Motorcycles Need Better Safety

臺灣中文 (zh-TW)  This Web Site uses UTF-8 encoding.

2019-05-06   How dangerous are motorcycles?  Licenses to drive three wheelers  Campaign to conditionally legalize lane filtering and splitting by motorcycles   Situations in Australia   Situations in Taiwan   Situations in the United States   Possible excuses   Images for lane filtering and splitting    Advanced stop lines   Proposals to reform   Important conditions to legalize lane splitting in tunnels  Shoulders  Bus lanes   Differences of riding versus walking motorcycles and bicycles   Pollution from motorcycles   Badness to smoke at parking areas of motorcycles and bicycles  Parking motorcycles   Angle and parallel parking of motorcycles   Paying to park motorcycles   Sidewalk parking of motorcycles  Special appendix: campaign to reform the Taiwanese right-of-way of motorcycles  Special alert: South Korean motorcycle ban on expressways

© 2005--2019 Justin JIH, a Member of the American Motorcyclist Association and the expert of the National Motorists Association in the United States. This web page in American English as a part of Fair Traffic Laws does not necessarily reflect the formal opinions of these organizations nor give any formal legal advice. Please consult reliable professionals for formal legal needs.

Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License.

How dangerous are motorcycles?

Motorcycles were invented in 1885. Motorcycles have advantages over cars such as better fuel economy, occupation of much less space and the like. However, potential dangers of motorcycles are the biggest disadvantage. How dangerous are motorcycles? Where are the dangers from?

Since roads have other larger vehicles ranging from cars to combination vehicles, motorcycles are much weaker. In crashes involving motorcycles, any liability depends on exact circumstances. Serious accidents and crashes can easily kill motorcyclists.

Motorcyclists may be at fault when they are unlicensed, improperly licensed, or untrained, or act so dangerously, such as drunk driving, wearing dark clothing so they are not well visible, failing to anticipate others, smoking or carrying lighted cigarettes, and the like.

Others may be at fault if they are not well skilled or if they fail to realize existence of motorcycles. Aggressive drivers who just consider motorcycles dangerous are worse enemies of motorcyclists. They are unsafe drivers. So many dangers are from other road users. Any passengers who throw something out of other vehicles without regard to passing motorcyclists are bad people.

Motorcycles are more vulnerable to bad weather. Strong wind can throw motorcycles off balance. When crossing large bodies of water, tunnels protect motorcycles from strong wind, but bridges without covers can be bad for motorcycles during strong wind. The thunder, rain, fog, snow and other bad weather may put motorcycles in disadvantage.

Many accidents and crashes involving motorcycles should be preventable. Motorcyclists should wear easily visible clothes and turn headlights and taillights on at all times to be more visible. Turning lights on at all times attracts others' attention to motorcycles. Even in daytime, motorcycles without lights on might appear to be shadows only. Motorcycles sold in the United States since 1978 have lights on when they are operated. Defensive driving is very important to survive in the traffic. Better traffic safety education is the key to make motorcycles much safer. Hand signals should be minimized to avoid falling.

Licenses to drive three wheelers

California, USA already allows driving three-wheel motorcycle with its Class C license for cars. Other places should also consider it. Still requiring licensed four-wheeler drivers to take motorcycle written tests, but waiving road tests on three-wheel motorcycle to enable driving three-wheelers helps motor vehicle offices simplify the procedures. The economy may therefore be boosted with increased sales of three wheelers and more tax revenues.

Campaign to conditionally legalize lane filtering and splitting by motorcycles

Proper lane filtering, sharing and splitting by motorcycles reduce traffic jam. As motorcycles are more maneuverable than cars, lane filtering by motorcyclists in a reasonable and prudent way should be legal. Squeezing between other traffic too fast or too closely can be dangerous if others suddenly change direction, open doors, or the like. Very slow lane filtering ≤ 7 km/h is much safer when other traffic is already stopped.

Situations in Australia

Australia did not consider lane filtering and splitting legal for motorcycles, until New South Wales, Queensland, Australian Capital Territory, Victoria, and South Australia allow lane filtering in various ways.

Situations in Taiwan

In Taiwan, driving a motor vehicle next to another one in one single lane is administratively fined 600 to 1800 New Taiwan dollars, thus making lane splitting by motorcycles not so legal. Since 1 November 2007, motorcycles with engine displacements of at least 550 cm3 are allowed on most Taiwanese expressways, but overtaking another vehicle in the same lane is banned under the flat fine of 3000 New Taiwan dollars. Both penalties fail to consider the different potential danger from different speeds when overtaking another vehicle in the same lane, so they are unfair.

Based on Judicial Yuan Interpretation Number 641, these flat penalties should be unconstitutional.

However, many administrative courts have ruled that motorcycles overtaking stopped vehicles would not be considered overtaking. This would be the judiciary balancing the legislation and administration to conditionally legalize lane filtering.

