Click on link below for an outstanding, free webinar series!
Assessing, Preventing, & Overcoming Reading Difficulties, by David Kilpatrick
A must-see presentation if your child is struggling to read!
Understanding Reading Development and Difficulties
Notes From Presentation by David Kilpatrick (1 hour 1 min)
“Research based” is not a protected term, every reading program on the market calls themselves “research based.” “Research based” = “Please buy my program”
Review of terminology:
Orthographic-the proper way to spell
Phonological awareness - strictly oral
Phonics- you have to be looking at words
You can do phonemic awareness activities with your eyes closed (no visual element)
Phonic decoding- assigning letter sound values and blending
Sight word- a familiar, instantly accessible, known word, ‘pops’ out at you
Alphabetic principle - the insight that the sounds in spoken language are represented by letters (K-1st)
Learning letter sounds- all the letters in which the first sound of the letter matches the letter are easier to learn (see below)
EX: Easier - B, D (1st sound)
More difficult - F, L, M, N (2nd sound)
Hard - H, W, Y
3 Phases of Word Reading Development:
(Children with phonological core deficit have problems with all three)
Early Phonological Awareness:
Rhyming, alliteration, syllable segmentation, Letter name & letter sound knowledge
First sound awareness
Basic Phonemic Awareness: Phonic decoding & Basic spelling skills
Segmenting & blending
Advanced Phonemic Awareness: Orthographic Mapping (efficient sight words)
Best assessed via phonemic manipulation acquisition- a rudimentary version of #3
And timed word lists overlaps with #2
ALL THREE PHASES REQUIRE PHONOLOGICAL SKILLS
Poor phonological skills disrupt any or all phases.
Rapid naming correlates with reading
Rapid naming Demo 1: Just ignore the words and quickly name the colors (visual - a list of printed color words such as ‘blue’ written in print with an opposing color)
Most K students can do this task quicker than older students/adults
Demo 2: quickly name the objects, just ignore the printed words (visual - rows of objects with opposing print on them, ex- a picture of a star with the word triangle written on it.
You have to put effort into not saying words- that’s sight vocabulary, you can’t supress them, they ‘pop’ out, they are effortless and precognitive.
The elusive key to reading fluency is sight vocabulary size. With a large sight vocabulary most (or all words) ‘pop out,’ reading is faster and accurate with a limited sight vocabulary. Reading is effortless and often inaccurate because too many words require attention and strategic decoding.
If you are good at orthographic mapping reading practice is tremendous. If you are not good at orthographic mapping, you keep reading the same words over and over and they are not picked up.
“Reading practice when you are a poor orthographic mapper is like writing on laminated paper”- D.Kilpatrick
Sight vocabulary is compromised in students with reading difficulties/disabilities.
In most weak readers, fluency is NOT primarily due to inadequate practice.
Very little ‘practice’ is needed to add words to one’s sight vocabulary for typically developing readers.
From 2nd grade on, 1 to 4 exposures is all that is needed for permanent storage! Consider typical growth rates from grades 1 to 3 (YAIT studies)
Once you have a sight word, you always have it.
Kids with reading problems- 12,20, 30 exposures needed.
Skilled readers exclusively rely on sight vocabulary unless they encounter a new, unfamiliar word.
Understanding sight word development is central to understanding & addressing most word level reading problems.
How sight vocabulary is developed- an intro to orthographic mapping
Sight word vocabulary is not based in visual memory/visual skills
Our intuition fails us here
Input and storage are not the same thing
Input is visual, storage is orthographic, phonological and semantic
Cattell’s findings in 1886 - flashed items quickly on a screen- drawing of a chair, and also the word ‘chair’- substantial difference between picture and printed word chair, printed word was faster, this was the first clue that visual memory is NOT the key
Findings from the 1970’s- correlation between word reading and visual memory-zero to weak
Reading disabled kids have equivalent visual memory to non-reading disabled kids
1960’s to 1980’s MiXeD cAsE sTuDiEs- reaction time was slower than when reading regular case, researchers quickly (and wrongly) assumed a visual connection. Study redone later- Ex: Wedding invite script- script is initially harder to read, but then you adjust.
Printed words are read instantly and effortlessly based on orthographic memory, not visual memory
Orthographic mapping- the mental process we use to store words for instant retrieval.
Orthographic mapping is how we efficiently turn unfamiliar words into familiar words.
Orthographic mapping is the mechanism for building one’s sight vocabulary.
Weak readers are inefficient orthographic mappers!
Letter-sound knowledge is an early predictor of difficulties
Having a hard time picking up letter names and letter sounds is a marker for a phonological core deficit.
Phonological Awareness vs. Phonological Proficiency
Phonological awareness (PA)- tied to performance on specific tasks (rhyming, alliteration, segmenting, blending, isolation, identification, categorization, manipulation)
All PA tasks correlate with reading development
Everyone agrees it is important
Most intuitively assume it simply relates to phonic decoding and spelling (but don’t fully understand relationship)
Phonemic proficiency - has a very detailed relationship with reading development
Ties with our theories of word reading development
Explains sight word acquisition (obviously not an intuitive conclusion)
Appears to be the holy grail of understanding orthographic mapping (i.e. sight word learning) and the intervention studies with most effective outcomes
**Intervention studies with phonemic/phonological proficiency had the best results
Phonological/phonemic proficiency:
Broadly:
Phonemic proficiency represents amount of phonological/phonemic skills needed to be an efficient word-level reader.
