+------------+
| FIRST PAGE |
+------------+
► Ada singkatan di judul (jumlah kata dan baris oke)
Please expand the abbreviation(s)/acronym(s)
► Judul lebih dari 3 baris/lebih dari 10 frasa
Please simplify the title into max. 10 words (prepositions excluded)
► Ada singkatan di judul dan judul lebih dari 3 baris/lebih dari 10 frasa
Please expand the abbreviation(s)/acronym(s), then simplify the title into max. 10 words (prepositions excluded, the full term of the acronyms counted as 1 word)
► Ada singkatan di nama author, misal:
Afizan Azman --> OK
Mohd. Fikri Azli Abdullah --> OK
Kalaiarasi S. Muthu --> OK
S. Yogarayan --> X
A. Y. Abdelaziz --> X"
Please provide all authors' full names, without abbreviation
► Affiliasi kurang kota
Please provide the city of this affiliation.
► Affiliasi tidak lengkap (dari universitas)
Please provide authors' affiliations completely and hierarchically from the lowest level into the highest one: Laboratorium (if any, or if under a department), Department (if any), Faculty, University, City, Country
► Keyword lebih dari 7 kata
Please reduce the keywords into max. 7
► Keyword ada singkatan
Please expand the abbreviation(s)/acronym(s)
+----------+
| ABSTRACT |
+----------+
► Ada sitasi di abstrak
There should be no citation in Abstract, please remove it.
► Jumlah kata lebih dari 200 (atau sampai introduction tidak kelihatan di halaman 1)
Please simplify the abstract into max. 200 words.
► Singkatan (tidak ada kepanjangan di paper/dicari tidak ketemu)
Please expand the full term of an acronym when it is mentioned for the first time (excluded from the main article).
+----------------------+
| BATANG TUBUH ARTIKEL |
+----------------------+
► Paragraf kurang dari 3 kalimat (cek per kasus tertentu)
Please elaborate this paragraph into at least 3 sentences, or merge this with the previous/next paragraph(s).
In one paragraph there are at least 3 sentences. please add a few more sentences.
► Paragraf terlalu panjang
Paragraph is too long. please break it into paragraphs.
► Ada bahasa Indonesia atau bahasa asing lainnya yang bukan bahasa Inggris (dan bukan merupakan variabel pemrograman) --> kalau kira-kira typo dan tahu benarnya, betulkan sendiri; kalau gak tau, lapor ke grup
Please translate it into English.
► Singkatan yang tidak ada kepanjangannya di paper/dicari tidak ketemu
Please expand the full term of an acronym when it is mentioned for the first time (abstract excluded).
Please complete the abbreviation with its abbreviation. check all the abbreviations in your paper and make sure they all have a length.
+-------+
| TABLE |
+-------+
► Tabel dalam bentuk gambar
Please convert this table into in-text table (not in the form of a picture/screenshot).
► Ada tabel yang tidak disebut dalam body-text
A table must be mentioned and explained in the body-text before it appears; please cite this table.
► Penyebutan tabel di paragraf tidak urut
Please number the tables consecutively based on the order of mention in the body-text.
► Ada bahasa Indonesia atau bahasa asing lainnya yang bukan bahasa Inggris (dan bukan merupakan variabel pemrograman) kecuali sudah disebutkan/dijelaskan maknanya sebelumnya [CEK PER KASUS!]
Please translate this into English; however, if this should be in English, please provide the English translation so that our readers can understand your idea completely.
+--------+
| FIGURE |
+--------+
► Figure blur (tidak ada tulisan apa pun di gambar)
Please enhance this image into a better quality/resolution.
► Figure blur (ada tulisan di gambar dan tidak terbaca)
Please enhance this image into a better quality/resolution so that the text is readable.
► Figure tidak disebut/dijelaskan di body text (tidak ada subfigure-nya)
A figure must be mentioned and explained in the body-text before it appears; please cite this figure.
► Figure tidak disebut/dijelaskan di body text (ada subfigure-nya)
A figure (including EACH of the subfigures) must be mentioned and explained in the body-text before it appears; please cite this figure.
► Subfigure (a), (b), … tidak disebut/dijelaskan di body text
If a figure contains subfigures, please mention EACH subfigures in the body-text after mentioning the main figure
► Figure induk tidak disebutkan sebelum subfigure (a), (b), dst.
Please mention the whole Figure 1 first before the sub-figure of Figure 1(a) and 1(b).
► Penyebutan figure di paragraf tidak urut
Please number the figures consecutively based on the order of mention in the body-text.
► Belum ada caption untuk subfigure (a), (b), dst
"Please complete the caption by adding descriptions/phrases for the subfigures (a), (b), (c), … after the main phrases.
Ex: Figure 2. Comparing simulation results in wind turbine performance with the power control mode to that with the rotor speed control mode in (a) energy output and (b) smoothing function"
► Belum ada caption/keterangan induk di figure
"Please complete the caption by adding the main description/main phrases for the whole Figure 1 before the subfigures (a) and (b).
Ex: Figure 2. Comparing simulation results in wind turbine performance with the power control mode to that with the rotor speed control mode in (a) energy output and (b) smoothing function"
► Ada bahasa Indonesia atau bahasa asing lainnya yang bukan bahasa Inggris (dan bukan merupakan variabel pemrograman) kecuali sudah disebutkan/dijelaskan maknanya sebelumnya [CEK PER KASUS!]
Please translate this into English; however, if this should be in English, please provide the English translation so that our readers can understand your idea completely.
► Figure dengan keterangan/legenda berwarna dan tidak dibedakan berdasarkan pola/pattern
According to our new policy, graphs or charts with legends are required to be in black and white format. Distinguish the data series using patterns instead of colors.
