under contract with Cambridge Elements in Global Philosophy of Religion (CUP)
Religious syncretism in Southeast Asia is characterised by the blending of indigenous spiritual practices with major religious traditions such as Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, and Islam. In this Element, we present a philosophical challenge that arises from this phenomenon. At its core lies the internal contradiction frequently found within these blended religions. We examine six philosophical approaches that address this challenge, detailing both their explanatory strengths and limitations. We conclude with an alternative outlook on the challenge posed by Southeast Asian syncretism and its implications for the global philosophy of religion.
for Aletheia Publishing
In this monograph, I defend a version of the Simple View of personal identity. This version has three main theses: (i) personal identity is a primitive, unanalyzable concept, (ii) persons are ontologically fundamental, not derivative, and (iii) prudential concern is identity-involving. I present some arguments for these theses and respond to possible objections against them.
a collection of interviews with some of the top philosophers in the world
under contract with Springer Singapore
In Introduction to Logic (chapter 12), the late Jesuit philosopher Harry Gensler developed a rather curious natural deduction proof system for deontic logic. In this paper, I present a version of this and show its ramifications to some well-known deontic principles, particularly Hare's do's-from-ought principle, Kant's ought-implies-can principle, Hume's no-ought-from-is principle, and Poincare's no-do's-from-is principle. I also show how it addresses some familiar deontic paradoxes, particularly Ross's paradox of obligation, Prior's good Samaritan paradox, and Chisholm's contrary-to-duty puzzle.
In this paper, I formulate Weak Kleene semantics in a multiple-conclusion entailment setting. I show some interesting facts that result from this formulation.
The Frege-Geach problem for expressivists is often cashed out as the challenge of explaining the logical behaviour of expressive, non-truth-evaluable sentences. In particular, it asks (i) how an expressive sentence and its negation can be logically inconsistent and (ii) how expressive sentences can figure in logically valid inferences. Both problems form the general embedding problem for expressivists. That is, the problem of explaining how expressive sentences could be subsentences of compound sentences. In this paper, I explore two versions of the Weak Kleene semantic framework that could address these challenges. These frameworks imply the non-truth-aptness of these expressive sentences and their logical infectiousness as well.
Jorgensen's dilemma is the problem of explaining how arguments that contain imperative sentences could be deductively valid. In this paper, we extend this dilemma to moral arguments in general. We show that the current metaethical theories could be seen as possible answers to this generalised dilemma.
In 'What's wrong with tonk(?)', Roy T. Cook proposes a semantics for Prior's binary connective tonk. In this note, we show that this semantics is not truth-functionally complete.
In Problems of Logic, Ushenko presents a version of the liar paradox, which he claims to be an exception to Russell’s theory of types or Ramsey’s theory of language levels. Encarnacion, however, shows that far from being an exception to these theories, Ushenko’s paradox only rests on a mere symbolic fallacy. In this paper, I aim to evaluate Encarnacion’s argument for his verdict by looking at the immediate responses to it.
with Abbas Ahsan
Buddhism, Christianity, and Islam embrace contradictions within their respective core doctrines. Using a certain type of non-classical logic, some dialetheists have offered a piecemeal approach to understanding the doctrinal contradictions of a particular religion. In this paper, we propose a more general dialetheic approach to classifying these contradictions. We then discuss the ramifications of this approach to analytic theology, in particular, and the global philosophy of religion, in general.
with Jc Beall
The classical collapse thesis implies that in a multiple-conclusions setting, sub-classical logics like LP, K3, and FDE collapse into classical (propositional) logic. In this paper, we argue that the thesis also holds for other weaker logics such as Weak Kleene and Cooper's Ordinary Logic.
In 'The Role of Trust in Argumentation', Catarina Dutilh-Novaes offers the Attend-Trust-Engage (ATE) framework of how epistemic social exchanges ought to be. This paper formalises ATE in social choice theoretic terms and explores its conceptual ramifications to argumentation theory.
Entailment barriers abound in philosophy -- theses that tell us that some derivations are illicit or fallacious. For example, Hume's 'no-ought-from-is' thesis tells us that deriving normative, obligation conclusions from purely factual statements is fallacious. In contrast, Bertrand Russell's 'no-general-from-particular' thesis warns us against deriving general statements from purely particular statements. This paper examines another entailment barrier thesis, which originates from Tertullian's polemical work, De Carne Christi. As we shall argue in this paper, Tertullian's thesis implies that it is illicit to derive statements about what is eternal from statements about what is temporal. We demonstrate that if this thesis holds, then certain arguments for the existence of the Christian God are flawed.