present now
will later be past, the order is rapidly fading, and
the first one now will later be last…” This song
was written by Bob Dylan in 1964 – he was 23
years old.
Today the world is changing rapidly in all aspects,
concerning the economy, the technology, the
politics and the society. Nothing is fixed, all is in
flow. You are personally affected – new technology
changes the work place. New skills are demanded,
your employability might be endangered.
Companies have to react and be innovative and
resilient to stay in the market.
There are many examples of enterprises which
were not good enough in perception of the need
for change and completely failed to adapt.
Consequently they fell back or even went
bankrupt. One example is Kodak.
Kodak - failed to adapt adequately.
The upcoming of all the different products of the
digital world has been a real change for many
companies. We have old well-known companies
which have generated huge revenues from their
traditional products. One example is Kodak. It was
founded in 1880 and was one of the leaders in the
camera and film industry. By 1976 it accounted for
90% of the film and 85% of the camera market
share in America. Still in 1990 it was one of the five
most valuable brands and had round about 140.000
employees. Then the digital photography came up
and changed the market completely. Kodak had
seen it coming and was the first company to invent
a digital camera. But it was not able to see the real
impacts of this new technology. The management
was not prepared for a fast adaption to the new
challenges. The executives still believed in the
necessity to create the perfect products in the
traditional market. “Kodak had become a complacent monopolist.1”
Kodak was complacent, even when its troubles
were obvious. Kodak had a chance. If they had
perceived that the world had completely changed
by digitalization, they would have given up their
monopolist thinking and started to change their
perception. One good idea could have been
partnering with other companies to develop the
new demand for devices like smartphones and
devices for social media.
On January 19th 2012, Kodak officially announced
the results of some 15 years of failed transformation.
Eastman Kodak, the 131-year-old film pioneer that
has been struggling for years to adapt to an increasingly digital world, filed for bankruptcy protection
early on Thursday, 12 January 2012. 2
Lego – creative thinking and reinvention
On the contrary, Lego was able to analyse the situation in time and conducted the needed change
successfully. Lego was on the brink of bankruptcy
in 2003. But opposing to Kodak, Lego was undergoing a timely process of creative thinking and set
up a completely new system of processes, techniques, roles and policies. As a result, the company
re-emerged more powerful, resilient and inventive
than before. Lego sales are growing at 24 percent
and profits at 40 percent per year each year for the
last five years 3. The company had reinvented itself
and the brand achieved a renaissance.
IBM – transformation from hardware maker to
integrated system provider
Another positive example of change regarding strategical initiative aligned with new company values
is IBM. In the early 1990s IBM, under the governance of Lou Gerstner, succeeded in the transformation from mainframe maker into a robust provider of integrated hardware, networking and software solutions. Mr. Palmisano took over in 2002
and set new corporate values: “dedication to every
client’s success”, “trust and personal responsibility
in all relationships” and “innovation that matters” 4.
Changes in economy
Something about the new economy drives think
tanks to extremes. The one promises the age of
abundance for all. The others predict abundance
for a few and impoverishment for many. The term
for these kind of changes is the disruptive economy.
There is a wind of change and all industries are
affected. Disruption has a dark side. Smart machines will destroy jobs and knowledge workers will
be abundant. The consequences are raising insecurity and promotion of protectionism. But at
the same time, the new economy is providing new
opportunities and it will give people the new tools
to cope with disruption 5.
Changes in politics
George Osborne declared recently that he wants
to raise the minimum wage in UK to 12.50 by the
year 2020. That is more than 30% increase. In
comparison, the minimum wage in Germany is
currently 8.50 €. This is a significant change – and
for the conservatives in UK, a change of their
political direction. What is next after Margaret
Thatcher’s austerity politics and her rigorous
liberalism? Now the state, respectively the First
Secretary of State – George Osborne, one of the
political leaders of the conservative party – is
talking about wage increase for all the employees
with little income. This is a change of a paradigm.
The reason behind this new pragmatic approach is
that currently the state subsidizes the enterprises
which do not pay enough to their workers.
It should not be the task of the state to transfer
additional money to employed workers to maintain
their living costs. 6
This change is subtle and the
real impacts of this new attitude are worth being
observed in the coming months.
