PG: Dick McGuire
- PPG: 8.0, APG: 5.6, RPG: 4.2
- 8 seasons (1950-1957)
- 5x NBA All-Star (1951, 1952, 1954-1956)
- All-NBA Second Team (1951)
- NBA assists leader (1950)
- No. 15 retired by New York Knicks
PG: Walt Frazier
- PPG: 19.3, APG: 6.3, RPG: 6.1, SPG: 2.0
- 10 seasons (1968-1977)
- 2x NBA champion (1970, 1973)
- 7x NBA All-Star (1970-1976)
- NBA All-Star Game MVP (1975)
- NBA-ABA All-Star Game MVP (1971)
- 4x All-NBA First Team (1970, 1972, 1974, 1975)
- 2x All-NBA Second Team (1971, 1973)
- 7x NBA All-Defensive First Team (1969-1975)
- NBA All-Rookie First Team (1968)
- NBA 50th Anniversary All-Time Team
- No. 10 retired by New York Knicks
SG: John Starks
- PPG: 14.1, APG: 4.0, SPG: 1.2
- 8 seasons (1991-1998)
- NBA All-Star (1994)
- NBA All-Defensive Second Team (1993)
- NBA Sixth Man of the Year (1997)
SG: Earl Monroe
- PPG: 16.2, APG: 3.5, SPG: 1.0
- 9 seasons (1972-1980)
- NBA champion (1973)
- 2x NBA All-Star (1975, 1977)
- NBA's 50th Anniversary All-Time Team
- No. 15 retired by New York Knicks
SG: Dick Barnett
- PPG: 15.6
- 9 seasons (1966-1974)
- 2x NBA champion (1970, 1973)
- NBA All-Star (1968)
- No. 12 retired by New York Knicks
SG: Richie Guerin
- PPG: 20.1, RPG: 6.4, APG: 5.3
- 8 seasons (1957-1964)
- 6x NBA All-Star (1958-1963)
- 3x All-NBA Second Team (1959, 1960, 1962)
SG: Allan Houston
- PPG: 18.5, RPG: 3.1
- 9 seasons (1997-2005)
- 2x NBA All-Star (2000, 2001)
SF: Bill Bradley
- PPG: 12.4, APG: 3.4, RPG: 3.2
- 10 seasons (1968-1977)
- 2x NBA champion (1970, 1973)
- NBA All-Star (1973)
- No. 24 retired by New York Knicks
SF: Bernard King
- PPG: 26.5, RPG: 5.2, SPG: 1.2
- 4 seasons (1983-1985, 1987)
- 2x NBA All-Star (1982, 1984)
- 2x All-NBA First Team (1984, 1985)
- NBA scoring champion (1985)
SF/PF: Carmelo Anthony
- PPG: 24.7, RPG: 6.9, APG: 3.2, SPG: 1.0
- 7 seasons (2011-2017)
- 7x NBA All-Star (2011-2017)
- All-NBA Second Team (2013)
- All-NBA Third Team (2012)
- NBA scoring champion (2013)
- USA Basketball Male Athlete of the Year (2016)
PF/SF: Harry Gallatin
- PPG: 12.7, RPG: 12.1
- 9 seasons (1949-1957)
- 7x NBA All-Star (1951-1957)
- All-NBA First Team (1954)
- All-NBA Second Team (1955)
- NBA rebounding leader (1954)
PF: Dave DeBusschere
- PPG: 16.0, RPG: 10.7, APG: 3.1
- 6 seasons (1969-1974)
- 2x NBA champion (1970, 1973)
- 5x NBA All-Star (1970-1974)
- 6x NBA All-Defensive First Team (1969-1974)
- All-NBA Second Team (1969)
- NBA's 50th Anniversary All-Time Team
- No. 22 retired by the New York Knicks
PF: Charles Oakley
- PPG: 10.4, RPG: 10.0, SPG: 1.2
- 10 seasons (1989-1998)
- NBA All-Star (1994)
- NBA All-Defensive First Team (1994)
- NBA All-Defensive Second Team (1998)
C/PF: Willis Reed
- PPG: 18.7, RPG: 12.9, BPG: 1.1
- 10 seasons (1965-1974)2x NBA champion (1970, 1973)
- 2x NBA Finals MVP (1970, 1973)
- NBA Most Valuable Player (1970)
- 7x NBA All-Star (1965-1971)
- NBA All-Star Game MVP (1970)
- All-NBA First Team (1970)
- 4x All-NBA Second Team (1967-1969, 1971)
- NBA All-Defensive First Team (1970)
- NBA Rookie of the Year (1965)
- NBA 50th Anniversary All-Time Team
- No. 19 retired by New York Knicks
C/PF: Patrick Ewing
- PPG: 22.8, RPG: 10.4, BPG: 2.7, SPG: 1.0
- 15 seasons (1986-2000)
- 11x NBA All-Star (1986, 1988-1997)
- All-NBA First Team (1990)
- 6x All-NBA Second Team (1988, 1989, 1991-1993, 1997)
- 3x NBA All-Defensive Second Team (1988, 1989, 1992)
- NBA Rookie of the Year (1986)
- No. 33 retired by the New York Knicks
- NBA's 50th Anniversary All-Time Team