Imagining New Worlds: Reclaiming Native Hawaiian Narratives on TikTok
Karina Cherniske
Department of Sociology & Anthropology, University of Puget Sound
Department of Sociology & Anthropology, University of Puget Sound
ABSTRACT
Narratives shape mindsets and in turn influence actions. If someone has no prior knowledge of a place or a people other than reductive stereotypes, they are less likely to engage with it in a respectful and reciprocal way. This is true of the Hawaiian islands. "The thing is, nobody knows how to ask questions. Nobody really understands how to ask, because not a lot of people actually know that Hawaiians really even exist." The dominant narrative that the United States has of the Hawaiian islands is that it is the 50th state and a prime destination for vacation, with a welcoming population and beautiful and pristine natural environment. This limited narrative is problematic in countless ways. Centuries of history, cultural context, and contemporary struggle are masked by this narrative. Social media is one tool used to shape narrative that is particularly relevant today, given the increased dialogue and discourse happening online since the pandemic has pushed us deeper into the virtual world. For this thesis I interviewed 10 Native Hawaiian (Kanaka Maoli, or Kanaka) individuals who use social media, TikTok specifically, to present an alternative narrative: one that more accurately represents the rich and complex history and culture of the Hawaiian Islands and its people. They achieve this by providing historical overviews, language lessons, personal anecdotes, speaking out about gentrification and appropriation, and modifying popular trends. Through my research interviewing and participating in Hawaii TikTok I found that Kanaka creators reach a wide age range of individuals both in Hawaii and around the world. They help other Kanaka connect back to their culture and instill cultural values and pride in young Native Hawaiians. Additionally, they address problematic trends and videos that reduce the islands to a narrow view of paradisiacal self-improvement, and call for a more equitable tourism sector and investment in Indigenous lives.
OBJECTIVES, RELEVANCE, QUESTION
This research begins to overcome the limits of existing studies on social media use for political mobilization by engaging Native Hawaiian TikTok users who use their platforms to address misconceptions about their home and raise awareness on issues facing Hawaiians. This research is important because it highlights social media activism by Indigenous Hawaiians as a method of reshaping the unequal relations between the US and Hawaii by providing information from primary sources and contextualizing the issues facing Native Hawaiians within a settler colonial framework.
To accomplish this I employ the theoretical frameworks of:
Manuel Castells: Social movement theory in the Internet Age which discusses the limitations and opportunities of virtual activism
McAdams social movement theory that classifies social movement as collective and ongoing
Indigenous Scholars like H.K. Trask and Audra Simpson on decolonial concepts of sovereignty and refusal
Reclaiming Native Truths study on Indigenous representation and perception in North America
The hashtag Hawaii has been viewed 9.08 billion times
The most viewed videos typically showcase the natural beauty of the Islands in a feminized way
DATA and METHODS
Hawaii's last Monarch:
Queen Liliuokalani
I conducted semi-structured interviews 10 Hawaiian creators about their experience using TikTok as a tool for education and activism. Additionally, I conducted several months worth of virtual participant observation through following trends and other content in the world of Hawaii TikTok and engaging with content from Hawaiian users. I found participants through hashtags and snowball sampling and received verbal consent from all participants.
FINDINGS and DISCUSSION
"we want to share with other people, we want to welcome people here. But when we welcome and we give, which historically we keep on giving, giving, giving, what do we get back? We fight for what we get. And that’s a continued fight constantly for our housing, for our sacred spaces, for resources in general." - Melissa
I found that beyond just communicating to outsiders about their home and culture, Native Hawaiian creators use TikTok to find community and connect other Hawaiians back to their roots. Whether it's through years of dancing Hula, dedication to learning and spreading Olelo Hawaii (Hawaiian language), or following in a legacy of cultural educators, each creator uses their unique life experiences and fields of expertise to educate those in their own communities and abroad, and reclaim the narrative of Hawaii. This is accomplished on TikTok through the ability to go viral from the For You Page, and also through interactive sharing options like duetting and stitching. Many creators used the metaphor of their ability to "plant a seed", to present an alternative view to what mainstream educational institutions teach about Hawaii and in turn transform the nature of how outsiders perceive their role in upholding these inequalities.
CONCLUSIONS
Algorithmic pros and cons: Creators had mixed reviews of the overall structure of the app, saying that they appreciate the aspects of Indigenous solidarity it fosters and the wide scope of individuals their videos are viewed by, but also felt censored at times and that the impersonal interface could lead to slacktivism.
Expressing refusal: Through their platforms, creators expressed refusal in many ways. Refusal to be subjects of American government, refusal to allow people to spread hate and bigotry, refusal to accept the glorification of the neocolonial nature of tourism and gentrification on their islands, and much more.
Informed and Experienced: Informed by researching Hawaiian Kingdom royalty and learning from relatives and cultural teachers in their communities, creators use their areas of interest and expertise to communicate important issues.
A Legacy of Learning: TikTok provides a virtual space for a continuation of the Hawaiian Renaissance that occured in the 1970's which was reignited by A Ole TMT (Mauna Kea). The teaching, learning and sharing that occurs on the platform, which trolls attempt to disrupt, is a continuation of these movements to protect and expand cultural knowledge that is embedded in the community of Kanaka creators.
Transforming Tourism: Many users address the exploitative nature of tourism in their videos and interact with visitors virtually. Through interviews we discussed alternative forms of tourism that incorporate more service and cultural learning. When one of my participants posted about this possibility, hundreds of people expressed excitement about the idea. This shows the sentiment that many of my participants shared which is that people are becoming more and more willing and interested in learning the true history of Hawaii from the Indigenous perspective.
Kanaka Maoli flag towel advertisement shows the dissonance between representations of whitewashed paradise and rooted resistance
A 'Ole TMT protests at Mauna Kea where cultural knowledge was shared by Kupuna (elders). The upside down Hawaiian flag in the background signifies solidarity with Hawaiian sovereignty.
KEY REFERENCES
Castells, Manuel. 2012. Networks of Outrage and Hope: Social Movements in the Internet Age. Polity Press.
Castells, Manuel. 1999. Information technology, globalization and social development (No. 114). Geneva: UNRISD.
McAdam, Doug. "Culture and social movements." Culture and politics. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, 2000. 253-268.
Trask, Haunani-Kay. 1991. “Lovely Hula Hands: Corporate Tourism and Prostitution of Hawaiian Culture.” Border/Lines, (23).
Reclaiming Native Truth, firstnations.org. 2020.