2005 Bobby Imbody, Kansas State University
2006 Robert Layne, Willamette University
2007 Desiree Rowe, Arizona State University
2008 August Benassi, Bradley University
2008 Amy Martinelli, University of Florida
2008 Jason Warren, George Mason University
2009 Lindsay Wakefield, University of Oklahoma
2010 Ken Young, James Madison University
2010 Megan Koch, Illinois State University
2010 Jason Stahl, Belmont University
2011 Hillary Hoover, Clemson University
2011 Abbie Syrek, University of Nebraska-Omaha
2011 Tim Brown, Cedar Crest College
2013 Rebecca Buel, University of Northern Iowa; Cadi Kadlecek, Gustavus Adolphus College
2014 Mike Chouinard, Florida State University; Darren Epping, Kansas State University; Ian Hopkins, Miami University; Austin McDonald, Louisiana State University
2015 Amy Arellano, University of Nebraska—Lincoln, Alyssa Reid, James Madison University; Nathaniel Wilson, Doane College
2016 Joshua Hamzehee, Univ. of Northern Iowa, Cameron Scott Logsdon; Univ. of Nebraska, Omaha
2017 Sade Barfield, University of Northern Iowa; Allison Bonander, University of Nebraska-Lincoln; Mickey Cox, University of Texas at Austin; Brandon Paris McCasland, Minnesota State University, Mankato.
2018 Yaw Keyermateng, Concordia University Irvine; Eddie Gamboa, Northwestern University; Mallory Marsh, University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
2019 Sam Ohrenberger-Hopkins, Seaton Hall University; Jeremy B. Frazer, Western Kentucky University
2020 Jordan Johnson, University of Nebraska-Lincoln; Ryan Tinlin, University of Texas-Austin
2021 Bill Heinze, University of Minnesota; Joe Davis, Concordia University
2022 Patrick Seick, University of Tampa
2023 Eva Margarita, University of Texas Austin; Agatha Attridge, California State University-Los Angeles
2024 Cassidy Emmerich, University of Nebraska-Lincoln; Brent Mitchell, University of Alabama