Long-Term Care
Hernández-Pizarro, H. M., Nicodemo, C., & López-Casasnovas, G. (2020). Discontinuous system of allowances: The response of prosocial health-care professionals. Journal of Public Economics, 190, 104248.
Awarded Best Article in Health Economics by Spanish Economic Association (AES)
This paper examines the unintended strategic effects of non-linear incentives in public policies. A system of health care subsidies structured into discrete intervals may lead to strategic behaviour. We provide new evidence on this issue, focusing on a case where strategic actions are taken by healthcare providers (HCPs). We show that HCPs adjust the score of claimants in long-term care needs assessments, allowing claimants to access higher levels of care benefits. This adjustment does not bring any pecuniary gain for HCPs. In a quasi-natural experimental setting –the implementation of Spanish long-term care (LTC)– we show that the distribution of the claimants' needs includes kinks around the thresholds set for the LTC system. These kinks reveal that healthcare providers adopt prosocial behaviour, helping claimants jump to a higher level of benefits without discriminating by health status, residence, or gender. By developing a new non-parametric estimator, we prove that these adjustments increase the public LTC spending, which is equivalent to moving thresholds to the left. The additional cost per adjusted claimant per annum is approximately 1000 euro on average. Finally, we also explore empirically whether the number of thresholds could affect such behaviour, by exploiting a reform that eliminated some thresholds. We find that the lower number of thresholds is associated with an increase of adjustment around the thresholds that remain.
(Previously circulated as Against the Discontinuity Trap: the Case of Long-Term Care in Spain)
Awarded Fedea Best Young Researcher Paper at the XL Jornadas AES
Link - Featured on NadaEsGratis (Spanish), BlogAES (Spanish) & BSE Voice (English)
This paper estimates effects of long-term care (LTC) benefits on utilization of primary and secondary healthcare in Catalonia (Spain). Identification comes from plausibly exogenous variation in the leniency of LTC needs assessment. We estimate that receiving LTC benefits worth 365 euros per month, on average, reduces the probability of avoidable hospital admissions by 66%, and has no significant effect on planned hospitalisations nor on hospitalisation for any reason. Receiving LTC benefits is estimated to reduce unscheduled primary care visits by 44% and has no significant effect on scheduled visits. These findings have important policy implications suggesting that allocating resources to LTC may not only increase the welfare of LTC beneficiaries but also reduce avoidable and unscheduled utilisation of healthcare.
Link (open access)
We study the socioeconomic horizontal inequity in the allocation of publicly subsidised long-term care (LTC) in Spain, using administrative data from the universe of applicants in Catalonia. We find that, after controlling for needs, cash subsidies for informal care are disproportionately concentrated among wealthier individuals, while the use of formal care services (home care and nursing homes) is concentrated among the less well-off. This suggests that cash benefits may inadvertently facilitate access to wealthier individuals’ private care. We also find inequity in the form of provision, with in-kind services being more prevalent among the worse-off while wealthier beneficiaries are more likely to receive vouchers. While this duality in provision does not lead to significant differences in overall time to access LTC, we find that lower-income individuals wait longer for telecare, and wealthier individuals opting for in-kind nursing home care wait longer, suggesting potential differences in preferences or constraints. We find no evidence of socioeconomic inequity in the time spent navigating the administrative application process. Our findings highlight the need for policymakers to consider the potential unintended consequences of cash benefits and different forms of provision to ensure equitable access to LTC services.
Link (open access) - Extended Versions: Health Policy Paper 2025-7 (English) and Full Paper at 4rt Congrés d'Economia i Empresa de Catalunya (Col·legi d'Economistes) (en Català)
Background. Spain has one of the highest life expectancies at 65-years-old among OECD countries, yet only half of these years are expected to be in good health. Thus, many older people require support for carrying out activities of daily living. In response, the Spanish government established the Spanish long-term care (LTC) system in 2007.
Objective.To review the published evidence from the analysis of the first 18 years of existence of the system.
Methods. This study adopts a narrative literature review approach, drawing from academic and policy-oriented research on the Spanish LTC system.
Results. The LTC system has improved the wellbeing of its beneficiaries -particularly in terms of health- and has reduced healthcare costs by lowering hospital admissions and primary care visits. However, it suffers from chronic underfunding and design flaws. Financial sustainability remains a challenge, especially due to low central Spanish government contributions and regional disparities. Nonetheless, the LTC system has yielded significant economic returns through job creation and increased female labour participation. LTC benefits have also influenced family decisions: reducing savings, increasing the supply of informal caregivers and delaying early retirement. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed structural vulnerabilities, particularly in residential care. Moreover, while the navigation across the LTC system ensures horizontal equity, inequity is documented in the form of providing the benefits.
