Analyze

Figure 1: Picture of MVCC Campus Credit: MVCC

Moraine Valley Community College and the Numbers

As a general average, college campuses use 18.9 kWh of electricity per square foot of a building per year [1]. The buildings on MVCC’s campus are collectively 1,032,000 square feet [2]. Using these values, the college campus uses an estimated 19,504,800 kWh of electricity for each year. The campus operates 94 hours per week, meaning roughly 9.531010 kW of electricity is consumed per year [3].

Analyzing the Energy Options for MVCC

Solar

A commonly considered form of renewable energy that could be a source of electricity for Moraine Valley is solar energy. The college campus already has made steps towards implementing solar power for the campus’s energy production, and the next step is to now consider this on a larger scale [4]. Solar panels operate at an efficiency of about 20% and have a wattage output ranging from 2.5 kW to 4 kW [5]. They also require an average of five hours of direct sunlight a day in order to function properly [6].

Figure 2: Solar Panel Rows Photographer Credit: SunPower [8]

Assuming weather conditions in Palos Hills, the town MVCC is located, can provide this appropriate amount of sunlight, the total amount is still limited. There are only 189 sunny days, on average, in the town of Palos Hills [7]. Using these averages, a single solar panel installed on campus can generate 2360 - 3780 kWh of electricity per year. Moraine Valley would need to establish a solar energy plant with 5,160 solar panels with an output of 4kW or 2,064 panels outputting 10kW in order to match the campus’s yearly electricity usage. The average size of a 4kW solar panel is 65in by 39in or 5.4ft by 3.25ft [8]. Given these dimensions, 5,160 solar panels of this size would require 2.10 acres of space if installed flat, side-by-side, and not angled upwards. The solar panels could also be installed in various locations around campus and not all be necessarily congested in a single location. While the initial expense for switching to complete use of solar energy is high, Moraine Valley could logistically make the switch and derive all of its electricity from the sun.

Figure 3: Geothermal Process Credit: Ablison

Geothermal

While highly improbable for real use for Moraine Valley, geothermal energy plants are high producing in electricity. The vast majority of effective geothermal plants are located in the western portion of the United States since geothermal resources are closer to the surface in these regions [9]. Since the Moraine Valley Community College campus is within northern Illinois, a significantly cooler location in terms of geothermal energy, a plant concentrated on this energy production would not find success.

The plant also demands a large plot of land to operate. A geothermal power plant would need up to 404 square miles in order to function [10]. Moraine Valley’s campus is significantly smaller than this required amount, taking up a little less than half a square mile of land. It is not possible to implement this type of power plant on a small community college campus. If a geothermal plant could, however, be used to provide electricity to the campus, the plant’s average output would be 1 GWh or 1106kWh [10]. The plant would also operate at an average efficiency of 12% [11]. The production rate of a geothermal plant would meet 5.13% of the electricity currently used by the college campus.

Wind

A different potential source of energy for a power plant on the community college campus is the use of energy derived from wind. The college already considered the plausibility of obtaining energy from wind through the potential installation of a 30 kW wind turbine directly on campus [4]. A possible type of 30kW wind turbine that could be implemented in an energy plant for the campus is the WT3 Vertical Axis Wind Turbine by Sunsurfs; this turbine is capable of outputting 30 kW and needs a wind speed of 4 mph to start up [12]. MVCC resides in the town of Palos Hills, which averages a daily wind speed of 10.5 mph, 8.2 mph in the calmer months, and 13 mph in the windiest months [13]. Based on these averages, wind turbines as a source of energy for a plant placed on or near MVCC’s campus would be supplied with a steady source of wind. The plant could operate consistently and daily under these conditions.

Figure 4: Horizontal Rotating Wind Turbine Credit: SunSurf Solar [12]

Each wind turbine must be placed 10m or 32.8 ft apart for safe use [12]. Given that the campus size is 307 square feet and assuming only a quarter can be devoted to the plant, only three to four wind turbines can be safely installed on campus. If the wind turbines operated daily for a full year, they would output an average of 1.05106kW of electricity, making up only 0.011% of the total electricity consumed by Moraine Valley. Even with these values, the wind turbines would be operating at the high efficiency of 30-45% [14]. The limited space on the college campus does not allow for the proper use of a wind-based energy plant. Wind turbines require large spacing for safe function, and MVCC does not have the acreage to accommodate this. The use of an energy plant focused on wind is highly inefficient for the small campus.