How to tackle the large-scale strategic
initiative, how to manage the turn-around?
First of all you have to see the urgency and the
essentiality of the change. Change is not only a
possibility. It is a necessity if you want to survive.
You cannot swim twice in the same river
7
. The
river is in flow, never the same. This is a suitable
analogy how we must see the environment and
ourselves.
Machiavelli wrote “Nothing is more difficult than to
change the order of things.” The change is always
a challenge and not easy to achieve. It seems to
be a complex endeavour to change the business.
According to John P. Kotter there are eight steps
to transforming the organization, from establishing
a sense of urgency to anchoring new approaches
in the culture 8 . Many companies fail because too
many managers don`t realize that transformation is
a process and not an event. 9
Leo Tolstoy “Everyone thinks of changing the
world, but no one thinks of changing himself.”
Changing the reality is a continuous process. The
perception of the change of the human being is
discontinuous. You recognize it all of a sudden.
Perception is disruptive. You suddenly become
aware that there was a change – and then it is
reality. Like in Bob Dylan’s song, it’s good to be on
time – recognize the change and then start swimming.
Luc de Brabandere, Two Types of Change
Perception and Reality 10
A good example of both the change in the outside
world and in the perception in the business world
is a merger and acquisition. Two banks want to
merge. First step is to build one new by integrating
systems, people, branches etc. This is changing
the reality. But what is about people’s minds? Do
they change the perception of their work? Sometimes it takes years, sometimes it never happens
– the people are not merged. There are two groups
of people: The one from company A and the one
from company B. The change will be a failure. You
need to change twice.
Luc de Brabandere, To Change is to Change
Twice 11
First you need to change the reality and then the
perception of the people. The last step is needed
for a successful change. People have to incorporate the new vision. That was the key success in
the IBM case – they changed the corporate
mission and values. A vision is a change in perception of the people, the employees and the
clients.
Today change is everywhere and all organisations
irrespective of size, sector or location must embrace
change and the opportunities and benefits it brings.
Future change needs to be sustainable and requires a project-based approach to planning, implementing and preserving, so that behaviours change
and remain changed. Strong leadership is critical
and needs to be effective for success to be
achieved. 11
On Strategy : What Managers Can Learn from Philosophy - PART 1, https://www.coursera.org/learn/management-philosophy/, Luc de Brabandere, Professor at Ecole Centrale Paris CentraleSupélec
PMI offers the workshop “Business Change
Management - Heading for the Future” http://
learning.pmi.org/course-detail.php?id=3476,
the practice guide “Implementing Organizational
Project Management: A Practice Guide” http://
marketplace.pmi.org/Pages/ProductDetail.
aspx?GMProduct=00101500501
and an in-depth report PMI’s Pulse of the
Profession: “Enabling Organisational Change
Through Strategic Initiatives”, http://www.pmi.
org/~/media/PDF/Knowledge%20Center/UK/
organizational-change-management-uk.ashx
as well many articles related to the topic Change!
Free of charge for PMI members.
Kurt Lehberger, PMP, MBA
Project Manager
VP Sponsors & Fundraising, PMIFC
1
The Economist 14th January 2012.
2
https://engageinnovate.wordpress.com/2012/02/07/kodak-and-its-inability-to-change-a-tale-for-many/Kodak is at death’s door; Fujifilm, its old rival, is thriving. Why? http://www.economist.com/printedition/2012-01-14
3
see PMI Today July 2015, p. 13
4
HBR’s 10 Must Reads, On Change Management, Harvard Business Review Press (8. März 2011), pages 36-37
5
The new economy – Still the land of opportunity, The Economist, p 73
6
FAZ, 10.7.2015, p. 15
7
6
FAZ, 10.7.2015, p. 15
7
Heraclitus,535 BC – 475 BC, Greek philosopher
8
Leading Change, by John P. Kotter, Harvard Business Review Press, New edition (6th November 2012)
9
“Leading Change – Why Transformation Efforts Fail, by John P. Kotter in HBR’s 10 Must Reads, On Change Management, Harvard Business Review Press (8th March 2011), page 3
10
Luc de Brabandere: The Forgotten Half of Change: Achieving Greater Creativity through Changes in Perception (Englisch) Gebundene Ausgabe – 1. Mai 2005, page 1