I teach the same course both virtually and face to face. When I teach this class online, the grade distribution is much higher than when I teach it in person. At the same time, I feel like students are actually learning less (and I don’t teach as well online as I do in person). Part of the reason students’ grades are higher when I teach online is that I give them points to incentivize them to do things like participate in a discussion board, but I don’t feel like I need to do that to get them to participate in an in-person discussion. How can I ensure that students get a more similar experience (both in grades, but especially actual learning) regardless of the instruction mode in which I’m teaching?
A Textual description for the Dashboard Screenshot Virtual and Face-to-Face / Pass Rate vs. Quality Scenario Images below are available in a Google Doc.
The mode of instruction will impact the way that students engage with the course. While incentivizing participation with points might be tempting, you are correct in your observation that it may not translate to better learning outcomes. Think about why you use discussion as a learning strategy, and what aspects of the in-class discussion you find to be effective. In the online class, rather than offer points for completion, consider using a small rubric to evaluate quality of responses.
Consider where there is opportunity for flexible assessments into the course, where students can select how they are assessed from a few options you provide. This gives students an additional stake in the assignment and is an opportunity to work with their learning preference/personal needs without sacrificing rigor via additional free points. Go through your existing assignments with a +1 mindset: “what is one additional way a student could show me they [insert existing assignment learning objective]?”
To activate your CSUCI institutional OneHE account, please complete this interest form.