Anxiety and Information in an Autocracy: Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic in Russia. Conditionally accepted at the American Journal of Political Science. (with Grigore Pop-Eleches and Graeme Robertson)
Previous research documents how authoritarians seek to control the media, but we know less about what drives changes in citizens’ demand for information. We argue that crisis-driven anxiety can increase information demand of a potentially politically consequential character in autocracies. Using observational data from two nationwide surveys in Russia and an emotion induction experiment, we find that heightened anxiety about the COVID-19 pandemic leads people to want more information about the source of their anxiety, including from media sources they do not typically consume and with which they are not aligned politically. We find some evidence that anxiety increases regime supporters’ attention to opposition media; however, we more clearly demonstrate that it heightens regime opponents’ interest in pro-government sources. Together with the finding that anxiety-driven information demand in one area can reduce interest in other issues, this analysis implies that incumbents may manipulate crisis-induced anxiety to their advantage.
Democratic Backsliding and the Politicization of Public Employment. In Global Challenges to Democracy: Comparative Perspectives on Backsliding, Autocracy and Resilience, edited by Valerie J. Bunce, Thomas Pepinsky, Rachel Beatty Riedl, and Kenneth M. Roberts. Cambridge University Press, 2025. (with Frances Cayton)
This chapter examines the relationship between a politicized public sector and democratic backsliding. It is argued that politicization of public employment is an important, if understudied, component of the institutional landscape that makes democracy vulnerable. Bureaucratic politicization increases the likelihood that backsliding becomes endogenous by generating electoral advantages for incumbents and by raising the stakes of control over government. Politicization of the state administration allows incumbents to dole out patronage jobs; introduce political loyalty tests as a precondition for accessing basic government services; press public employees into campaign-related work; and utilize state funds for political purposes. Building on this volume’s aim of untangling the relationship between institutional subversion and backsliding, particular attention is given to the timing and sequencing of these processes. Evidence from Eastern Europe and a global sample shed light on how governments in countries that once seemed to be the front-runners of democratization concentrated political power by extending the economic reach of the state and subverting public sector independence. This study contributes to research on the illiberal political economy that supports backsliding regimes and their capture of key levers of political power.
Information Politics and Propaganda in Authoritarian Societies. Annual Review of Political Science 27: 263–281, 2024. (with Jeremy Wallace)
What role does propaganda play in the information politics of authoritarian societies, and what is its relationship to censorship? What have we learned from rival accounts in recent literature about why states produce it? While regimes clearly invest in propaganda believing that it is effective, there is still much to learn about whether, when, and how it actually is effective. We first discuss some of the tensions inherent in distinguishing between persuasive and dominating, soft and hard, propaganda. We then review efforts to understand the conditions under which propaganda changes attitudes and/or behavior in terms of propaganda’s content, relational factors, aspects of the political environment, and citizens’ own predispositions. We highlight the need for more research on propaganda in authoritarian settings, especially on how patterns of its consumption may change amid crises, technological shifts, and direct state interventions.
Amid ongoing uncertainty, regular surveying in Russia continues to date and collaborations with Western academics have too. These developments offer some basis for cautious optimism. Yet they also raise critical questions about the practice of survey research in repressive environments. Are Russians less willing today to respond to surveys? Are they less willing to answer sensitive questions? How can we design research to elicit truthful responses and to know whether respondents are answering insincerely about sensitive opinions? This article lays out some of the existing evidence on these important questions. It also makes the argument that cross-fertilization with other fields can help to ensure a rigorous understanding of and response to changes in the environment for survey research in Russia.
Independent Media under Pressure: Evidence from Russia. Post-Soviet Affairs 38(3): 155–174, 2022. (with Tom Paskhalis and Katerina Tertytchnaya)
Existing literature recognizes growing threats to press freedom around the world and documents changes in the tools used to stifle the independent press. However, few studies investigate how independent media respond to state pressure in an autocracy, documenting the impact of tactics that stop short of shuttering alternatives to state media. Do independent outlets re-orient coverage to favor regime interests? Or does repression encourage more negative coverage of the regime instead? To shed light on these questions, we investigate how the abrupt removal of independent outlet TV Rain from Russian television providers influenced its coverage. We find that shortly after providers dropped TV Rain, the tone of its political coverage became more positive and its similarity with state-controlled Channel 1 increased. However, these effects were short-lived. Additional evidence suggests that subscription revenue contributed to the station’s resilience. These findings add to our understanding of media manipulation and authoritarian endurance.
