Published by Prescience. We offer the products recommended here.
Here's a worked comparison for a team with typical startup ages plus two senior hires. Everyone is on single coverage to keep it readable.
Illustrative monthly premiums and contributions, not quotes; group premium $777, employer pays 80%, ICHRA premium-only allowance $600 (Age)
25: Benchmark silver premium $491 · ICHRA pays $491 · Employee pays on ICHRA $0 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
28: Benchmark silver premium $532 · ICHRA pays $532 · Employee pays on ICHRA $0 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
32: Benchmark silver premium $579 · ICHRA pays $579 · Employee pays on ICHRA $0 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
35: Benchmark silver premium $598 · ICHRA pays $598 · Employee pays on ICHRA $0 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
41: Benchmark silver premium $637 · ICHRA pays $600 · Employee pays on ICHRA $37 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
47: Benchmark silver premium $734 · ICHRA pays $600 · Employee pays on ICHRA $134 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
55: Benchmark silver premium $1,091 · ICHRA pays $600 · Employee pays on ICHRA $491 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
62: Benchmark silver premium $1,405 · ICHRA pays $600 · Employee pays on ICHRA $805 · Employee pays on group plan $155.40
Illustrative only. The individual premiums in the table are assumed inputs, not current quotes or calculated national age-curve rates. The group premium is exactly $777 per employee monthly, with an 80% employer contribution. Assume all eight employees enroll, an ICHRA limited to premiums, and hypothetical administration of $45 per enrollee plus $50 monthly. No premium tax credits or other fees are included. A broader ICHRA may reimburse eligible nonpremium expenses, so unused premium allowance need not equal unused total benefits.
Group employer contribution: 8 × $621.60: $4,972.80
Group employee contributions: 8 × $155.40: $1,243.20
ICHRA premiums reimbursed: $491 + $532 + $579 + $598 + 4 × $600: $4,600
Assumed ICHRA administration: 8 × $45 + $50: $410
ICHRA employer total: $5,010
ICHRA employee premium payments: $37 + $134 + $491 + $805: $1,467
In these assumptions, ICHRA costs the employer $37.20 more monthly. The four youngest employees pay no premium, while the two oldest together pay $1,296. That distribution is not inevitable: allowances and local quotes can change it. Compare medical costs and tax treatment separately before deciding. The example does not establish that either option has a better network or lower deductible.
An ICHRA is "affordable" if the employee's cost for the lowest-cost silver self-only plan in their area, minus the monthly allowance, is no more than 9.96% of household income in 2026 (up from 9.02% in 2025). It matters in two ways:
For employees: if the offer is affordable, they can't get a premium tax credit. If it's unaffordable, they can opt out of the ICHRA and claim a credit if they're otherwise eligible.
For employers with 50+ full-time equivalents: an unaffordable offer can trigger an employer mandate penalty for each full-time employee who gets a credit ($5,010 per affected employee in 2026). Employer penalty analysis may use applicable affordability safe harbors. Confirm the permitted location, age and look-back methodology with the administrator; it is separate from the employee’s household-income tax-credit test.
Illustrative. A 62-year-old single employee. Assumes her lowest-cost silver plan is $1,300 a month and her benchmark silver plan is $1,405. 2026 marketplace credits use the 2025 poverty line of $15,650 for one person. Assume the contiguous-state guideline, no other disqualifying coverage or tax circumstance, and eligibility for the general 2026 credit rules.
Lowest-cost silver minus allowance: $1,300 − $600 = $700
At $90,000 income: 9.96% ÷ 12: $747, so the offer is affordable; no tax credit
At $60,000 income: 9.96% ÷ 12: $498, so the offer is unaffordable
$60,000 is about 383% of the poverty line: Potentially eligible if she opts out and meets all other credit requirements
Her benchmark silver cost with the credit: About $498 a month instead of $805 on the ICHRA
At $60,000 she saves about $307 a month by declining the ICHRA and taking the tax credit; at $90,000 that assumed benchmark costs $805 after the allowance, although she can compare other policies. Employees need this explained one by one, which is part of why ICHRA enrollment takes more work than a group plan.
People in treatment. Someone mid-chemotherapy or pregnant may lose their doctors if the local individual plans are HMOs or EPOs that exclude them. Check their providers before you set the date.
Employees in several states. ICHRA handles this well; premiums differ by rating area, and you can set allowances by rating area as a class.
Families. Allowances can rise with dependents, but family individual premiums climb fast. Price your largest family separately.
Medicare: ICHRA can integrate with Medicare Part A and Part B together, or Part C, under the rules. Medicare secondary payer and nondiscrimination requirements still need review. Do not move older employees into a Medicare-only arrangement merely to shift employer liability.
People on COBRA from your old plan. Ask your carrier and counsel what happens to their coverage when the group plan ends.
Switching mid-year. Possible, but deductible credit should not be assumed on new individual plans, and you must still give employees adequate notice.
Recruiting. Candidates compare plans. "You get $600 to buy your own plan" reads differently from "PPO, we pay 80%".