Figure 5: Hydro Implementation Photographer Credits: Cal Sag [15]

Hydro

Due to the nature of the size of the Moraine Valley campus and its limitations, there is little plausibility in implementing a hydro-plant for the campus. Detailed in Figure I, there are sources of water on the campus, but they are limited to small ponds; there are no direct connections to larger bodies of water such as rivers or lakes. If the range is expanded to outside the boundaries of MVCC, the plausibility of using hydropower does not change. The closest body of water to the campus with the potential of being used for hydropower is the Calumet Sag River, however, there are issues with using this source of water.

The Calumet Sag River was built as a ship canal that carries large barges, meaning the river was designed for single, particular use [15]. Implementing a hydro plant would encroach too heavily into the narrowness of the river, obstructing the movement of the barges that are required to travel the length of the Calumet Sag. In addition to this, hydropower has both positive and negative impacts on the environment. While lowering greenhouse gas emissions, hydropower plants can cause rivers to dry up quickly through a combination of increased water surface area and evaporation, essentially consuming the water supply [16]. With this factor taken into account, a system such as this could be detrimental to the Calumet Sag River as it could result in damage to the necessary travel route. Neglecting these issues, the implementation of hydropower on this community college campus could take on a majority of the energy production needed for full functionality. In dams, hydropower can convert about 90% of the energy from falling water into usable electricity [17]. With an average of about 9.85 gallons of water per kilowatt-hour, it would take approximately 938.7 billion gallons of falling water per year to power MVCC [18].

Biomass

Biomass plants make use of waste to generate electricity. Possible sources of input for a biomass plant include waste produced by humans, animals, forests, agriculture, and industries [19]. The area surrounding Moraine Valley Community College is a heavily populated suburb; there are no nearby animal or agricultural farms nor are there large industrial factories; the land around MVCC is used by homes and small businesses, leaving the only potential source of fuel for a biomass plant to be waste from humans. To keep the focus even more centralized, the only waste to be used in the biomass plant will be derived from only Moraine Valley. There is an average of 25,000 people attending and working on campus [4].

Figure 6: Biomass Materials Credit: Let's Talk Science

The amount of energy produced from the sewage created from the college campus would equate to a rough maximum of 4.97109 kWh of electricity [20]. The power plant would be operating at an efficiency of 35-40% to obtain this electricity [21]. If the plant was capable of operating at this maximum efficiency, then a biomass plant could sufficiently supply enough electricity to power MVCC twice over. While this causes the biomass plant to be the best option for an alternate power source for the community college, the issue in implementing such a power plant arises in cost and limitations of space.

Analyzing the Efficiency of the Abbott Power Plant

The Abbott steam power plant is an energy source that uses the Rankine cycle to create energy. Using methane, or natural gas, the power plant heats up compressed liquid in a boiler to create steam. This steam then passes through a turbine attached to a generator, creating consumable energy. After this, the vapor is compressed back into liquid. The liquid is then compressed once more in preparation for evaporation for the cycle to continue [22].

Figure 7: Simplified Rankine Cycle Credits: Energy Education

Work, power, heat, and efficiency calculations using the ideal Rankine cycle and given condition values of the Abbott steam power plant.

With the given conditions of the local Abbott steam power plant, it was calculated that the overall efficiency is about 15.81%. Meanwhile, the efficiency of solar power is about 20%, geothermal power is about 12%, wind power is 30-45%, hydropower is about 90%, and local biomass power is 35-40%. It can be seen that all of these energy sources, aside from geothermal power, are more efficient than the Abbott power plant. A few of these energy sources, such as solar panels, take up less land, resulting in better use of the given community college campus space. The benefit in energy production from a source like the Abbott power plant is its consistent energy production. The more eco-friendly options of solar panels and wind turbines rely on particular weather conditions in order to operate.

Aside from its decrease in efficiency, the Abbott power plant also has another large downside: sustainability. The power plant relies on methane as its main source of heating the boiler to produce steam. Although methane is a cleaner fossil fuel, the process of burning fossil fuels still adds to the ongoing climate crisis by producing more greenhouse gasses. Increasing the quantity of greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere forces the energy source to be unsustainable in the long run. With this in mind, using the Abbott power plant as a main source of energy would go against the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) proposed in 2015, which hopes to eliminate poverty, inequality, lack of education, and environmental deterioration by the year 2030 [23]. In particular, it goes against SDG 7, which states that in order to create a better world for all of humanity, we must “ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for all” [24]. In contrast, relying on more eco-friendly energy sources would drastically reduce greenhouse gas emissions, aiding in the achievement of SDG 7. If MVCC starts its conversion to solar energy within the next few years, it could rely solely on sustainable energy before 2030. By converting to solar energy and storing the energy for later use, Moraine Valley Community College could be one of hopefully many institutions that aid in reaching all Sustainability Development Goals by 2030.

Figure 8: SGD 7 on Sustainable Development Goals Credit: United Nations