Laura Pierce-3rd-1986
Amy Bowling-4th-1988
Erin Conner-5th-1988
Jackie Paulus-4th-1992, 4th-1993, 1st-1994, 1st-1995, One of the top 50 Softball Players in Missouri Valley Conference
Kate McCannon-3rd-1994, 2nd-1995, 1st-1996, High School All-American 2nd team-1996 , All Tournament Team-1996
Melissa Navntoft-3rd-1995, 1st-1996, All-Tournament Team-1996
Kaci Richart-5th-1994, 5th-1995, 3rd-1996
Monica Moeller-4th-1995, 2nd-1996
Katy Lambert-5th-1995, 2nd-1996,1st-1997
Katie Boney-5th-1996, 2nd-1997, 1st-1998, 1st-1999, All-Tournament team-1999, High School
All-American 2nd-1999, IGHSAU Hall of Fame Inductee-2006
Amy Oleson-5th-1997
Amber Glasgow-5th-1997
Laura Workman-3rd-1998, 4th-1999
Abbey Glasgow-5th-1998, 3rd-1999
Julie Gerdes-5th-1998, 4th-1999, 2nd-2000
Natalie Johnson-1st-1999, 1st-2000, IGHSAU Hall of Fame Inductee-2009, All Big Ten Softball-2004
Allison Ehret-4th-2000, 3rd-2001
Erin Heland-5th-2000, 4th-2001, 4th-2002, 5th-2003
Blair Anderson-4rd-2001
Ashley Jay-2nd-2002, 1st-2003
Lanette Boeset-2nd-2002, 3rd-2004
Katie Pilger-5th-2002
Sonja Schwenker-4th-2003, 2nd-2004, 2nd-2005
Hannah Luttenegger-3rd-2004
Ashley Johnson-3rd-2005
Whitney Plein-2nd-2006, 2nd-2007, 1st team-All Missouri Valley Conference-2012
Anna Nelson-3rd-2006, 3rd-2007
Connie Ferrill-3rd-2007, 2nd-2008
Kara Atkins-1st-2008
Ali Martin-3rd-2009
Miranda Kramer-2nd-2009, 1st-2010, 1st-2011, All-Tournament Team-2009, 2011, 1st Team College All-American-2015, IGHSAU Hall of Fame Inductee-2019
Katie Oleson-3rd-2010
Courtney Carl-3rd-2011
Chandra McCampbell-2nd-2012
Paige Zahner-3rd-2012, 2nd-2013
Mia Ruther-3rd-2015, 2nd-2016 1st-2017
Makaylin Powers-3rd-2018, 1st-2019
Emily Bloomer-3rd-2018
Bryanna Mehaffy-3rd-2019, 2nd-2020
Carley McGinity-2nd-2021
Kayla Norton-3rd-2021
Saydee Plummer-2nd-2022, 2nd-2023 2nd-2024
Kylee Hill-1st-2023 3rd-2024
Mady Taeger-Academic All-State-2024
Sophie Brown-Academic All-State-2025
Keirah Wiseman-Academic All-State-2025
Keirah Wiseman-2nd-2025