Phonological vs. phonemic depends on level of development
Narrowly:
Phonemic is the ability to instantly & automatically (without conscious attention) regard the phonemic properties of spoken words
Phonological proficiency is not adequately captured in our K-1 screeners
PA develops until 3-6th grade, it doesn’t stop at 1st.
* This further development is critical for sight word development
Test of Word Reading Efficiency - Good readers by 2nd grade can decode non-words instantly, fetching the letter-sound relationships
Phonological/Phonemic Proficiency:
More difficult tasks & timing/automaticity are better estimates (manipulation, timed word reading)
Why deletion and substitution PA tasks are better assessments of phonemic proficiency
It’s all about automaticity & implicit access to the phonemic segments, phonemic segmentation tasks do not necessarily assess that. Segmenting assessment is not enough
The self-teaching hypothesis- We were only directly taught a tiny fraction of the 40,000 to 90,000 words in our sight vocabulary. Most were learned ‘in real time’ while reading. We taught them to ourselves. What was needed: phonic decoding skills and phonemic proficiency
How we map words
‘Transparent’ words - words with 1:1 correspondence
RED- /r/ /e/ /d/-(phoneme awareness/analysis- red (oral first- a mind prepared to store words)
Letter sound knowledge, orthographic mapping, phonemic analysis skills, phonological long term memory activation
You can have good phonic skills and not good orthographic mapping skills
How we map words- words that are ‘opaque’ (words without a 1-1 correspondence)
EX: Make, Read, Comb
If we have the pronunciation, we can anchor the sequence to that pronunciation
It now becomes a familiar sequence, from then on, will not confuse red with read
Breakthrough in intervention research
Kilpatrick’s 90/10 “insight” Spring 2013
After meeting with Dr. Ehri & Dr. Share, went back through the National Reading Panel Studies
**About 80%-90% of intervention studies show a 0-9 standard score (SS) point improvement while about 10%-20% of intervention studies whoe 12.5 to 25 SS point improvement, results maintained at 1,2,3, & 4 year follow ups (depending on the study)
Results for the 0-8 studies often lost in follow up studies
These are studies re: word level reading skills
Summer 2014- The 80%-90% can be subdivided
0 to 5 SS points & 6-9 SS points, thus a ‘tripartite’ division within the intervention research
Minimal results group- 0 to 5 SS improvements, mostly 2-4 points
Moderate results group - 6 to 9 SS improvements, mostly 6-7 points
Highly successful group - 12.5 to 25 SS point improvements, mostly 14-17 points (basically a standard deviation of improvement) and gains maintained
Tripartite Intervention Research:
Studies in all three categories cut across-
Age/grade
SES
Group size (1:1 vs. 3:1)
Severity of reading difficulties
Length of intervention
Such factors cannot explain the disparity of outcomes,
6 to 8 recent meta-analysis of intervention focused on these and missed the glaring tripartite division
All categories used explicitly systematic phonics, this phonics is not the answer
It’s an important PART of the answer: All studies NOT using phonics were in the 0-5 minimal outcome group (phonics is necessary but not sufficient)
The phonological Proficiency Intervention Continuum:
The 3 categories based on outcomes align with 3 different intervention approaches relative to orthographic mapping!
Minimal group (0-5 SS improvements)-
None formally trained in phonological awareness/analysis
Most did explicit, systematic phonics
All provided reading practice with connected text
Moderate group (6-9 SS improvements)-
All did explicit, systematic phonics
All provided reading practice
All but one trained phonological segmenting and/or blending
(This is BASIC phonological awareness, mastered by most at end of 1st grade)
HIGHLY SUCCESSFUL GROUP (12-25 SS improvements)-
Aggressively addressed/‘fixed’ phonological awareness issues using advanced PA training, all did explicit systematic phonics
All provided reading practice with connected text
These interventions gave the students the foundational tools for orthographic mapping, turned these kids into good orthographic mappers
They now became efficient at adding words to their sight vocab, apparently none of the interventions did this
There was a fluency lag, however
Fluency improved, but not to the same degree as isolated word reading
Capacity to add to the sight vocabulary vs. actual sight vocabulary based on reading experience (Have not had years of reading experience their typical peers have had)
Intervention with at-risk and weak readers:
Conclusions consistent with orthographic mapping
Unless the problem with advanced phonemic awareness is fixed, poor word level readers don’t catch up
Advanced phonemic awareness is necessary for sight word development and if they don’t have it, they cannot efficiently add to their sight vocabulary.
The ‘Formula’ for Word-Level Reading Success:
The three part formula used in studies with highly successful outcomes:
Aggressively train phonological awareness to the advanced level
Teach and/or reinforce letter-sound knowledge and skills (phonics)
Extensive opportunities to read connected text
Phonological awareness assessment training is typically segmentation, which only takes a child to an ending 1st grade level. This is not enough PA for orthographic mapping.
PA continues to grow past 1st grade
PA often wrongly assumed not be helpful with older students
PA assessments only take us to the basic level. We do not assess the advanced level on our current tests
Summary of Prevention and Intervention:
There is a singular developmental path of typical word level reading from letter name knowledge to fluent reading of multisyllabic words in connected text.
This singular path involves the development of phonological proficiency and letter-sound/phonic proficiency.
The goal is to get students to develop orthographic mapping skills- phonic decoding is a very important step along the way. Also a lifelong skill for encountering unfamiliar written words.
Fluency does not appear to be an additional reading skill independent of this singular process. Fluency appears to be a byproduct of the efficiency of reading development.