This commentary discusses the contributions of the special issue on Belarus’ 2020 uprising to understanding public opinion, protest, and regime crisis in countries like Belarus, and the case of Belarus itself.
Protest Participation and Attitude Change: Evidence from Ukraine’s Euromaidan Revolution. Journal of Politics 84(2): 625–638, 2022. (with Grigore Pop-Eleches and Graeme Robertson) Replication data.
Lead article
Do protests actually influence political opinions or do they merely reflect existing policy preferences? We study this issue using panel data with measures of political attitudes and behavior taken both before and after Ukraine’s Euromaidan protests. We find that protests do not just reveal protesters’ political views but also shape them. Participation changed protesters’ policy preferences on issues related to the main protest frames, and it also increased attitude coherence on core issues. In addition, protest participants experienced significant increases in political efficacy, trust and participation compared to non-participants. We show that the mechanisms underlying these attitudinal and behavioral changes are related to the experience itself of protesting, and thus depend to an important degree on protest context. These findings speak to both the short and long-term mechanisms by which protest participation can shape political engagement and public opinion.
State Dependency and the Limits of Middle Class Support for Democracy. Comparative Political Studies 54(3–4): 411–444, 2021.
Frances Rosenbluth Best Article Prize
Scholars have long viewed the middle class as an agent of democratization. This paper provides the first rigorous cross-national analysis of middle class regime preference, systematically investigating the importance of an authoritarian state’s economic relationship with the middle class. Using detailed survey data on individual employment histories from 27 post-communist countries, I show that, under autocracy, state-sector careers diminish support for democracy, especially among middle class professionals. The results are robust to changes in the measurement of both the middle class and democracy support. I also show that neither selection nor response bias, redistributive preferences, communist socialization, or transition experiences can explain the results. The findings imply that a state-supported middle class may, in fact, delay democratization.
Sensitive Survey Questions with Auxiliary Information. Sociological Methods & Research 49(2): 418–454, 2020. (with Winston Chou and Kosuke Imai) Replication data.
Scholars increasingly rely on indirect questioning techniques to reduce social desirability bias and item nonresponse for sensitive survey questions. The major drawback of these approaches, however, is their inefficiency relative to direct questioning. We show how to improve the statistical analysis of the list experiment, randomized response technique, and endorsement experiment by exploiting auxiliary information on the sensitive trait. We apply the proposed methodology to survey experiments conducted among voters in a controversial anti-abortion referendum held during the 2011 Mississippi General Election. By incorporating the official county-level election results, we obtain precinct- and individual-level estimates that are more accurate than standard indirect questioning estimates and occasionally even more efficient than direct questioning. Our simulation studies shed light on the conditions under which our approach can improve efficiency and robustness of estimates based on indirect questioning techniques. Open-source software is available for implementing the proposed methodology.
Going Public: Choosing to Work for the Russian State. In Citizens and the State in Authoritarian Regimes: Comparing China and Russia, edited by Valerie J. Bunce, Karrie J. Koesel, and Jessica Chen Weiss. Oxford University Press, 2020.
This chapter investigates the political orientations and career aspirations of students who intend to join the state sector in Russia, using original survey data from three elite Russian universities. The analysis focuses on whether and how Russia’s future public servants differ from others in their views of the importance of political freedom, order, national security, and strong economic performance. It finds that Russian youth aspire to work for an autocratic state not because they favor autocratic values nor because they hope to build more democratic institutions. Rather, their preference is based on access to recruitment channels: universities with strong alumni networks in the state apparatus or a parent working in the public sector. These findings suggest that public sector workers’ attitudes are similar to those of others at the start of their careers. Over time, however, public servants’ political attitudes diverge, suggesting that Russia’s large public sector also plays a vital role in securing regime support.
The Popularity Costs of Economic Crisis Under Electoral Authoritarianism: Evidence from Russia. American Journal of Political Science 62(2): 382–397, 2018. Replication data.