► Pada diagram Kartesius, tidak ada keterangan axis x dan/atau y
Please complete the graph by adding the axis title (both vertical and horizontal axis must have a label)
+--------+
| SITASI |
+--------+
► Sitasi tidak urut
Please number the citations consecutively based on the order of appearance.
Number the citations consecutively according to the first mention of each source in the text (sequential order). First citation in your text is written [1], second citation is written [2], third citaion is written [3], etc.
► Sitasi tidak urut, tidak dimulai dari no 1
Please number the citations consecutively based on the order of appearance, start at 1.
► Sitasi kelompatan (cuma 1-2 kasus, bukan banyak)
Please number your citation in consecutive order. After [16], this should be [17]. (Don’t forget to adjust the other citations' numbering.)
► Nama di sitasi tidak sinkron dengan nama di reference pada nomor yang sama
The authors' name is not the same with the authors in ref. [1]. Please check again.
+----------+
| EQUATION |
+----------+
► Tidak terbaca
This equation (7) is blur/unclear/too small that we cannot identify the character(s)/symbol(s).
► Equation dalam bentuk gambar, bukan pakai MathType atau Equation Editor yang ada di Word (intinya tidak bisa diedit)
Please convert the equation into the editable format (use MathType or the embedded Equation Editor by Ms Word)
+----------+
| FOOTNOTE |
+----------+
► Berupa kalimat penjelasan/deskriptif
Footnote is not recognized in our journal. Please modify this into a paragraph.
► Berupa sumber
Footnote is not recognized in our journal. Please simply make it into a citation.
► Kombinasi keduanya/tidak tahu termasuk yg mana
Footnote is not recognized in our journal. Please modify this into a paragraph or simply make it into a citation.
+------------+
| CONCLUSION |
+------------+
► Ada sitasi
There should be no citation in the Conclusion, please remove it or move it into the previous section(s).
► Ada figure
There should be no figure in the Conclusion, please remove it or move it into the previous section(s).
► Ada table
There should be no table in the Conclusion, please remove it or move it into the previous section(s).
► Kurang dari 3 kalimat (hanya ada 1 paragraf tsb)
Please elaborate the paragraph into min. 3 sentences.
+-----------+
| REFERENCE |
+-----------+
► Format acak-acakan, tidak pakai IEEE style (cek juga kesalahan lain; kalau tidak ada komentar lainnya, abaikan)
"Please use IEEE style for references consistently. Learn more: https://ieeeauthorcenter.ieee.org/wp-content/uploads/IEEE-Reference-Guide.pdf
Use references manager like Mendeley to assist you."
► Informasi sumber tidak lengkap (tidak ada judul paper, tidak ada nama jurnal, dll)
"Please provide the complete information of this source. Learn more: https://ieeeauthorcenter.ieee.org/wp-content/uploads/IEEE-Reference-Guide.pdf
Use references manager like Mendeley to assist you."
► Tidak ada DOI-nya (tidak wajib)
Please provide the DOIs of the references (if any)
► Self citation Journal lebih dari 20%
Too many self-journal citations: 30 of 100 (KONDISIONAL) or 30%. Please reduce it into max. 20%.
► Self citation Author lebih dari 20%
Too many self citations: 30 of 100 (KONDISIONAL) or 30%. Please reduce it into max. 20%.
► Minimal jumlah ref adalah 25.
The min. number of references required is 25. Please add … more.
► Cek apa ada ref yang dobel (kalau yg dobel dihapus, reference masih 25 atau lebih)
Duplicated references. Same as [6]. Change/delete one.
► Cek apa ada ref yang dobel (kalau yg dobel dihapus, reference jadi kurang dari 25)
Duplicated references. Same as [6]. Change/delete one. (Please make sure that your paper still have at least 25 references)
► Ada ref. yang belum disitasi di body-text
This reference is not cited in the article yet; please cite it.
► Referensi terlihat disusun menggunakan Mendeley atau ref. manager lainnya
Please attach the BibTeX/RIS file of the references.
► Ref. berbahasa lokal (terkhusus bhs Indonesia) --> Untuk case khusus, tanyakan PJ/koor/di grup tim
We do not appreciate a local journal with local language as a reference. We strongly recommend you change this reference into another one from an international journal that uses English.
► Ref. TERPAKSA menggunakan bhs lokal, dan menggunakan huruf selain huruf latin
Please provide the English translation of this title. Write it in the form: [Translation] (in [the original language's name]: [the title in its original language]
► Ref. dari web dan tidak bisa diakses
The link is not accessible. Please change this reference to the reliable source, such as: journals or proceedings.
► Ref. dari web (selain dataset)
Avoid using webpages as references unless it is a dataset. Please use journal articles or proceedings.
► Ref. dari web (trusted) dan tidak ada tanggal akses
Please provide the accessed date.
+-----------+
| BIOGRAPHY |
+-----------+
► Foto blur
The photo is blurry. Please enhance into a good quality.
► Ada/semua author tidak melampirkan foto
Please provide the author's photo.
► Hanya berupa 1 kalimat singkat
Please elaborate the biographies into min. 3 sentences.
► Berupa list (bukan paragraf)
Please elaborate the biographies into sentences in a single paragraph.
► Belum ada medsos author (email sudah ada)
Please provide the links of the researchers social media accounts of the authors as complete as possible: Scopus, ORCID (required), Google Scholar, Publons (if any).
► Belum ada medsos author (email belum ada)
Please provide all authors' email addresses and their links of the researchers social media accounts as complete as possible: Scopus, ORCID (required), Google Scholar, Publons (if any).
► Email belum ada (sosmed lengkap)
Please provide all authors' email addresses.