Conclusions. After almost two decades of the Spanish LTC system, evidence calls for adequate and stable financing mechanisms to achieve sustainability. It should also expand towards service-based care, integrate with healthcare, and systematically measure quality-of-life outcomes.
Link (open access)
Many long-term care (LTC) policies have shifted to promote “aging-in-place”, although little is known about the effectiveness of LTC settings (home-based vs institutionalized). Spanish LTC policy enables to investigate whether user-selected LTC settings lead (or not) to reduction healthcare utilization. Drawing administrative data from Spain (2009-2014), we employ a difference-in-differences to examine variations in hospitalization rates between residential care and home-based LTC beneficiaries, the latter predominantly receiving informal caregiving. Our analysis encompasses scheduled and emergency hospitalizations, as well as admissions for nursing home avoidable conditions. We find no statistically significant differences in hospitalization probability after three years between residential and home-based care beneficiaries with comparable needs, with one exception (institutional care increased the probability of emergency hospitalization for the married in Severe + LTC needs group). These results suggest that the LTC settings, on average, do not significantly influence the incidence of hospital use when the care is provided by non-medically trained carers in both settings, although home-based care backed by strong informal support may reduce emergency admissions. This provides novel empirical evidence on the relative effectiveness of different care settings, with important implications for the economics of LTC and public policy. The, overall, equivalence of residential and home-based care in terms of hospitalization supports users and family decision-making in LTC. These insights can inform the design of cost-effective LTC policies, potentially optimizing resource allocation in healthcare systems facing demographic pressures.
Other Ageing Related Publications
Background: Physical activity is associated with mental health benefits. This systematic literature review summarises extant evidence regarding this association, and explores differences observed between populations over sixty-five years and those younger than sixty-five. Methods: We reviewed articles and grey literature reporting at least one measure of physical activity and at least one mental disorder, in people of all ages. Results: From the 2263 abstracts screened, we extracted twenty-seven articles and synthesized the evidence regarding the association between physical (in)activity and one or more mental health outcome measures. We confirmed that physical activity is beneficial for mental health. However, the evidence was mostly based on self-reported physical activity and mental health measures. Only one study compared younger and elder populations, finding that increasing the level of physical activity improved mental health for middle aged and elder women (no association was observed for younger women). Studies including only the elderly found a restricted mental health improvement due to physical activity. Conclusions: We found inverse associations between levels of physical activity and mental health problems. However, more evidence regarding the effect of ageing when measuring associations between physical activity and mental health is needed. By doing so, prescription of physical activity could be more accurately targeted.
While the benefits of physical activity on health are well documented, in high-income countries 1 in 3 adults do not reach the recommended levels. Thus, policy makers have developed interventions to promote physical activity. The aim of this research is to evaluate the effectiveness of physical activity prescription on mental health outcomes, by studying an intervention that prescribes physical activity at the primary care level in Catalonia (PAFES). This intervention specifically targets the adult population with high cardiovascular risk. We use data from the Health Survey of Catalonia (2011-2016) and exploit the variation in the number of trained General Practitioners that prescribe physical activity. Our results show that physical activity prescription reduces the probability of suffering from poor mental health. This effect is mainly driven by females within the targeted population. We also explore the main effect (or the output) of the intervention. While PAFES increases the probability of patients undertaking high-level physical activity, it does not affect rates of sedentarism or minutes walked per day. Results are consistent when using alternative mental health outcome measures, including self-reported depression and anxiety. We conclude that the prescription of physical activity not only contributes to the improvement of physical health but is also a useful tool to help preserve mental wellbeing.
Link (open access)
Objective. This study investigates the health effects of loneliness among adults (18+ years) and elderly adults (60+ years).
Method. Using data from the Health Survey of Catalonia (ESCA), 2013-2019, the effects of loneliness on health and healthcare utilization outcomes are estimated. Ordinary least squares estimates are provided to explore the channels affecting such relationships.
Results. Loneliness is significantly associated to worse health outcomes in all age groups. Among adults, it reduces self-perceived health by 7.1%, increases multi-morbidities by 22.1%, and raises the probability of depression and anxiety by 65.8%. Consequently, a positive and strong association between suffering from loneliness and the use of healthcare resources is documented: with a 7.4% rise in medication use, 20.9% more emergency care visits, and 6.1% higher primary care use. Results for the elderly are aligned with adults, although the magnitude associated to self-perceived health is substantially greater (13.2%). Channels exploration identifies living alone (with a 97.3% increase) and poor household habitability (33.5% increase) as key predictors in all the analysis. Being foreign (60.3% increase in the adult population and 106% in the elderly population) and gender (women, 26.8% for the adult population and 27.5% in the elderly population) become relevant factors explaining loneliness.