Research Highlight in Nature Human Behaviour
While a large literature recognizes that economic crises threaten the stability of electoral autocracies, we know relatively little about how citizens form economic perceptions and how they attribute blame for worsening conditions in these regimes. To gain traction on these questions, I exploit subnational variation in economic performance across Russia’s regions during a recent downturn, combining regionally representative surveys of more than 67,000 voting-age respondents with data on growth and unemployment. Contrary to conventional wisdom that citizens are passive consumers of propaganda, I show that they extract objective economic information from personal experience and local conditions. Moreover, I find that they give greater weight to this information where regional party dominance makes economic performance a clearer indicator of the ruling party’s competence and when they believe media are biased. These results suggest limits on illiberal regimes’ ability to exploit informational asymmetries to bolster popular support during economic downturns.
Reevaluating the Middle Class Protest Paradigm: A Case-Control Study of Democratic Protest Coalitions in Russia. American Political Science Review 111(4): 637–652, 2017. Replication data.
Lead article
Best Article Award Honorable Mention, Democracy & Autocracy
A large literature expects rising middle classes to promote democracy. However, few studies provide direct evidence on this group in nondemocratic settings. This article focuses on politically important internal differentiation within the middle classes, arguing that middle class growth in state-dependent sectors weakens potential coalitions in support of democratization. I test this argument using surveys conducted at mass demonstrations in Russia and detailed population data. I also present a new approach to studying protest based on case-control methods from epidemiology. The results reveal that state sector professionals were significantly less likely to mobilize against electoral fraud, even after controlling for ideology. If this group had participated at the same rate as middle class professionals from the private sector, I estimate that another 90,000 protesters would have taken to the streets. I trace these patterns of participation to the interaction of individual resources and selective incentives. These findings have implications for authoritarian stability and democratic transitions.
An Empirical Validation Study of Popular Survey Methodologies for Sensitive Questions. American Journal of Political Science 60(3): 783–802, 2016. (with Kosuke Imai and Jacob N. Shapiro) Replication data.
When studying sensitive issues such as corruption, prejudice, and sexual behavior, researchers have increasingly relied upon indirect questioning techniques to mitigate such known problems of direct survey questions as under-reporting and nonresponse. However, there have been surprisingly few empirical validation studies of these indirect techniques, because the information required to verify the resulting estimates is often difficult to access. This paper reports findings from the first comprehensive validation study of indirect methods. We estimate whether people voted for an anti-abortion referendum held during the 2011 Mississippi General Election using direct questioning and three popular indirect methods: list experiment, endorsement experiment, and randomized response. We then validate these estimates against the official election outcome. While direct questioning leads to significant under-estimation of sensitive votes against the referendum, these survey techniques yield estimates much closer to the actual vote count, with endorsement experiment and randomized response yielding least bias.
Who Follows the Autocrat? Evidence from a Panel Survey Spanning Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine (with Timothy Frye, Henry Hale and John Reuter, R&R)
Sensitivity Bias in Regime Support: Evidence from Panel Surveys in an Autocracy at War (with Timothy Frye, Henry Hale and John Reuter)
Risk Attitudes and Political Participation under Autocracy
Polarization and Support for Undemocratic Behavior: The Case of Russia (with Yunus Orhan, John Reuter, and David Szakonyi)
“Putin’s Hidden Weakness: New Evidence Shows Many Russians Support Him—but Not the War.” Foreign Affairs, March 25, 2024.
“Curious What Russians Think about the War? Ask Yourself This before You Read the Polls.” Russian Analytical Digest No. 292, February 22, 2023.
“What are Russians really thinking about the war?” The Washington Post Monkey Cage, December 29, 2022.
“Russia may be about to invade Ukraine. Russians don’t want it to.” The Washington Post Monkey Cage, February 11, 2022.
“The Kremlin has a new toolkit for shutting down independent news media.” The Washington Post Monkey Cage, June 29, 2021.
“Putin’s support is weakening. Will that show up in Russia’s regional elections this weekend?” The Washington Post Monkey Cage, September 10, 2020.
Russia’s Autocratic Resilience and the Sources of Political Change: Lankina’s Estate Origins.” Nationalities Papers, 52(6): 1431–1433, 2024.
Review of Citizen Support for Democratic and Autocratic Regimes, by Marlene Mauk. Perspectives on Politics 20(1): 339–341, 2022.
Review of Weak Strongman: The Limits of Power in Putin’s Russia, by Timothy Frye. H-Diplo XXIII-34, 2022.