Welcome, Detectives!
Crime Scene Investigation
Russell County Middle School
Welcome, Detectives!
Thank you so much for coming so quickly…this is not an easy case to solve. We have a lot of work ahead of us because this case is a tricky one. Today is March 6, 1770 and last night there was some type of fight between the colonists here in Boston and the British soldiers that are stationed here. We’re not sure exactly what happened but we do know that shots were fired and five colonists are now dead. Your task is to sort through all of the evidence to determine whether the British soldiers murdered the American colonists or whether the entire incident was an accident that happened in self-defense.
As you read and listen to the accounts as well as look at the art, please remember that the people and artists have bias, which means that they were on one side or the other. Their perception of the event might change what they see or they may even be willing to lie about the incident. Your job is to sort through all the evidence and try to determine the facts. The people of Boston are extremely angry right now so we want to make sure we do a good job of truly studying the evidence. As you find important information, record it in your detective's notebook.
Good luck... this might be the hardest case you will ever try to solve!
Bias: A judgment based on a personal point of view (favoring some ideas or people over others).
Objective: not influenced by personal feelings, interpretations, or prejudice; based on facts; unbiased.
Propaganda: information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view.
Massacre: an indiscriminate and brutal slaughter of a large number people.
We have exclusive footage of the aftermath of the incident. Watch this and look for clues. Take some notes on the physical environment of the site of the massacre and look and listen to the people portrayed.
What time of day was it?
What time of year was it?
What are the people yelling?
Why did John Adams run to the water pump?
Before the incident 600 British soldiers had occupied Boston as a police force for two years. They were there to enforce British and tax and custom law that had been resisted by some Boston residents, often violently. The soldiers were not welcome by the townspeople of Boston and hostility had been growing between civilians and soldiers.
On March 5, 1770 a crowd of about 400 colonists (all men accept for one woman) confronted a squad of eight British soldiers. The crowd threw snow balls and other objects at the soldiers, many of the men in the crowd carried clubs. The eight soldiers loaded their muskets and formed a single line facing the crowd.
Their commander, Captain Thomas Preston, stood in front of his soldiers and asked the crowd to go home. But the crowd, far from drawing back, came close, calling out, "Come on you rascals, you bloody backs, you lobster scoundrels, fire if you dare, .........we know you dare not" and striking at the soldiers with clubs and a cutlass. Someone yelled “Fire!” and shots rang out. The soldiers and the crowd battled briefly. As a result of this incident five Bostonians would die – three that night (Samuel Gray, Crispus Attucks, and James Caldwell) and two within a few days (Samuel Maverick and Patrick Carr). Six other Bostonians were injured. Captain Preston and eight soldiers were arrested for murder.
Preparations for the trial began almost immediately. Witnesses were summoned to appear before the justices and give statements about what they saw, and the British military collected witness statements as well. A Boston lawyer, John Adams, was asked to represent Captain Preston. Adams took the case because he believed the defendant was entitled to a lawyer. He also agreed to defend the eight soldiers. The trials took place October 24-30 and November 27-December 5, 1770.
Additionally, may people rushed to publish either in newspapers, letters, or illustrations their version of what happened that night. Colonists called this incident the “Boston Massacre,” but there was great controversy about who was to blame for what happened that night. The controversies lasted for many years after this incident.
Sources:• Source Citation: "The Boston Massacre Trials (1754-1783)" American Eras. 8 vols. Gale • Research, 1997-1998. Reproduced in History Resource Center. Farmington Hills, MI: Gale Group. http://galenet.galegroup.com/servlet/HistRC• Boston Massacre Historical Society, http://bostonmassacre.net• “The Boston Massacre Files,” The Boston Society