Situations in the United States

Only California formally allows motorcyclists to lane filter and split. Utah will allow motorcycles other than autocycles to lane filter since Tuesday, May 14, 2019, only within these five conditions, to allow motorists to be much more able to adapt:

All American motorcyclists should print out and carry both of the following American Federal Governmental web pages at https://one.nhtsa.gov/people/injury/pedbimot/motorcycle/00-NHT-212-motorcycle/motorcycle51.html that:

"traveling between lanes of stopped or slow-moving cars (i.e., lane splitting) on multiple-lane roads (such as interstate highways) slightly reduces crash frequency compared with staying within the lane and moving with other traffic"

and at http://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/freewaymgmt/faq.htm#faq15 that:

"it is safer to keep two-wheeled vehicles moving than to have them travel in start-and-stop traffic conditions".

Outside California, try to avoid being stopped by the police by not going too fast for conditions. If still stopped for very slow lane filtering with very short stopping distance, like lane filtering under 7 km/h (2 m/s or 4 miles per hour) past stopped vehicles, claim the necessity defense that being rear-ended by a car is much more dangerous than very slow lane filtering past stopped vehicles.

The police focusing on summoning but not helping motorcyclists may violate the 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution. States prohibiting lane splitting without differentiating how fast everyone is going may violate the 5th, 8th, 9th Amendments (parts of the Bill of Rights) and Section 1 of the 14th Amendment (Equal Protection Clause) to the United States Constitution. Abusing motorcycle-only checkpoints is even worse, but some states have outlawed them.

Donald John TRUMP posted at Twitter on November 29, 2016 to call for loss of American citizenship or a year in jail for burning American flag. Dangerously interfering with lane filtering and splitting or causing intolerable fire hazard while burning American flag may, if demanded in any plea deal to reduce or avoid criminal penalty, risk losing American citizenship and nationality. Please respect the moral responsibility of American citizenship at http://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/files/article/chapter2.pdf :

"Finally, America becomes stronger when all of its citizens respect the different opinions, cultures, ethnic groups, and religions found in this country. Tolerance for differences is also a responsibility of citizenship."

Possible excuses

Even if the police are not present, a few motorists purposely block lane filtering and splitting. Doing so against riders with occupations as medical professionals, firefighters, lawyers, police officers, prosecutors, and judges will likely increase the badness. There are possible reasons to tell the blocking motorist why lane filtering or splitting, but please use them wisely:

"I was almost rear-ended." "It might launch me to the air and land on your head." "There is a broken taillight."

"There is a broken brake light."

"There is a broken turn signal."

"There is a broken license plate light."

"The license plate is obscured."

"The fuel cap is open."

"The bumper is bent (scratched)."

"The tire is under-inflated."

Images for lane filtering and splitting

The above image is from American and Taiwanese governmental edicts in the public domain. The upper left is cropped from Article 174-2 of the Regulations for Road Traffic Signs, Markings, and Signals to show a Taiwanese advanced stop line. Its front-view motorcycle symbol is enlarged in mid-right in centimeters.

The lower right is the Shared Lane Marking for bicyclists (bicycle sharrow) in Figure 9C-9 of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) in the USA. (One inch equals 25.4 mm.) The lower left combines the arrow in American bicycle sharrow and Taiwanese motorcycle symbol to make a motorcycle sharrow, and should be added into Chapter 3B of the MUTCD and any legal standards anywhere to allow responsible lane filtering and splitting. They should also be used on hard shoulders and bus lanes where feasible.

Advanced stop lines

Advanced stop lines for motorcycles and bicycles further facilitate responsible lane filtering, sharing, and splitting. They are usually used at intersections with traffic light signals. Advanced stop lines are already used in Japan and Taiwan.

The area between a stop line and a crosswalk may be good as advanced stop line with symbols of motorcycles and bicycles if the traffic light signals will detect these vehicles. If that area must be clear, such as due to turning large vehicles, prohibitory net lines in the upper right of the above image may show where not to stop.

To prevent motorcyclists and bicyclists from being rear-ended, toll booths, customs posts, filling stations, ferry docks, etc. should also have advanced stop lines. For example, North Ferry to and from Shelter Island, New York, USA has a specific waiting area for motorcycles and bicycles. The Fair Weather Riding Act in New Jersey in 1987 would allow motorcycles to go to the front of inspection lines before eliminating annual inspection in 2010. Customs posts should use more videophones to inspect motorcyclists and bicyclists faster, and any reasonable doubts may undergo secondary inspection by customs officials on the spot. Cars and large vehicles, but not motorcycles or bicycles, usually have air conditioners and heaters.

As too many lane splitting motorcycles and bicycles may excessively delay cars and large vehicles from service, a simple rule of courtesy is to have no more than one cycle in front of a car or large vehicle, then more cycles wait between other cars and large vehicles visible by their drivers. Then cyclists wait for shorter time without excessively delaying other enclosed vehicles.

The drivers and passengers of cars and large vehicles must respect motorcyclists and bicyclists who are much more vulnerable to injuries in case of any collisions, or they do not deserve driving privilege.

Proposals to reform

The American Motorcyclist Association, Ride To Work Incorporated, ABATE of the Garden State and New York Motorcycle & Scooter Task Force in the United States support lane splitting in different ways. Please answer questions 5, 6 and 7 of the fair traffic survey to specify the speed limit to legalize lane filtering and splitting. Some levels of lane filtering and splitting by motorcycles should be conditionally legalized: