Due (10/18/22)
Update this page with current information
chain vs flat belt vs v belt
3.1.2. Chain Drive
In this concept, a chain that passes over a sprocket transfers power from the rear axle of the vehicle to the front axle to engage a four wheel drive.
The rear sprocket is attached to the output shaft of the gearbox
The front sprocket is attached to the front axle of the car
Drive reduction of 0.7:1 will be accomplished by sizing the front sprocket to be larger than the smaller sprocket
This is done because a larger diameter for the front sprocket means, when the rear sprocket finishes a revolution, the front sprocket will still be progressing through its first revolution and thus cause underdrive
Underdriving is good because it increases engine output
The chain can be tensioned with a tensioning device
Commonly used in bicycles and motorcycles
Basic components of chain drives:
Larger sprocket(Front sprocket)
Smaller sprocket (Rear Sprocket)
Chain Link
Advantages:
Applicable for a variety of distances
Compact and have overall small dimensions
Lightweight when compared to a driveshaft
Initial tension is not required
Very high efficiency (98%)
Easy to install
Low maintenance cost
Withstand abrasive conditions
Operate in wet conditions
Disadvantages:
Requires frequent lubrication
Requires precise alignment when compared to belt drives
Load capacity is less than gear drives
Requires adjustments for slack (i.e. why a tensioning device is needed
Weight:
40 series chain: .41 lb/ft
A tubular component that is connected that is connected to the gearbox(in the rear of the vehicle) in order to transmit torque from the transmission to the differential in the front of the vehicle; differential delivers torque to the front wheels which runs the vehicle
Components of a driveshaft:
Flanges
Slip yoke and tube yoke
End yoke
Midship shaft
Universal joint
Center bearing
Tube
Gears used in the final drive axle/differential are ring and pinion gears
Pinion gear is the small gear at the end of the drive shaft and connects to a larger ring gear which rotates the drive axle
In order to achieve the final drive ratio to underdrive the vehicle, one must lower the number of drive shaft rotations (pinion gear) for every tire rotation (ring gear)
Advantages of driveshaft:
Drive system is less likely to get jammed
Lower maintenance than chain and belt system
High durability
Simple construction
Low noise even at high torque
Is not jammed easily
Disadvantages of driveshaft:
High weight, especially when compared to other options
Less efficiency than a chain driven system
The shaft can be damaged when the speed is very high
Advantages of a driveshaft can often be done with a chain driven system
A trapezoidal shaped belt is looped over pulleys in order to transmit power between two or more rotating shafts, shafts that often have parallel axes of rotation
Pulleys would be placed at a measured distance to cause tension on the belt
The rotation of the rear pulley would increase the tension on one side of the belt and those create a tight side
Tight side applies tangential force to front pulley
Opposite side is the slack side
Performance of a V-belt is determined by how tightly it fits into the groove of the sheave
In order to get the appropriate drive reduction, the front pulley would larger than the rear pulley
Components of a V-belt drive system:
Front pulley
Rear pulley
V-belt
Advantages of V-belt drive system:
Less chance of slippage when compared with other belts
Fairly high efficiency when compared to driveshafts
Lubrication free
Smooth operation
Easy installation and maintenance
Low noise when operating
Disadvantages of V-belt drive system:
Limited speed range
Susceptible to wear and tear
Still prone to slippage and can be difficult to adjust
High cost when compared to flat belt
Cannot transfer power at a longer distance
A flat rectangular cross section belt that is run over a drive pulley(connect to input) to a driven pulley
Components of a Flat Belt
Front pulley
Rear pulley
V-belt
Advantages of a Flat-Belt System
Can be used for transmitting power to a long center distance (even up to 15m)
Comparatively higher efficiency than V-belts
Relatively cheap
Elasticity of belt allows for good dampening characteristics
Disadvantages of a Flat-Belt System
High Slippage
High noise
Low mechanical efficiency
Cannot achieve constant velocity ratio between driver and driven pulley
Gates GT3 5mm (20mm width 95.5mm pitch) timing belt
What is a chain drive?- A chain drive is a means of transferring mechanical power from one place to another. On a vehicle this is used to transmit power from the engine to the axles of the car. Thus achieving four wheel drive. Chain drives are most common on motorcycles and bikes but some automobiles have used them. A chain drive is mainly composed of three main parts, the chain, a rear sprocket and a front sprocket.
