All Ohio
Doyle Smales 1955 RB Columbus Jaycees, Chic Harley All-Star
Marty McCorkle 1960 RB 3rd Team
Wayne Williams 1964 OL 2nd Team
Stan Lewis 1969 OL 2nd Team
Joe Boggs 1975 DL 3rd Team
Tim Williams 1976 RB 1st Team Back of the Year
Doug Hale 1976 LB 2nd Team
Doug Hale 1977 LB 1st Team Lineman of the Year
Randy Yates 1979 LB 2nd Team
Shane McCoy 1982 QB 3rd Team
Jim Slone 1982 TE 1st Team
Johnny Harrison 1983 WR 1st Team
Brian Hughes 1983 OL 3rd Team
Larry Adkins 1985 LB 3rd Team
Michael Hale 1987 DB 2nd Team
Bobby Ward 1988 RB 1st Team
Josh Ruff 1989 RB 1st Team
Jeff Webb 1989 OL 1st Team
Chad Jones 1991 DL 2nd Team
Bill Potter 1991 RB 2nd Team
Benjie Lewis 1992 WR 2nd Team
Mike Harden 1993 RB 2nd Team
Andy Orender 1997 RB 2nd Team
Jesse Slone 2009 QB 1st Team
Joey Maynard 2009 WR 3rd Team
Jesse Slone 2010 QB 2nd Team
Joey Maynard 2010 WR 3rd Team
Westen Hale 2010 RB 1st Team
Chris Fairchild 2010 DL 2nd Team
Chris Fairchild 2011 OL 2nd Team
Justin Dickens 2012 DL 3rd Team
Justin Dickens 2013 DL 1st Team
Jonathon Harrison 2013 DB 3rd Team
Jonathon Harrison 2014 WR 3rd Team
Bayley Clutters 2017 LB 2nd Team
Bayley Clutters 2018 LB 2nd Team