Conclusions. This study documents the impact of loneliness in Catalonia. Loneliness is associated to significant worse health and more use of healthcare. Tackling individuals with higher risk factors for loneliness could help preventing its concerning consequences on health and healthcare system.
Book Chapters and Other Publications
Long-Term Care
Population ageing is raising the demand for long-term care (LTC), leading many countries to develop publicly funded LTC systems. However, little is known about whether the benefits these systems provide help preserve the functional autonomy of the people who receive them. We use the administrative registry of the Catalan LTC system, covering 320,618 individuals aged 60 or over who entered between 2015 and 2024, and follow them for two, three, five and seven years. Because applicants are assessed and reassessed with the same standardised instrument (the BVD), we observe repeated, comparable measures of functional capacity, down to the level of individual daily-living tasks. We proceed in three steps. First, we estimate how the intensity of exposure to each benefit (informal home care, formal home care, day centre care and institutional care) is associated with death, grade deterioration and within-grade deterioration. Second, we compute life-years and deterioration-free years gained using regression-standardised survival curves. Third, we analyse the size and composition of functional decline among survivors. Greater benefit intensity is associated with lower mortality: full exposure to each benefit is associated with between 0.36 (institutional care) and 1.40 (informal home care) additional life-years over seven years, relative to no benefit. Among survivors, higher intensity is also associated with a greater probability of recorded deterioration, most markedly in institutional care. This pattern is consistent with survival-deterioration selection and with benefits responding to need, rather than with care causing decline. Losses in indoor mobility, changing body position and continence/toileting are most strongly associated with institutional care. Estimates are associations, not causal effects. The results show the value of routine functional assessment data for evaluating LTC policy in ageing societies.
Link - Altres versions: CRES Health Policy 2026-9 (Catalan) & Fedea Policy Paper 2026/04 (Spanish).
El sistema de dependència a Catalunya, desplegat sota el paraigua de la Llei 39/2006, ha universalitzat l’accés a les cures però arrossega un desequilibri estructural: infrafinançament, lentitud administrativa, una fragmentació persistent entre l’àmbit social i el sanitari, i una elevada càrrega familiar en l’atenció a les necessitats de cura, assumida desproporcionadament per dones. Tot i els avenços, les llistes d’espera continuen essent una barrera crítica —amb mesos de demora tant en la valoració com en l’accés efectiu als serveis—, i l’existència encara de mortalitat en espera d’atenció posa en evidència la urgència de reformes. El model es veu tensionat per una estructura familiar canviant i un mercat de treball de les cures precaritzat, feminitzat i amb salaris baixos. Aquestes mancances es reflecteixen tant en l’atenció domiciliària —insuficient i desigual— com en les residències, encara lluny d’esdevenir espais d’alta complexitat plenament coordinats amb la xarxa sanitària. Malgrat aquestes limitacions, el Sistema per a l'Autonomia i Atenció a la Dependència (SAAD) ha generat ocupació i activitat en el sector, ha reduït hospitalitzacions evitables i contribuït a l’economia, però ho fa sobre una base fràgil i desigual, amb un finançament estatal insuficient i sovint incert. Les prestacions encara no garanteixen una resposta ajustada als projectes de vida de les persones, i l’accés continua condicionat per desigualtats territorials i per un procés de valoració que no sempre capta la complexitat real. El document conclou que Catalunya es troba davant d’un punt d’inflexió: cal reforçar l’atenció domiciliària i l’atenció en l’entorn comunitari que no s’adequa als canvis de necessitats, modernitzar les residències, professionalitzar les cures, integrar sistemes d’informació i estabilitzar el finançament per poder construir un model coherent amb el desig majoritari de la ciutadania —viure i envellir com a casa: amb suport, autonomia i dignitat.
INTRODUCTION. The Research Methodology course is a core first-year subject in many degree programmes and provides essential skills for the development of academic projects. This study examines the impact of implementing structured cooperative learning techniques on student satisfaction.
METHOD. We use anonymised official satisfaction survey data from TecnoCampus, aggregated at the class-group level. A first-difference approach was employed to compare pre-intervention (2020–2022) and post-intervention (2023–2024) periods across three dimensions: overall satisfaction, satisfaction with the teaching methodology, and satisfaction with teaching performance. Control variables for group size, degree programme, and participation rate were included. To mitigate potential bias, we implemented a difference-in-differences design, using a comparable course without cooperative learning as a control group.
RESULTS. A 10% increase was observed in both overall satisfaction and satisfaction with the teaching methodology, while satisfaction with teaching performance remained stable over time. These findings support the introduction of cooperative learning approaches in first-year university courses.
DISCUSSION. The increase in satisfaction appears to have been driven by improvements in the learning experience, which enhanced collaboration, perceived support, and student engagement. However, evaluations of teaching performance remained unchanged, suggesting that the positive effect is attributable to the methodology rather than to the instructor.