The rear sprocket is attached to the output shaft of the gearbox
The front sprocket is attached to the front axle of the car
Drive reduction of 0.7:1 will be accomplished by sizing the front sprocket to be larger than the smaller sprocket
This is done because a larger diameter for the front sprocket means, when the rear sprocket finishes a revolution, the front sprocket will still be progressing through its first revolution and thus cause underdrive
Under driving is good because it increases engine output
Gear Ratio- The gear ratio is the ratio of the number of turns the output shaft makes when the input shaft turns once. In the scenario where output shaft is turning slower than the input shaft the output shaft will be be turning but will be outputting more torque.
Chain Tensioning "The engineering standard for chain tension is to have between 1%-3% of the distance between the front and rear shafts in total up-and-down chain movement" https://xladv.com/articles/how-to-properly-adjust-your-drive-chain-r19/:~:text=The%20engineering%20standard%20for%20chain%20tension%20is%20to,when%20the%20chain%20is%20at%20it's%20tightest%20point
Static Analysis
The drive system of a vehicle is governed by:
Kinematics/dynamics (slider-crank mechanism, valvetrain)
Solid mechanics/FEA (component stresses)
Tribology (bearings and lubrication)
Manufacturability (casting, machining, forging)
Chain Sizing- For our chain calculations we had to make some assumptions in our calculations. We assumed that the torque coming out of the gearbox as 100ft-lb. From there we also had to make an initial assumption of the rear sprocket diameter, we chose various diameters over 2 inches as to not interfere with our CV's. Then we were able to calculate our tension in the chain as the input torque divide by the radius of the sprocket. From there we obtained the tension in the chain and where able to look at McMaster-Carr and match-up a chain that would be able to withstand that tension.
Sprocket Sizing- From our obtained chain we where then able to get the correct sprockets on McMaster-Carr to comply with our .7 under-driven ratio.
Weight
Weight was determined to be the most critical factor when choosing our choice of drive chain. Minimizing unnecessary weight is vital to building a fast and competitive car in Baja SAE competitions.
Reliability
Reliability was determined to be our second most important factor to think about. This year's Baja team’s main priority is performing well in the Endurance event. To perform well at this event our car must remain on the track for as long as possible during this 4 hour race. This means we have to choose components that can withstand the grueling challenges of this race that can put intense strain on the car.
Power Efficiency
While it is important to be able to have high power efficiency to transmit engine torque. Based on our design torque is not always being transmitted, and all options have a high efficiency. So power efficiency is not our top priority.
Maintenance
While options like the chain drive require much more maintenance than the drive belts such as needing to lubricate the chain. Maintenance is already standard practice for our Baja team so extra maintenance requirements are not a problem.
Cost
While our baja team does strive to be cost efficient and effective we have adequate fundraising and cash reverses to buy any part that we need.
Other Considerations
Based on the previous information we have picked the chain drive to be the most suitable application for our drive train. But now there are many decisions to make that will maximize the potential of our choice. One area of refinement is to add idler sprockets to our chain drive system. This will allow us to reduce the overall packaging size of the drivetrain allowing more space for other components of the car. Another decision to make is whether or not our chain and sprockets are strong enough or if we needed to manufacture special heat treated or other special manufacturing to increase the strength of these components. A big area to look into with chain drives is proper chain tensioning. Chain tensioning can make or break a chain drive system. A chain that is too tightly tensioned will wear down on the sprockets and will eventually lead to failure. While a chain that is too loosely tensioned will slip and jam.